Michael Pierce

Michael Pierce

Judge to hear motion to dismiss double-murder charges against Michael J. Pierce on Sept. 11

PORT TOWNSEND –– Michael J. Pierce should not be tried a fourth time for the killings of Pat and Janice Yarr, his attorney says, and a judge will hear arguments on a motion to dismiss all charges next week.

“Mr. Pierce should not be subjected to a fourth trial where the failures of previous trials are solely attributable to the State,” his attorney, Richard Davies of Port Townsend, wrote in his motion for dismissal.

The motion to dismiss charges against Pierce, 38, of Quilcene will be heard by Superior Court Judge Sally Olsen at 1:30 p.m. Sept. 11 in Kitsap County Superior Court, 614 Division St., Port Orchard.

Pierce, who is housed in the Jefferson County jail in Port Hadlock, was convicted in 2010 of the 2009 murders of the Quilcene couple.

The state Court of Appeals overturned the conviction in 2013, ruling that Pierce’s constitutional rights were denied after his arrest and that Prosecuting Attorney Scott Rosekrans’ closing argument in the original trial represented prosecutorial misconduct.

Since then, two retrials have been declared mistrials. A third retrial is set to begin Oct. 9 in Kitsap County Superior Court.

In the first retrial, which was in Jefferson County, juror Laura Meynberg remembered seeing a man who might have been Pierce on the night of the murders.

The second, moved to Kitsap County, ended after it was revealed jailers there failed to administer anti-psychotic medications to Pierce that brought his ability to understand the proceedings into question.

Pierce faces eight charges: two counts of first-degree murder and one count each of first-degree burglary, first-degree robbery, first-degree arson, theft of a firearm, second-degree unlawful possession of a firearm and second-degree theft.

Kitsap County jailers “inflicted cruel and unusual punishment” when they failed to administer psychotropic medications to treat Pierce’s schizophrenia, Davies said in his motion filed in July.

The withholding of medication was “barbarous,” Davies said in his motion.

It “subjected Mr. Pierce to paranoia and hallucinations in a government-induced state of psychosis, just as if the government had actively induced that psychosis by the use of drugs on a person without pre-existing mental illness,” he said.

Jefferson County Chief Criminal Deputy Chris Ashcraft wrote in the state’s 321-page response filed Aug. 27 that “the only event in this case that merits the adjective barbarous is the execution of two innocent people while they were lying on their kitchen floor.

“At best, the facts show negligent acts by the Kitsap County Jail and [its medical contractor] Conmed,” Ashcraft continued.

“There is no evidence anyone acted consciously or with an objective or purpose to cut off Pierce’s medications.”

During the Kitsap County retrial before Olsen, jailers did not give Pierce all his medications March 8, 9 and 10.

Davies said Pierce became noticeably distant, easily agitated and absent from testimony during March 10.

Dr. Richard Yocum of Western State Hospital testified in March that the lack of medication caused Pierce to hear voices like a “radio playing in the back of his head.”

Kitsap County contracts its jail medical services with Conmed Healthcare Management.

Jefferson County jail officials said they had provided a month’s supply of medications for Pierce when he was taken to Kitsap only two weeks earlier.

Davies claims Pierce’s medication was “intentionally discontinued” by Kitsap County jailers and amounted to “physical and psychological torture.”

An emergency hearing in May renewed Pierce’s waiver of a speedy trial just before it expired, which would have put a halt to the county’s efforts to prosecute Pierce in a third retrial.

Kitsap County Superior Court Judge Jay B. Roof extended the speedy trial waiver to Oct. 31.

________

Sequim-Dungeness Valley Editor Joe Smillie can be reached at 360-681-2390, ext. 5052, or at jsmillie@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Quilcene schools, Clallam Bay fire district measures passing

Voters in Jefferson and Clallam counties appear to have passed measures for… Continue reading

Tribe seeking funds for hotel

Plans still in works for downtown Port Angeles

Clallam County eyes second set of lodging tax applications

Increase more than doubles support from 2023

Olympic Medical Center reports operating losses

Hospital audit shows $28 million shortfall

Jefferson County joins opioid settlement

Deal with Johnson & Johnson to bring more than $200,000

Ballots due today for elections in Clallam, Jefferson counties

It’s Election Day for voters in Quilcene and Clallam… Continue reading

Jefferson PUD has clean audit for 2022

Jefferson County Public Utility District #1 has received a… Continue reading

Jefferson Transit opens survey on climate action plan

Jefferson Transit Authority will conduct a survey through June… Continue reading

Three volunteers sought for Clallam County Disability Board

The Clallam County Disability Board is seeking volunteers to… Continue reading

Pictured, from left, are Mary Kelso, Jane Marks, Barbara Silva and Linda Cooper.
School donation

The Port Angeles Garden Club donated $800 to the Crescent School in… Continue reading

Clayton Hergert, 2, along with is mother, Mandy Hergert of Port Angeles, sit at the bow of a U.S. Coast Guard response boat on display during Saturday’s Healthy Kids Day at the Port Angeles YMCA. The event, hosted by all three Olympic Peninsula YMCA branches, featured children’s activities designed to promote a healthy lifestyle and a love for physical activity. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Captain on deck

Clayton Hergert, 2, along with is mother, Mandy Hergert of Port Angeles,… Continue reading

Clallam County Fire District 3 commissioners agreed on April 2 to seek a real estate market analysis for Lost Mountain Station 36 after multiple attempts to seek volunteers to keep the station open. They’ll consider selling it and using funds for emergency supplies in the area, and offsetting construction costs for a new Carlsborg fire station. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Fire District to seek market analysis for station

Proceeds could help build new building in Carlsborg