Demolition plans affecting two 19th century Port Townsend houses prompt fears of losing historic character

PORT TOWNSEND — Demolition permits filed for two older homes on Fillmore Street have stirred concerns about the city losing its historic flavor.

The Jefferson County Historical Society and several residents have written letters to the city’s Development Services Department protesting a partial demolition permit filed for 535 Fillmore, which was built about 1860, and for a full demolition permit filed for 308 Fillmore St., which was built around 1888.

“I saw those two notices being posted, and I realized I was seeing the footprint of our community changing,” said Linda Maguire, one resident who wrote a letter.

“It’s another change creeping in through the door.”

It isn’t that the permits wouldn’t be legal, said Bill Tennent, director of the Jefferson County Historical Society.

“In this community, the only buildings that are protected are the commercial buildings, and not residential buildings,” Tennent said.

But if too many homes in the district are altered or destroyed, there is a chance that Port Townsend’s national historic district classification will be lost, he said.

Tennent said that while two homes would not change the historical classification, the razing of old buildings takes its toll on the town.

“Once that is gone, it’s gone. We don’t get it back,” he said.

The society drafted two letters to John McDonagh, city development services department planner, registering its concerns.

Letters giving public comment, which were due by Tuesday, and plans for demolition will be weighed against the city’s moratorium on razing historic buildings.

More in News

Fire protection may impact insurance rates

New protection class considers nuanced data

The view looking south from Hurricane Ridge, where variable winter weather has limited snow coverage and contributed to pauses in snow sports operations in recent weeks. (Washington’s National Park Fund)
Lack of snow has impact at Hurricane Ridge

Water equivalent well below average for February

Port Angeles secures grant to aid in salmon recovery

State Department of Commerce to provide city with $109,000

Tickets still available for United Way of Clallam County fundraiser

Pajamas are encouraged, teddy bears are optional and comfort… Continue reading

Interviews set for hospital board

At least seven candidates up for commissioner seat

Port Angeles asks for fee to cover lodging tax contracts

Resolution sent to committee for administrative costs

Climate action group is guiding reduction goals

Reduced emmissions require reduced transportation footprint

County, Port Angeles to rebid public safety building

Three bids rejected due to issue with electrical contractor

Aliya Gillet, the 2025 Clallam County Fair queen, crowns Keira Headrick as the 2026 queen during a ceremony on Saturday at the Clallam County Fairgrounds. At left is princess Julianna Getzin and at right is princess Jasmine Green. The other princesses, not pictured, are Makenzie Taylor, Molly Beeman and Tish Hamilton. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Clallam County royalty crowned for annual fair

Silent auction raises funds for scholarships

Port Angeles Community Award recipients gather after Saturday night’s annual awards gala. From left, they are Frances Charles, Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe, Organization of the Year; Kyla Magner, Country Aire, Business of the Year; Amy Burghart and Doug Burghart, Mighty Pine Brewing, Emerging Business of the Year; Rick Ross, Educator of the Year; Kayla Fairchild, Young Leader of the Year; John Fox, Citizen of the Year. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
Community leaders honored at annual awards banquet

Fox named Citizen of Year for support of athletic events

Clallam County commissioners consider options for Owens

Supporters advocate for late state justice

Respiratory viruses are rising on the Peninsula

Health officer attributes increase to mutation of type of flu in circulation