One week later, Port Angeles pizzeria free of ‘Idol’ voting phone calls

PORT ANGELES — After a night devoid of misdialed “American Idol” calls to Gordy’s Pizza & Pasta, owner Randy Sexton said Thursday that he may create an “Idol”-themed pizza based on his customers’ votes.

It might be named “Port Angeles Idol” pizza, Sexton suggested.

“It would take a spin on ‘American Idol.’

“America votes for its favorite artist, so Port Angeles gets to vote for its favorite pizza” is how Sexton envisions it.

Wednesday night, exactly a week after being flooded with a phone-clogging portion of the 71 million votes cast for Fox TV’s “American Idol” contestants, it was business as usual at his 1123 E. First St. restaurant that features other Italian-style food in addition to pizza.

The cause of the snafu, he later learned: two misdialed digits.

Voters were told to call 855-443-6411.

Instead, enough voters called the restaurant’s unused — and now disconnected — line at 855-445-6511 to create a constant “ring, ring, ring, ring, ring,” as he put it last week, of “American Idol” votes.

Sexton said he did not know he had the 855-number and, anyway, has no need for a line for out-of-state callers.

“Obviously, no entity wants this to happen again,” he said.

Since the snafu, Sexton has received out-of-state requests for his menu and said he was hopeful the episode had a positive impact on Port Angeles.

A Peninsula Daily News report on the snafu was shared by The Associated Press with media outlets worldwide.

“I can only imagine that if you wanted to know more, you’re going to pop on the website to find out and in one way or . . . find out more about Port Angeles and Gordy’s Pizza,” Sexton said.

Customers could be asked to submit their favorite ideas for pizzas and then vote on them via email through the restaurant’s “Gordy’s Gang” program, with the top choice put on the menu as a special.

“I’m looking for input on how this can be done to engage Port Angeles in continuation of the phenomenon that happened,” Sexton said.

“We thank the phenomenon for happening,” Sexton said.

The past week or so has been a roller-coaster, he added.

“I’m not saying it should end anytime soon,” he said.

________

Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 5060, or at pgottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

About 100 people dipped three times into the water during the 38th annual Polar Bear Dip on Thursday at Hollywood Beach in downtown Port Angeles. The air and water temperature were both in the low 40s. Each received a certificate for participating, and proceeds benefitted Volunteer Hospice of Clallam County. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Ringing in the new year

About 100 people dipped three times into the water during the 38th… Continue reading

A new mural, painted by Larry White, has been installed on the east side of BarHop in downtown Port Angeles. (Sam Grello/Port Angeles Waterfront District)
New mural painted as part of initiative

Artist chooses orca on BarHop building

Michael Calvin Mills’ short story collection, “The Caged Man,” was released in December. (Elijah Sussman/Peninsula Daily News)
Author’s work published after a long wait

Stories set in Spain, Costa Rica, Colombia

x
Home Fund contributes to continuing education

United Way funds 11 students for job training at Peninsula College

EYE ON THE PENINSULA: Boards to set 2026 legislative priorities

Meetings across the North Olympic Peninsula

Aspen Mason-Kleeb, left, and Satria McKnight, both of Port Townsend and members of Popup Movement in Port Hadlock, a circus school owned by Sadie La Donna, right, rehearse a routine they were set to perform Wednesday in a performance as part of the First Night event put on by the Production Alliance. Watching is Julia Franz, seated, a rigger for the company. (Steve Mullensky/ for Peninsula Daily News)
First Night

Aspen Mason-Kleeb, left, and Satria McKnight, both of Port Townsend and members… Continue reading

Free days added for national parks

Non-U.S. residents to pay more for visiting

About 150 to 200 people jumped into 49-degree water at Hollywood Beach on Jan. 1, 2025, for the 37th annual Polar Bear Dip. The air temperature was about 39 degrees, so it was a short, brisk dip that they did three times. There was a beach fire to warm the dippers afterward as well as two portable saunas in the parking lot. The event was sponsored by Volunteer Hospice of Clallam County under the leadership of organizer Dan Welden. Hot drinks, tasty muffins and a certificate for participants were available. (Dave Logan/for Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Polar Plunge set for Hollywood Beach

Event raises funds for Volunteer Hospice of Clallam County

Five elected to Waterfront District board

Five people have been elected to three-year terms on… Continue reading

Holiday lights reflect off the water at Boat Haven in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Holiday reflections

Holiday lights reflect off the water at Boat Haven in Port Angeles.… Continue reading

Clallam extends public defense

Contract agreement is through February

Celebration of life set Super Bowl Sunday

Messages continue to arrive for John Nutter