Judge rules against portions of Brinnon resort pact

Jefferson County commissioners told to reconsider

PORT ORCHARD — A Kitsap County Superior Court judge has reversed portions of Jefferson County’s development agreement for the proposed Pleasant Harbor Master Planned Resort and sent it back to the Board of County Commissioners for further consideration.

In her decision, Judge Sally Olsen found inconsistencies between the development agreement and Jefferson County Code, particularly in regard to the master planned resort’s proposal to build out in multiple phases and to have each phase stand alone with the proper amount of recreational opportunities.

Olsen’s decision was rendered March 28 on the appeal filed by the Brinnon Group.

The development agreement between the county and the Pleasant Harbor Marina and Golf Resort covers a 238-acre area along the Hood Canal south of Brinnon.

Plans call for 200-plus condominiums and multiple recreational opportunities.

“Upon completion of Phase 1, according to the [development agreement], there would be the marina, 202 housing units and a cleared site for the nine-hole golf course, with no golf course being built,” Olsen wrote in her decision.

“In addition to lacking a golf course, Phase 1 fails to provide a spa, sports courts, pool or water slides, all of which the [Master Planned Resort] is required to provide.

“Phase 1 also fails to provide a community center, a recreation center, a conference center, staff quarters, a maintenance building or commercial space.”

The decision reversed the development agreement and sent it back to the Board of Jefferson County Commissioners to be revised consistent with the order.

Either the county or the developer could appeal within 30 days of the decision.

“It’s up to the developer to decide what they’re going to do given the court order,” Commission Chair Kate Dean said Tuesday. “They could ask us to amend in compliance with the court order, but it’s really up to the developer to decide the next step.”

Out of a 10-point statement, Olsen found in favor of the Brinnon Group, which opposes the development agreement, on three principles.

“The fundamental proposition here is under the state Growth Management Act,” said Rick Aramburu, a Seattle attorney who represents the Brinnon Group.

“You just don’t get to build waterfront condos any place you want unless you tie it with a real destination resort, and that’s specifically allowed for under the [county] code.

“We want the resort facilities to be built along with it so each phase would be accompanied by recreational facilities,” he said.

Arguments were heard in December.

Separately, a hearing was held in front of the Western Washington Growth Management Hearings board in December. One issue regarding the state Environmental Policy Act was dismissed at the request of the Brinnon Group, and the board ruled in favor of Jefferson County on the four other points in a statement filed Jan. 30.


Jefferson County Managing Editor Brian McLean can be reached at 360-385-2335, ext. 6, or at [email protected].

More in News

Bret Allen Kenney was in court on Friday.
$5 million bail set in officer assault

Man also a person of interest in homicide of his mother

Candidate filing week ends with list of hopefuls

Three contests to be on primary ballot

Housing, fish passage topics at county meetings

Government entities gather on North Olympic Peninsula

Clallam Farm Family of the Year nominations sought

The Clallam County Fair invites the public to submit… Continue reading

Brian King, left, and Marc Titterness.
Candidates for sheriff debate during forum

Wraparound services, staffing among issues discussed

Dick Richardson, volunteer coordinator of the U.S. Light House Society, shows off the 1880’s French made fresnel lens at the top of the Point Wilson Light at Fort Worden State Park. The society is the caretaker of the lighthouse, under a license from the U.S. Coast Guard. Public tours are conducted from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. on Saturdays and Sundays. Because of liability issues and Coast Guard regulations, the top floor, where the lens is located, will be off limits. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Lighthouse tours

Dick Richardson, volunteer coordinator of the U.S. Light House Society, shows off… Continue reading

Port sunsets discount program

Storage had been half price if prepaid

The Worthington Mansion restoration includes 9,000 cedar shingles that were hand dipped bay volunteers two years ago. They are installed on the mansard roof. The top floor of the mansion which is the interior of the roof area is envisioned to become a library area and meeting space. (Peninsula Daily News file)
Worthington Mansion volunteers to cut the ribbon

Overnight stays expected to begin in June

Construction tentatively finishes this week at the new Woodcock Road roundabout. (Bob Lampert)
Woodcock Road roundabout to tentatively finish May 20

Work on the Woodcock Road/Sequim-Dungeness Way roundabout is expected to… Continue reading

Most Read