Agencies support Dash Air

Kenmore Air filed complaint to USDOT

PORT ANGELES — Dash Air has requested additional time to respond to a complaint of “unfair and deceptive business practices” filed by Kenmore Air, while a coalition of area agencies announced Tuesday they plan to stand up for the company that aims to provide the first passenger air service from Port Angeles since 2014.

The Port of Port Angeles had sought a carrier to operate between the Fairchild and Seattle-Tacoma international airports since Kenmore Air stopped the service in 2014. Dash Air had begun selling tickets for flights expected to begin Thursday.

But Dash Air had to refund money and change schedules when Kenmore Air filed a 96-page complaint with the U.S. Department of Transportation on July 20.

On Aug. 3, it filed a request for a 15-day extension to respond to the Kenmore complaint. The original deadline for the response was Aug. 4.

Marc Abshire, executive director of the Port Angeles Chamber of Commerce, wrote a scathing public letter dated July 27, accusing Kenmore Air of being a deceitful company, believing that Kenmore issued its complaint in an attempt to damage Dash Air and claiming that the company abandoned Port Angeles due to its inability/unwillingness to manage its services.

“The Kenmore Air Harbor, LLC (Kenmore) complaint is vague, misleading, deceptive, and self-contradictory,” said the letter, which Abshire said was written on behalf of the chamber’s board.

“In addition, the complaint was filed with timing clearly intended to imperil (and effectually delay) the launch of a returned air service between the main Port Angeles (CLM) and Seattle (SEA) airports. Kenmore’s requests for a cease and desist order and a fine against Dash should be immediately denied and the complaint should be dismissed with prejudice,” reads the letter from the chamber.

On Tuesday, the Port Angeles Business Association (PABA) joined the Port Angeles Chamber of Commerce and the Sequim-Dungeness Chamber of Commerce in condemning the complaint by Kenmore Air and issuing a list of comments to the federal agency in response to the complaint and in support of Dash Air.

“We agree with and make reference to comments forwarded to you by the Port Angeles Chamber of Commerce and the Sequim-Dungeness Chamber of Commerce,” said PABA President Jim McEntire. “This complaint is a specious attempt to harm a business which it isn’t in competition with, by an airline which, until November 2014, served the air transportation Market between Port Angeles and central Puget Sound.”

Kenmore’s complaint charged that Dash Air was “openly proposing to operate interstate scheduled air service without having been found fit by the Department of Transportation, in violation of 49 USC 41102 and 14 CFR 201.”

Said Hank Myers, a consultant for Kenmore Air: “Dash Air has advertised itself as if it were an air carrier. Now, along the way, they (Dash Air) have said they are just a booking agent that would be hiring an air carrier, which is Back Country Aviation. But neither Dash Air nor Back Country Aviation has the authority from the Federal Aviation Administration or Department of Transportation to provide scheduled passenger service between Fairchild International Airport and Sea-Tac,” Myers said.

Kenmore Air asserts that there would be no immediate impact on the air carrier should Dash Air become operational.

“At least not in the immediate future, but as one of the exhibits shows in the complaint, Dash has proposed, after it gets its federal subsidy, to expand its operations, some of which parallel Kenmore,” Myers said.

Clint Ostler, president of Dash Air, said those claims are baseless.

“Dash Air Shuttle … maintains that there is precedent for the Department of Transportation to dismiss these claims. We have support from the FAA and are following all necessary requirements to ensure proper certification,” Ostler said.

The complaint also claimed that Dash Air is an unfit competitor to Kenmore and other regional small air carriers, to which Kenmore Chief Operations Officer David Gudgel was quick to say that Dash Air is not a competitor at the moment, but it would be a welcome one.

“First, Dash Air is not a competitor of Kenmore’s, although if it gets federal subsidy support, its proposed routes would be competitive. Competition by qualified competitors operating under the appropriate rules is great,” Gudgel said.

“We operated in Port Angeles until 2014. We are not taking issue with Dash Air as a competitor in this market. Our issue is with a local air carrier reporting to be something that they’re not,” Gudgel said.

“Our issue is not with the market. It’s with the carrier,” Gudgel said.

Gudgel responded to the criticism as well as other comments made online.

“We had these concerns with Dash Air a year ago, and we presented these same issues that were in the complaint to Dash Air at that time and received no response,” he said.

“When we saw that they were beginning to take bookings, it triggered our concern that none of the issues we had addressed with them appeared to have been addressed, and there was certainly no response from them on the issues we raised. The timing of this is not simply the last couple of weeks but an ongoing issue,” Gudgel said.

Ostler said that Dash Air had received a message from Myers addressing the issues outlined in the complaint and that he responded to it.

“We did receive an email inquiry from Hank (not in an official capacity of Kenmore Air) in November … While Hank is not a lawyer, and thus we are not required to respond, as a courtesy, I did respond via email to his concerns related to our operation,” Ostler said.

Kenmore departed Port Angeles in 2014, stating there was not enough demand for the business at the time.

“The level of business did not support the operation, so we weren’t able to obtain the passenger accounts at the rates that we needed in order to move back into operation,” Gudgel said.

However, the company had not abandoned the possibility of returning to Port Angeles.

“We leave all of our options open,” Gudgel said.

“We recently expanded our options to Paine Field for flights to the San Juans. So we are always looking at new markets, but we do not have plans at this point to return to Port Angeles,” Gudgel said.

________

Reporter Ken Park can be reached at kpark@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading

Navy training exercise to be conducted Thursday

Naval Magazine Indian Island will conduct a security training… Continue reading

North Olympic Library System public service specialist Jessica Raivo transfers books from the stacks to a cart on Saturday at the Sequim Public Library for eventual transport to a temporary library building. The current library on North Sequim Avenue is slated for renovation and expansion with library services slated to resume on April 1 at 609 W. Washington St., next to Fifth Avenue Furniture, in the storefront that was previously Brian’s Sporting Goods. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Book transfer

North Olympic Library System public service specialist Jessica Raivo transfers books from… Continue reading

Jefferson County is eying short-term rental regulations

Feedback to be presented to Planning Commission

Clallam PUD seeking faster solution for West End outages

County commissioners, coalition support idea of expanded right of way

From left to right, Sean Coleman, Colleen Robinson, Brown Maloney and Todd Ortloff display the awards they earned Friday during the annual gala of the Clallam County Economic Development Council at Field Arts & Events Hall in Port Angeles (Lorie Fazio/Clallam County EDC)
Coleman named Olympic Leader of the Year at EDC gala

Habitat for Humanity, Radio Pacific also win awards during event

Historic bell missing from Camp Parsons

Property crime up in Brinnon area, director says

Casey and Karen Proud, both of Sequim, look at a selection of St. Patrick’s Day hats and other souvenirs for participating in Saturday’s Shamrock Shuffle & Pub Crawl in downtown Port Angeles. The event, a benefit for the Hurricane Ridge Winter Sports Education Foundation, allowed crawlers to receive six tasting tokens for libations at participating bars and restaurants in the downtown area with a drawing for additional prizes. Numerous downtown businesses also offered sale discounts for purchases during the crawl. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Winter sports benefit in Port Angeles

Casey and Karen Proud, both of Sequim, look at a selection of… Continue reading

U.S. Rep. Derek Kilmer, right, discusses emergency services on Thursday during a roundtable session with emergency managers from across the region, including Clallam County Sheriff Brian King, left, and Clallam County Administrator Todd Mielke in Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Clallam seeks additional funds for emergency operations center

Administrator says $10 million still needed for proposed project

More than 100 educators appeared at Thursday’s Port Angeles School District board meeting to show their support for paraeducators, who are seeking a 3.7 percent pay raise and have been working without a contract since Aug. 31. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
Paraeducators fill school board meeting

Labor group asking for same raise teachers received

Committee forms to support Quilcene school levy

Lack of communication cited for failed vote

Herb Beck Marina improvements in the works

New concrete boat launch among the plans