Hearing set anew for Wednesday in Port Angeles murder, kidnapping case

Gary Borneman ()

Gary Borneman ()

PORT ANGELES — A plea deal for accused murderer Gary Borneman is still on the table, and a hearing on the matter is scheduled for Wednesday.

Borneman, 40, is charged with first-degree premeditated murder, first-degree kidnapping and five other charges related to the October shooting death of Jerry Howell and alleged kidnapping of Rebecca Messinger.

Borneman has pleaded not guilty to first-degree premeditated murder, first-degree kidnapping domestic violence, first-degree burglary, second-degree assault with a deadly weapon, unlawful imprisonment domestic violence, violation of a domestic violence protection order and second-degree unlawful possession of a firearm.

Port Angeles police allege that Borneman kidnapped Messinger at gunpoint and shot Howell to death at a Port Angeles residence Oct. 7.

Police said Borneman tied Messinger to the driver’s seat of her vehicle, ordered her to drive to her West 11th Street residence and shot Howell with a 22.-caliber pistol.

Messinger, who is described in court papers as Borneman’s ex-girlfriend, escaped from the vehicle and called 9-1-1 as she hid in bushes behind the house she shared with Howell.

Borneman was treated at Harborview Medical Center in Seattle for injuries suffered in a close-quarters gunfight with Howell, who was 40.

Several court hearings have been rescheduled in recent weeks to allow Borneman more time to consult with defense attorney John Hayden.

A hearing that was scheduled for Thursday was reset because Hayden was unavailable.

“He is out of town today. Therefore, I can’t really proceed with it,” defense attorney Loren Oakley told Clallam County Superior Court Judge Christopher Melly.

Noting that Hayden’s absence was expected, Melly reset the hearing for 9 a.m. Wednesday.

“I’m a little disturbed that all we’re doing is putting it over again,” Melly said.

“We could have done that last week.”

Clallam County Chief Criminal Deputy Prosecuting Attorney John Troberg would not discuss the plea offer in a Thursday interview.

“I don’t want to talk about the offer while the case is still pending,” he said.

Several letters have been filed with the court asking Melly to reject a plea offer.

First-degree murder, kidnapping and burglary are each Class A felonies punishable by a maximum of life in prison and a $50,000 fine.

Firearm enhancements were added to Borneman’s charges.

He is being held in the Clallam County jail on $50,000 bond.

More in News

Aspen Mason-Kleeb, left, and Satria McKnight, both of Port Townsend and members of Popup Movement in Port Hadlock, a circus school owned by Sadie La Donna, right, rehearse a routine they were set to perform Wednesday in a performance as part of the First Night event put on by the Production Alliance. Watching is Julia Franz, seated, a rigger for the company. (Steve Mullensky/ for Peninsula Daily News)
First Night

Aspen Mason-Kleeb, left, and Satria McKnight, both of Port Townsend and members… Continue reading

Free days added for national parks

Non-U.S. residents to pay more for visiting

About 150 to 200 people jumped into 49-degree water at Hollywood Beach on Jan. 1, 2025, for the 37th annual Polar Bear Dip. The air temperature was about 39 degrees, so it was a short, brisk dip that they did three times. There was a beach fire to warm the dippers afterward as well as two portable saunas in the parking lot. The event was sponsored by Volunteer Hospice of Clallam County under the leadership of organizer Dan Welden. Hot drinks, tasty muffins and a certificate for participants were available. (Dave Logan/for Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Polar Plunge set for Hollywood Beach

Event raises funds for Volunteer Hospice of Clallam County

Five elected to Waterfront District board

Five people have been elected to three-year terms on… Continue reading

Holiday lights reflect off the water at Boat Haven in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Holiday reflections

Holiday lights reflect off the water at Boat Haven in Port Angeles.… Continue reading

Clallam extends public defense

Contract agreement is through February

Celebration of life set Super Bowl Sunday

Messages continue to arrive for John Nutter

Committee members sought for ‘For’ and ‘Against’ statements

The Clallam County commissioners are seeking county residents to… Continue reading

Search and rescue teams locate deceased man

A deceased man was located following search and rescue… Continue reading

Anita La Salle, kneeling in the center, poses with her family of son, daughters, son-in-law and grandkids, all from Port Townsend, after spending Saturday on a scavenger hunt and celebrating a reunion to welcome a long-lost family member who hasn’t been seen in more than 50 years. The hunt originated at the Port Townsend Goodwill, where they each had to buy matching clothes, and took them to various venues around Port Townsend culminating at the anchor at Fort Worden State Park. This is the first Christmas they have all been together as a family. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Family reunion

Anita La Salle, kneeling in the center, poses with her family of… Continue reading

Clallam seeking to extend contracts

Pacts would impact criminal justice in Port Angeles, Sequim

John Nutter.
Olympic Medical Center board commissioner dies at age 54

Nutter, police officer of year in 2010, also worked for hospital, port