Two arrested in theft of cars, electronics featured on ‘Washington’s Most Wanted’

Kristopher Nickerson and Ericka Nitz were both arrested on Tuesday. Bainbridge Island Police Department

Kristopher Nickerson and Ericka Nitz were both arrested on Tuesday. Bainbridge Island Police Department

PORT HADLOCK — Two people arrested near Old Tarboo Lake Road in the Qullcene area with a cache of stolen property that included cars and electronics were the topic of a recent Washington’s Most Wanted TV episode.

Kristofer T. Nickerson, 32, of unincorporated Kitsap County and Ericka L. Nitz, 25, of Bainbridge Island remained in the Jefferson County jail in Port Hadlock on Wednesday after they were arrested Tuesday.

Jefferson County Sheriff Joe Nole has said the arrest broke up a theft ring.

The Washington’s Most Wanted segment, taped on Bainbridge Island on Sept. 14, aired that day and Sept. 24, according to David Rose, its executive producer and host for Q13 Fox News of Seattle.

The show, which Rose said has led to the capture of 571 fugitives since 2008, gets requests for help from local police departments.

“Bainbridge Island police are asking for the public’s help finding a couple on the run,” the TV show’s narrator said. “Kristopher Nickerson and Ericka Nitz have extensive criminal histories.”

“’Last weekend we believe there was a car prowl allegedly committed by them. The credit cards that were taken by them were used illegally here on the island,’ Bainbridge Police Chief Matthew Hamner said.

“Hamner said he is especially concerned about the public’s safety because Nickerson has a history of carrying and using guns during crimes. Both are wanted by the state Department of Corrections and have no-bail warrants.

“Nickerson also has a warrant for arrest in Thurston County for theft.”

Rural hideout

But the TV show had nothing to do with what lead to their arrests in a rural area of Jefferson County.

The two were found on a spur off Old Tarboo Lake Road after security guards employed by Pacific Mountain Products, which leases the land from Pope Resources, reported an illegal encampment.

Authorities said they made a hideout in the remote area after drilling through locks on gated access roads to gain entry.

When deputies arrived, Nickerson ran and was captured, while Nitz was taken into custody without incident, Nole said.

On site was a trailer that was reported stolen from a recreational-vehicle lot in Silverdale and a Toyota Tacoma truck that was stolen from Port Orchard, deputies said.

A third vehicle, a Honda, was not stolen, deputies said, but they suspect it was involved in the Friday theft from the Port Townsend Safeway of a maroon Mazda Protege, which is still missing.

“We can only speculate where the Mazda is at right now,” said Port Townsend Police Officer Luke Bogues on Wednesday.

Recovered goods include two motor vehicles along with several iPads, iPods and cellphones, Nole said, adding that by Wednesday, several of the items had been traced to a break-in on Mount Walker.

In addition to the property officials believe was stolen in Jefferson County, the two are wanted in the investigation into the Sept. 13 car prowl in Bainbridge Island and the arrest warrant on theft in Thurston County.

Nickerson is being held in Jefferson County for investigation of second-degree theft-taking of a motor vehicle, criminal impersonation, making false or misleading statements to a public servant, first-degree possession of stolen property and a probation/supervision violation. Bail has been set at $75,000.

Nitz is being held for investigation of a controlled substance violation, second-degree theft-taking of a motor vehicle, first-degree possession of stolen property, third-degree possession of stolen property and making false/misleading statements to a public servant. Bail has been set at $10,000.

Nickerson has a tattoo of the cartoon character, Felix the Cat, holding a knife on his left arm and some writing on the right side of his neck. Both he and Nitz are Bainbridge Island natives.

________

Jefferson County Reporter Charlie Bermant can be reached at 360-385-2335 or at charlie.bermant@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Aspen Mason-Kleeb, left, and Satria McKnight, both of Port Townsend and members of Popup Movement in Port Hadlock, a circus school owned by Sadie La Donna, right, rehearse a routine they were set to perform Wednesday in a performance as part of the First Night event put on by the Production Alliance. Watching is Julia Franz, seated, a rigger for the company. (Steve Mullensky/ for Peninsula Daily News)
First Night

Aspen Mason-Kleeb, left, and Satria McKnight, both of Port Townsend and members… Continue reading

Free days added for national parks

Non-U.S. residents to pay more for visiting

About 150 to 200 people jumped into 49-degree water at Hollywood Beach on Jan. 1, 2025, for the 37th annual Polar Bear Dip. The air temperature was about 39 degrees, so it was a short, brisk dip that they did three times. There was a beach fire to warm the dippers afterward as well as two portable saunas in the parking lot. The event was sponsored by Volunteer Hospice of Clallam County under the leadership of organizer Dan Welden. Hot drinks, tasty muffins and a certificate for participants were available. (Dave Logan/for Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Polar Plunge set for Hollywood Beach

Event raises funds for Volunteer Hospice of Clallam County

Five elected to Waterfront District board

Five people have been elected to three-year terms on… Continue reading

Holiday lights reflect off the water at Boat Haven in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Holiday reflections

Holiday lights reflect off the water at Boat Haven in Port Angeles.… Continue reading

Clallam extends public defense

Contract agreement is through February

Celebration of life set Super Bowl Sunday

Messages continue to arrive for John Nutter

Committee members sought for ‘For’ and ‘Against’ statements

The Clallam County commissioners are seeking county residents to… Continue reading

Search and rescue teams locate deceased man

A deceased man was located following search and rescue… Continue reading

Anita La Salle, kneeling in the center, poses with her family of son, daughters, son-in-law and grandkids, all from Port Townsend, after spending Saturday on a scavenger hunt and celebrating a reunion to welcome a long-lost family member who hasn’t been seen in more than 50 years. The hunt originated at the Port Townsend Goodwill, where they each had to buy matching clothes, and took them to various venues around Port Townsend culminating at the anchor at Fort Worden State Park. This is the first Christmas they have all been together as a family. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Family reunion

Anita La Salle, kneeling in the center, poses with her family of… Continue reading

Clallam seeking to extend contracts

Pacts would impact criminal justice in Port Angeles, Sequim

John Nutter.
Olympic Medical Center board commissioner dies at age 54

Nutter, police officer of year in 2010, also worked for hospital, port