Darold Stenson

Darold Stenson

Double-murder retrial venue change granted; Stenson going to Kitsap County court

PORT ANGELES — A Clallam County judge has ordered a change of venue for the retrial of Darold Stenson, who is accused of two 1993 murders.

Clallam County Superior Court Judge S. Brooke Taylor ruled during a hearing late Thursday.

“After considerable deliberation, I came to the conclusion that it is not only probable, but highly probable, that we could not get an impartial, open-minded jury in Clallam County,” Taylor said.

“Mr. Stenson could not get a fair trial in this county for all the reasons set forth in the opinion, which I don’t need to elaborate on here in court.”

Taylor said he will preside over the trial in Kitsap County.

Jury selection is scheduled to begin on July 8.

After announcing the change of venue, Taylor rendered moot a defense motion to compel the release of achieved material from the now-defunct Peninsula News Network and Northland Cable News and KONP radio.

He also denied a defense motion to order the production of disciplinary and training records of state witnesses.

Stenson, 60, is being held in the Clallam County jail without bail.

He is charged with two counts of first-degree murder for the shooting deaths of his wife and business partner at his exotic bird farm near Sequim.

Stenson served time on death row until separate stays of execution were issued in 2008.

His 1994 conviction was overturned by the state Supreme Court last May and remanded to Clallam County for a new trial.

He is being represented by lead attorney Roger Hunko of Port Orchard, Sherilyn Peterson of Seattle and Blake Kremer of University Place.

Peterson filed a motion to move the trial to King County because of a “consistent barrage of negative media coverage to the small Clallam County population.”

She cited more than 150 articles that have appeared in the Peninsula Daily News and Sequim Gazette over the past 20 years, radio and television news stories, and a 1993 episode of “A Current Affair,” a then-nationally syndicated Fox television newsmagazine that “covered the case in a sensational manner, thrusting this small community into the national limelight.”

Clallam County Prosecuting Attorney Deb Kelly took the death penalty off the table last December, announcing that she would instead seek a life sentence for Stenson.

Peterson filed a supplemental motion for a change of venue in February after Clallam County Sheriff Bill Benedict told KONP Radio that Stenson’s death penalty-qualified defense team was an unnecessary expense to county taxpayers.

More in News

Volunteer Al Oman, right, guides an auger operated by Steve Fink during site preparation for rebuilding the Dream Playground on Wednesday at Erickson Playfield in Port Angeles. A community rebuild is scheduled for May 15-19 to replace portions of the popular playground that were destroyed in an arson fire on Dec. 20. Volunteer signups are available at https://www.padreamplayground.org. The nonprofit Dream Playground Foundation, which organized and orchestrated previous versions of the playground, is also seeking loaner tools with more information available at https://www.signupgenius.com/go/904084DA4AC23A5F85-48241857-dream#/. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Site preparation for playground

Volunteer Al Oman, right, guides an auger operated by Steve Fink during… Continue reading

Hood Canal bridge closures begin Monday

Roundabout work also starts next week

Some water system users face steep price hikes

County commissioners’ letter asks rates to be examined

Reforms making a difference at Fort Worden, PDA director says

Organization moving toward stability; challenges remain

Port Townsend woman in serious condition after wreck

A Port Townsend woman was in serious condition following… Continue reading

Federal law limits marine traffic openings at bridge

The state Department of Transportation reminds mariners that, while its… Continue reading

A new mural at Sequim High School honors 2020 graduate Alissa Lofstrom, who started the mural in 2019 but had to stop due to COVID-19 shutdowns. She died in 2021, but past and current students finished her mural for the Interact Club. (Chelsea Reichner)
Teens put finishing touches on mural to honor student

Teachers, students remember Lofstrom as welcoming, talented, artistic

Palmer to resign from Port Townsend City Council

City to open process for replacement

Roundabouts, timber industry top discussion

Peninsula’s state lawmakers recap session

Welcome center to open at Northwest Maritime Center

The Northwest Maritime Center will celebrate the opening of… Continue reading

St. Joseph’s confirmation class in Sequim brought in more than 35,000 laundry pods through a fundraiser for Serenity House of Clallam County. It was their service project as part of the class. (Morgan Nolan)
Serenity shelter receives 35,000-plus laundry pods from youths

Guests at the shelter at Serenity House of Clallam… Continue reading