Late report in Hill case leads to termination

Officer let go after internal investigation, according to records

PORT ANGELES — Allegations against a former emergency room doctor who stands charged with six counts of sexual misconduct with patients predated the first instance for which he was charged by nearly a month, but the police officer who talked with the alleged victim did not file a timely report, according to investigation records.

The trial of former Olympic Medical Center doctor Josiah Hill is set for June 5 on five counts of indecent liberties by a healthcare provider and one count of second-degree rape. Prosecutors have said more charges may be filed at a later date.

The charges are based on allegations made to investigators beginning in April. A woman alleged sexual assault twice in March, according to documents concerning the termination of Michael Johnson from the Port Angeles Police Department (PAPD) as obtained by Ashton Dennis, an attorney with Washington Law group representing two of the alleged sexual assault victims.

Johnson was terminated as an officer on Aug. 19, following an internal investigation that determined he had been found in violation of several PAPD policies, the records said.

The investigation found that Johnson violated the Sexual Assault Required Reporting policy and the department’s code of ethics by making false or misleading statements, dishonorable/disgraceful conduct, and violations against policy regarding administrative investigations.

Chief Brian Smith said in a letter sent on Aug. 19 to Johnson, who had been with the department since 2007, that not filing the reports in a timely fashion delayed the investigation of Hill.

According to a probable cause statement filed by Johnson in May, he had on two occasions in March 2022 been told by an alleged victim, a woman in her 30s, that Hill had sexually assaulted her.

He said he was told this while investigating other reports.

The first time Johnson heard the woman’s allegations was March 22, according to the internal investigation report. He heard allegations from her also on March 24 when he followed up with her at the request of her family to help her find mental health resources, the report said.

During this conversation, the woman told Johnson that Hill had made suggestive comments about her chest and touched her inappropriately on March 16.

Internal investigation documents reveal that on both those occasions, Johnson did not file a report.

“By not completing the initial report in a timely manner, you did not provide investigators with the opportunity to begin their investigation,” Smith said in his letter to Johnson.

”The initial report should have been written promptly regardless of who might have completed the follow-up investigation, and those efforts would have been properly documented in supplemental reports,” Smith continued.

“It will never be known whether a timely report written by you regarding the sexual assault allegations would have prevented the suspect from committing additional crimes,” Smith said.

Detectives did not begin to investigate Hill until two other women had come forward in April 2022. They subsequently learned from Johnson about the woman he had spoken with in March.

Johnson was instructed to immediately file a report by his superior officer on May 10. The officer was soon placed on unpaid administrative leave while under internal investigation.

On June 8, Detective Sgt. Kori Malone interviewed Johnson as part of the internal investigation, according to investigation documents.

Johnson said he had intended to file the sexual assault reports but did not have time. Sgt. Malone said that the call log for the time period, March 22-May 10, showed he had at least 49 opportunities to file the reports.

Johnson also was interviewed by his union representative, Richard Stone with Teamsters 589 and Chief Smith, during which Johnson repeated what he told Sgt. Malone, and also said the primary reason he delayed filing the reports was to obtain more information about the woman’s allegations from OMC. Stone could not be reached for comment.

It was ultimately determined that Johnson never requested documentation from OMC.

In a July 11 letter to Deputy Chief Jason Viada and Chief Smith, Johnson said it was his belief that submitting the report with the woman’s brief statement and no other information would result in his report being rejected and sent back to him to obtain more information.

“You apparently considered and abandoned the excuse that you lacked time to complete the necessary task in favor of a different excuse that you considered more plausible,” Smith said in his letter to Johnson.

“Given your lack of effort to obtain any additional information, including making a request for a video that could be recorded over when no one was asking for it to be preserved, I did not credit this new excuse.”

During a pre-disciplinary hearing in July 2022, Smith gave Johnson an opportunity to demonstrate why he should not be terminated, explaining he needed to convince the chief that he was not lying during the internal investigation to cover up what would have been a forgivable offense.

“Forgetting to write a report after receiving allegations of sexual assault violates policy and warrants some disciplinary actions,” Smith said.

”Mistakes can be forgiven and corrected.

“But being dishonest as to why you failed to write the report when interviewed for the investigation cannot be tolerated.

“It is the dishonesty, and not the failure to write a report that had led me to the decision that the disciplinary sanction, in this case, is the termination of your employment with the PAPD,” Smith said.


Reporter Ken Park can be reached at

More in News

Customers at the Nordland General Store on Marrowstone Island look over cards and other items during a weekend of activities to celebrate the re-opening of the store after it had been closed for six years due to a fire. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Nordland General Store reopens with new model

Cooperative, board of directors leading operations of facility

Makah to cut ribbon on sawmill

Mill built in partnership with Port Angeles company

Elizabeth Resager of Bainbridge Island turns a sheep over so it is comfortable as she sheers its year-old woolen fleece, a highlight of the 41st Shepherd’s Festival at the Sequim Prairie Grange on Monday. The festival was half inside and half outside and included many vendors with sheep, goats, llamas and related products. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Shepherd’s Festival

Elizabeth Resager of Bainbridge Island turns a sheep over so it is… Continue reading

Centrum awarded $45K grant from national endowment

Centrum has been approved for a Grants for Arts… Continue reading

Helen and Greg Starr, executors of James Minsky’s estate, cut the ribbon for LtCol James Minsky Place on May 17 with Cheri Tinker, executive director of Sarge’s Veteran Support, right, and Sarge’s board president Lorri Gilchrist, and city council members Harmony Rutter and Rachel Anderson. The facility will permanently house six disabled and/or elderly veterans in Sequim. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Minsky Place opens to support elderly, disabled veterans

Sarge’s Veteran Support seeks five veterans for permanent housing

Public comment opens on Dabob Bay

State, county look to move lands into conservation

Clallam renews pact with investigative unit

Agencies are currently investigating shooting outside PA bank

Motrocyclist airlifted to Harborview after wreck

A San Antonio man was airlifted to Harborview Medical Center… Continue reading

WomenSpirit Coalition staff members include, from left, Michelle Williams, Dee Koester, Diane Good (in back), Cheryl Neskahi Coan, Erin Lopez Neskahi and Laura Fierro. (Elijah Sussman/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
WomenSpirit Coalition steps into new phase

Multi-service indigenous support organization to host open house

Members of the Mount Olympus Detachment 897 of the Marine Corps League give a 21-gun salute at a Memorial Day ceremony at Mt. Angeles Memorial Park in Port Angeles on Monday. The ceremony was hosted by the Veterans of Foreign Wars Post 6787 of Carlsborg and was one of many Memorial Day events held in Clallam and Jefferson counties. (Peter Segall/Peninsula Daily News)
Solemn ceremonies honor America’s war dead

Flowers, wreaths decorate gravesites across Peninsula

Peninsula College, teachers agree on contract

Three-year deal to raise faculty salaries

Clallam County pledges $1.5 million toward preserving two farms

Commitment would provide conservation easement on properties