Double-murder trial in jury’s hands; cost of proceedings adds up for Jefferson County

PORT TOWNSEND — Jefferson County had paid $282,202 in expenses related to the case of double-murder defendant Michael J. Pierce as of Dec. 31, the county Auditor’s Office said Thursday — the first day of jury deliberations on whether Pierce should spend the rest of his life in prison.

The Superior Court jury, which did not reach at verdict by 4:30 p.m., will reconvene at 9 a.m. today at the county Courthouse, 1820 Jefferson St., Port Townsend.

The members of the nine-woman, three-man panel will go home for the weekend if they do not reach a verdict today, Judge Craddock Verser told jury members in a courtroom that included more than two dozen spectators.

In addition to two counts of first-degree murder, Pierce also is charged with arson, burglary, theft and unlawful possession of a firearm related to the shooting deaths of Patrick Yarr, 60, and his wife, Janice, 57, at their Boulton Farm Road home north of Lake Leland on March 18, 2009.

Pierce’s trial began March 11 and included testimony from 44 witnesses, including several forensics experts, before concluding Wednesday.

The investigation included the participation of the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco Firearms and Explosives, the FBI and the State Patrol crime lab.

County Prosecuting Attorney Juelie Dalzell said the county is expecting help from the state Legislature to defray the cost of expert witnesses and other trial expenses — or else there could be layoffs.

The state Legislature has approved a $190,000 expenditure for that purpose, but Dalzell is worried it won’t survive legislative budget-cutting that lawmakers are now engaged in to fill a $2.8 billion budget gap.

If the money doesn’t come through, at least one person will be laid off at the Jefferson County Courthouse she said.

“There will be layoffs without getting that amount from the state,” Dalzell said.

“I can’t see how we can find the money without laying somebody off or getting more grant money to make up for it, and I am applying for grants like crazy,” she added.

“It is a lot of money, but that’s the price for justice.”

County Auditor Donna Eldridge said a complete list of expenditures related to the Pierce case was not available Thursday because they had not been coded into the county’s accounting system.

But she felt confident that $282,202 had been spent through Dec. 31.

Expenses related to the Pierce case include $42,807 for attorney services to the law firm of Walsh & Larranaga, a death-penalty-qualified law firm.

The prosecution is seeking life in prison for Pierce, not the death penalty.

Dalzell refused to say why her office did not seek the death penalty until after the jury reaches a verdict.

Richard Davies, director of Jefferson Associated Counsel, which holds the county’s public defender contract, said the decision came soon after DNA results came back “on all sorts of stuff” showing no link between Pierce and the Yarrs or to Pierce and the Yarrs’ residence.

Dalzell denied the DNA results affected her office’s decision but would not comment further.

Davies’ firm received $50,414 for public defender services through Dec. 31, according to the Auditor’s Office.

Specific public defender expenses have been sealed under court order issued by Verser that allows disclosure of aggregate expenditure totals.

The sealed documents include invoices and time sheets.

“There’s an order sealing the records so that the defense is not exposed to public scrutiny until after the case is completed,” Davies said Thursday.

Verser reviews and approves defense expenditures, Davies said.

“The court is the gatekeeper of public funding in situations like this.”

Expenses through Dec. 31 also include $14,128 in prosecuting attorney costs.

“Everyone is working on this case,” Dalzell said, noting four attorneys and four legal assistants have kept track of all hours related to the Pierce case.

Extraordinary security surrounded the trial. Four deputies were in the courtroom at all times, including two stationed within about 10 feet of Pierce.

Sheriff’s Office costs related to the case were listed at $15,438.

________

Senior Staff writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-417-3536 or at paul.gottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Mark Gregson.
Interim hospital CEO praises partnership, legacy

Gregson says goal is to solidify pact with UW Medicine in coming months

Jefferson County Auditor Brenda Huntingford, right, watches as clerk Ronnie Swafford loads a stack of ballots that were delivered from the post office on Tuesday into a machine that checks for signatures. The special election has measures affecting the Port Townsend and Brinnon school districts as well as East Jefferson Fire Rescue. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Jefferson County voters supporting school district measures, fire lid lifts

Port Townsend approving 20-year, $99.25 million construction bond

Port of Port Townsend Harbormaster Kristian Ferrero, right, watches as a crew from Seattle Global Diving and Salvage work to remove a derelict catamaran that was stuck in the sand for weeks on a beach at the Water Front Inn on Washington Street in Port Townsend. The boat had been sunk off of Indian Point for weeks before a series of storms pushed it to this beach last week. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Derelict boat removal

Port of Port Townsend Harbormaster Kristian Ferrero, right, watches as a crew… Continue reading

Rob Birman has served as Centrum’s executive director for 14 years. When the arts nonprofit completes its search for its next leader, Birman will transition into a role focused on capital fundraising and overseeing capital projects for buildings Centrum oversees. (Centrum)
Centrum signs lease to remain at Fort Worden for next 35 years

Executive director will transition into role focused on fundraising

Clallam approves contracts with several agencies

Funding for reimbursement, equipment replacement

Mark and Linda Secord have been named Marrowstone Island Citizens of the Year for 2025.
Secords named Marrowstone Island citizens of year

Mark and Linda Secord have been chosen as Marrowstone… Continue reading

The members of the 2026 Rhody Festival royalty are, from left, Princess Payton Frank, Queen Lorelei Turner and 2025 Queen Taylor Frank. The 2026 queen was crowned by the outgoing queen during a ceremony at Chimacum High School on Saturday. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Rhody coronation

The members of the 2026 Rhody Festival royalty are, from left, Princess… Continue reading

Jefferson considering new site for solid waste

Commissioners direct further exploration

Public feedback still shaping Clallam ordinance on RV usage

Community Development department set to move sections of its proposal

Jen Colmore, Sequim Food Bank’s community engagement coordinator, has been hired as the executive director. She will start in her new role after outgoing director Andra Smith starts as executive director of the Washington Food Coalition later this month. (Sequim Food Bank)
Sequim Food Bank hires new executive director

Sequim organization tabs engagement coordinator

Sara Nicholls, executive director of the Dungeness Valley Health and Wellness Clinic, also known as the Sequim Free Clinic, inspects food items that are free to any patient who needs them. Soroptimist International of Sequim sponsors the food pantry, she said. (Austin James)
Sequim Free Clinic to celebrate 25th year

Volunteer-driven nonprofit will reach quarter-century mark in October

Weekly flight operations scheduled

Field carrier landing practice operations will take place for aircraft… Continue reading