Death penalty may come into play in Quilcene double killings

PORT TOWNSEND — The Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office has until Aug. 14 to decide if prosecutors will pursue the death penalty in the murder trial of Michael J. Pierce.

Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Scott Rosekrans filed amended charging documents against Pierce, 34, of Quilcene, who is now facing two counts of aggravated murder in the deaths of Quilcene residents Patrick and Janice Yarr.

Pierce is also charged with six other felony charges in connection with the slayings of the Yarrs and the burning of their Boulton Farm Road home on March 18.

Pierce has pleaded not guilty on all counts and remains in Jefferson County jail in lieu of $250,000 bail.

A conviction on one of the aggravated murder charges carries a minimum sentence of life in prison and a maximum of the death penalty.

If the Prosecuting Attorney’s Office does not pursue the death penalty within 30 days from Friday, the maximum penalty would be a life sentence in prison.

Rosekrans said he made the call to increase the charges after receiving all of the investigative documents from the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office.

“Early on we had the indications that it would reach this point,” Rosekrans said.

“But you don’t want to jump the gun on that type of a charge.

“Now that we have almost all of the discovery in, it’s clear that these are the charges we want to file.”

Pierce’s next court appearance is scheduled for Aug. 14 at 8:30 a.m.

The Yarrs were found dead in their home at 780 Boulton Farm Road in Quilcene on March 19, the day after a fire destroyed the house.

Investigators said the Yarrs had not died from the fire — and that the flames were intentionally set.

No official cause of death has been released, but investigators said bullet casings were found on the ground near the bodies of the Yarrs.

Pierce is charged with two homicides, arson, robbery, burglary, theft of a firearm, unlawful possession of a firearm and theft.

He was arrested on March 23 after he was identified by investigators from an image taken from a surveillance camera at an automatic teller machine at a Quilcene bank.

The camera allegedly recorded him using the Yarrs’ debit card minutes after the fire at their home began.

________

Reporter Erik Hidle can be reached at 360-385-2335 or at erik.hidle@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Jefferson County Auditor Brenda Huntingford, right, watches as clerk Ronnie Swafford loads a stack of ballots that were delivered from the post office on Tuesday into a machine that checks for signatures. The special election has measures affecting the Port Townsend and Brinnon school districts as well as East Jefferson Fire Rescue. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Jefferson County voters supporting school district measures, fire lid lifts

Port Townsend approving 20-year, $99.25 million construction bond

Port of Port Townsend Harbormaster Kristian Ferrero, right, watches as a crew from Seattle Global Diving and Salvage work to remove a derelict catamaran that was stuck in the sand for weeks on a beach at the Water Front Inn on Washington Street in Port Townsend. The boat had been sunk off of Indian Point for weeks before a series of storms pushed it to this beach last week. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Derelict boat removal

Port of Port Townsend Harbormaster Kristian Ferrero, right, watches as a crew… Continue reading

Rob Birman has served as Centrum’s executive director for 14 years. When the arts nonprofit completes its search for its next leader, Birman will transition into a role focused on capital fundraising and overseeing capital projects for buildings Centrum oversees. (Centrum)
Centrum signs lease to remain at Fort Worden for next 35 years

Executive director will transition into role focused on fundraising

Clallam approves contracts with several agencies

Funding for reimbursement, equipment replacement

Mark and Linda Secord have been named Marrowstone Island Citizens of the Year for 2025.
Secords named Marrowstone Island citizens of year

Mark and Linda Secord have been chosen as Marrowstone… Continue reading

The members of the 2026 Rhody Festival royalty are, from left, Princess Payton Frank, Queen Lorelei Turner and 2025 Queen Taylor Frank. The 2026 queen was crowned by the outgoing queen during a ceremony at Chimacum High School on Saturday. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Rhody coronation

The members of the 2026 Rhody Festival royalty are, from left, Princess… Continue reading

Jefferson considering new site for solid waste

Commissioners direct further exploration

Public feedback still shaping Clallam ordinance on RV usage

Community Development department set to move sections of its proposal

Jen Colmore, Sequim Food Bank’s community engagement coordinator, has been hired as the executive director. She will start in her new role after outgoing director Andra Smith starts as executive director of the Washington Food Coalition later this month. (Sequim Food Bank)
Sequim Food Bank hires new executive director

Sequim organization tabs engagement coordinator

Sara Nicholls, executive director of the Dungeness Valley Health and Wellness Clinic, also known as the Sequim Free Clinic, inspects food items that are free to any patient who needs them. Soroptimist International of Sequim sponsors the food pantry, she said. (Austin James)
Sequim Free Clinic to celebrate 25th year

Volunteer-driven nonprofit will reach quarter-century mark in October

Weekly flight operations scheduled

Field carrier landing practice operations will take place for aircraft… Continue reading

“Angel” Alleacya Boulia, 26, of St. Louis, Mo., was last seen shopping in Port Angeles on Nov. 17, National Park Service officials said. Her rented vehicle was located Nov. 30 at the Sol Duc trailhead in Olympic National Park. (National Park Service)
Body of missing person found in Sol Duc Valley

Remains believed to be St. Louis woman