The state Supreme Court’s most junior Justice, Mary Yu, foreground, and Chief Justice Barbara Madsen, during an event in Chimacum on Friday, said there is a coordinated effort to unseat the three justices running for re-election over two controversial school-funding rulings. (Jesse Major/Peninsula Daily News)

The state Supreme Court’s most junior Justice, Mary Yu, foreground, and Chief Justice Barbara Madsen, during an event in Chimacum on Friday, said there is a coordinated effort to unseat the three justices running for re-election over two controversial school-funding rulings. (Jesse Major/Peninsula Daily News)

State Supreme Court justices decry tactics

Justice Mary Yu and Chief Justice Barbara Madsen say opponents focus on the McCleary and other decisions.

CHIMACUM — An orchestrated effort is attempting to unseat three state Supreme Court justices over two controversial school-funding rulings, the court’s most junior justice said during the Jefferson County Bar Association’s Continuing Legal Education session in Chimacum on Friday.

Justice Mary Yu and Chief Justice Barbara Madsen, who are both running for re-election in the Nov. 8 general election, told the nearly 100 people who attended that their opponents are focusing on the controversy surrounding the court’s 2012 McCleary and 2015 charter school decisions to unseat the three justices running for re-election.

Justice Charles Wiggins is also running for re-election but did not attend the event.

Much of the discussion revolved around the McCleary decision, in which the court ruled the state must adequately fund K-12 education. In 2014, the court held the state in contempt and imposed a $100,000 fine per day, a fine now totaling more than $36 million.

The court also ruled in 2015 that charter schools were unconstitutional.

“The court is not grabbing and politicizing issues,” Madsen said. “We are not political … we are doing our job.”

David DeWolf, a Gonzaga University law professor, is challenging Yu, Kittitas County Prosecutor Greg Zempel is looking to replace Madsen and David Larson — a Federal Way municipal court judge — is challenging Wiggins.

“The races are nonpartisan, but all three challengers share the view that the court has failed to respect the autonomy of the Legislature by holding the state in contempt in the McCleary case — a criticism frequently lobbed by Republican lawmakers over the past two years,” the Yakima Herald said.

”The three judicial candidates also take issue with the court’s 2015 decision striking down the state’s voter-approved charter school law.” the newspaper said.

Yu called attacks from Madsen’s opponent, Zempel, “vicious.”

“If people think they should unelect a sitting justice because of one case, then that is a very bad precedent,” she said.

Zempel told the Herald that he had no “real ax to grind” on either the McCleary or charter schools case — although he sees those cases as representative of what he called the court’s unpredictability.

He is primarily concerned about the court overturning long-standing precedents, he said when he announced his candidacy in May, and called the court highly-politicized. He also said the court needs more representation from Eastern Washington.

Zempel said in an interview Saturday the three challengers are no more coordinated than the justices they are seeking to unseat.

“We’re three different individuals taking on three different incumbents,” he said. “All three of us have commonalities.”

DeWolf, a Gonzaga University law professor, has testified before the state Legislature that the state Supreme Court went too far in the McCleary decision, according to the Yakima Herald.

Larson has said he decided to run against Wiggins primarily because he thinks the Supreme Court misinterpreted legal precedent when striking down charter schools last year.

Yu said she believes there is a coordinated attack on the court because the opponents that she and Madsen face are both focusing on the McCleary decision.

“When they are all singing the same song, it’s all the same script. You wonder if this is a specific orchestrated effort,” she said.

State Rep. Matt Manweller, R-Ellensburg, was active in recruiting DeWolf and Zempel to run, and also reached out to Larson, the Herald said.

Others who Manweller said worked to recruit judicial challengers included former Republican U.S. Sen. Slade Gorton and former Democratic state Sen. Rodney Tom, who until recently led a Senate coalition of mostly Republicans.

Madsen said the justices are responsible for interpreting the law and avoiding their own personal biases when making decisions.

Yu called it troubling that a minority of legislators is claiming the court overstepped its authority with the McCleary decision and showing a lack of respect for the rule of law.

Madsen called it unfair that independent groups are funding Zempel’s campaign. Two PACs, the Judicial Integrity WA PAC and the Stand for Children WA PAC, have contributed a combined $230,000 to Zempel’s election, according to the state’s Public Disclosure Commission.

The Stand For Children PAC, which provided $130,000 in support of Zempel, said in a 2015 article on its website referring to the court’s charter school decision that “whether or not the court’s decision has legal merit, there is no doubt that the result is morally wrong.”

Zempel’s campaign is the only judicial campaign in the state to receive more than $200 in support from a PAC as independent expenditures.

Zempel said he is humbled he is receiving the financial support from the PACs and said there’s likely PACs waiting to support Madsen later in the campaign.

“She was offended anyone would challenge her when I filed,” he said. “Now she is complaining about the fact that money is a factor.”

“It puts the courts at risk when anybody with money determines who can be on the Supreme Court,” Madsen said.

________

Reporter Jesse Major can be reached at 360-385-2335, ext. 5550, or at jmajor@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in Politics

Republican Jaime Herrera Beutler, left, and Democrats Patrick DePoe, center, and Kevin Van De Wege, all candidates for state Commissioner of Public Lands, met before the Port Angeles Business Association on Tuesday to discuss their priorities for leading the Department of Natural Resources. (Peter Segall/Peninsula Daily News)
Fires are top priority for Commissioner of Public Lands hopefuls

Candidates want to increase state harvests

League of Women Voters sets candidate forum schedule

Hopefuls for state seats, county commissioner position invited to debate

From left to right, State Sen. Emily Randall, D-Bremerton, state Sen. Drew MacEwen, R-Union, Port Angeles attorney Graham Ralston and Commissioner of Public Lands Hilary Franz, all candidates for Washington’s 6th Congressional District, appear before the Port Angeles Business Association on Tuesday to answer questions about their priorities for serving in Congress. (Peter Segall/Peninsula Daily News)
Congress hopefuls meet for a forum

Candidates to focus on bipartisanship

Clallam PUD candidates cite costs as top priority

Three hopefuls line up for six-year board position

More candidates join local races

Third declares for state Senate seat

Packed races begin to emerge

Political hopefuls file intent to run

Heather Dudley-Nollette.
Bayside director to run for Jefferson County commissioner

Heather Dudley-Nollette seeks District 1 seat

Port Angeles City Council hopefuls Kate Dexter and Travis Berglund answer questions during a Port Angeles Business Association forum Tuesday. (Jesse Major/Peninsula Daily News)
Port Angeles mayor to run for county commission

Dexter has supported climate action plan, affordable housing

Emily Randall, left, and Hilary Franz.
Stalwarts take sides in race for Kilmer’s seat

A growing constellation of Democratic Party influencers are choosing sides in the… Continue reading

Online learning keeps rising among state’s K-12 students

Online learning for Washington’s public school kids is here to stay. That’s… Continue reading

Jefferson County turnout tops in state

More than half registered voters handed in ballots

Battle narrows to Biden and Trump

Tuesday’s primaries give each the delegates needed for a November contest