Prosecutor faces discrimination damages claim

PORT ANGELES — Four people claiming age and disability discrimination in the workplace have filed a claim seeking an estimated $1 million in damages each from the Clallam County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office.

The four — two former employees in the office, one present employee and the daughter of a former employee who died in 2007 — filed a claim with the county Auditor’s Office on Sept. 28, said attorney Richard Creatura of the Gordon, Thomas, Honeywell, Malanca, Peterson and Daheim LLP law firm in Tacoma.

The claimants are Carol Case, deputy prosecuting attorney; Elain Sundt, former office administrator; Kathy Nielsen, former deputy prosecuting attorney; Hollie Hutton, who is representing Robin Porter, a former legal assistant who died last year.

Hutton is Porter’s daughter.

The claimants allege that county Prosecuting Attorney Deb Kelly and Mark Nichols, chief deputy prosecuting attorney, as well as other staff, discriminated against them based on their “age and/or disability,” beginning in 2006.

The claim for damages document also says that the claimants “have been treated in a hostile, demeaning and condescending manner” due to their age and/or disability, which created a hostile working environment.

Damages are estimated at $1 million each, the claim says.

‘No harassment’

The county hired an outside investigator after the allegations were first aired, the Prosecuting Attorney’s Office said in a written statement.

The investigator, who was not identified, “found no harassment, hostile work environment or discrimination,” the statement said.

Nichols had no further comment on Wednesday, and said that the Prosecuting Attorney’s Office has a policy against “discussing matters of focus of pending litigation.”

The claim can’t be filed with Clallam County Superior Court until 60 days after it was filed with the Auditor’s Office, Creatura said.

Stephanie Bloomfield of the Tacoma law office also is representing the claimants.

Creatura said the claimants are all over 40 years of age, which put them under the protection of state laws against age discrimination.

He wouldn’t comment on who is claiming discrimination based on disability or what the disability is.

Younger staff

Creatura said the claimants allege that Kelly and Nichols both said that the office needed a younger and more energetic staff, and reassigned older employees into positions that were “untenable.”

“They found ways to discriminate and harass those that had been in the [Prosecuting Attorney’s Office] for a number of years,” he said.

Creatura said a couple of the claimants say they have had adverse health and mental affects from the alleged mistreatment.

More in News

Workers from Van Ness Construction in Port Hadlock, one holding a grade rod with a laser pointer, left, and another driving the backhoe, scrape dirt for a new sidewalk of civic improvements at Walker and Washington streets in Port Townsend on Thursday. The sidewalks will be poured in early February and extend down the hill on Washington Street and along Walker Street next to the pickle ball courts. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Sidewalk setup

Workers from Van Ness Construction in Port Hadlock, one holding a grade… Continue reading

The first graduating cohort of EDC Team Jefferson's business advisors training stands with certificates. From left to right are George Sawyer, Kit Malone, Devin Rodriguez, Charlotte Richardson and Justine Wagner. Standing is the EDC's Executive Director David Bailiff. Sitting is the EDC's Program and Finance Manager Phoebe Reid and course instructor Ray Sparrowe.
Five business advisors graduate

Cohort studied accounting, marketing in 40-week program

Victoria Helwick.
Seaview Academy becoming popular option for online K-12 education

Port Angeles School District has about 375 students enrolled in program

x
Home Fund contributes to OMC cancer center

Funding supports patient navigator program’s effort to remove barriers

April Messenger, left, and Olympic National Park Ranger Chris Erickson share ideas on Wednesday during a listening session at Field Arts & Events Hall in Port Angeles. Nearly 150 people provided feedback about a new Hurricane Ridge Lodge project following the 2023 fire that destroyed the original structure. Nine easels were set up with questions and notes were provided for people to express their goals for a new lodge. The earliest construction can begin is in 2028, and it would take two to three years to complete, weather permitting. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Listening post

April Messenger, left, and Olympic National Park Ranger Chris Erickson share ideas… Continue reading

Port of Port Townsend to pursue grant for airport

Funds aimed to spur small industrial work

Future of Oceans program to focus on puffins

Expert spent 37 years studying seabirds in Alaska

The city of Port Angeles has put out a request for proposals for the sale of the historic fire hall at 215 S. Lincoln St. (City of Port Angeles)
Port Angeles is seeking a buyer for fire hall, prioritizes affordable housing

Historic preservation also noted for city’s landmark property

A standup paddle boarder and his dog take advantage of mild temperatures and calm waters on Tuesday to go for a ride on Port Townsend Bay. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Going for a ride

A standup paddle boarder and his dog take advantage of mild temperatures… Continue reading

Port of Port Angeles seeking design team

Building intended for aerospace production

Olympic National Park Superintendent Sula Jacobs answers questions Wednesday during the Port Angeles Chamber of Commerce luncheon at the Red Lion Inn. (Emily Hanson/Peninsula Daily News)
Superintendent says national park had more than 3.6M visitors in ’25

Construction projects to affect amenities in ONP this summer