POINT OF VIEW: Not all net pens are created equal

Kurt Grinnell

Kurt Grinnell

By Kurt Grinnell

Jamestown S’Klallam Tribe

With all of the recent publicity about net pens, we feel compelled to weigh-in.

Net pens are a technique for growing fish — a technique that has at times been done well, and at other times been done poorly.

We are not inherently opposed to net pens.

We are opposed to growing a non-native species in our waters.

It is the non-native Atlantic salmon, not net pens, which pose a threat to our treaty resources.

The Jamestown S’Klallam Tribe has thrived since time immemorial on the abundance of sea life living in our usual and accustomed waters, and we have acted as stewards of those environments in order to preserve our lifeways, our culture and our food sources.

Retaining our rights to harvest fin and shellfish was one of the key provisions of the Treaty of Point No Point that we negotiated with the federal government in 1855 — rights that have been reaffirmed in several court cases, including the Boldt and Rafeedie decisions.

The abundance of fish that once provided for us is no longer available naturally.

Since the early 1900s, propagating native fin and shellfish from larvae has been a successful method for augmenting natural populations in our area as conditions (including loss of habitat and commercial over-harvesting) have changed.

Tribes, Washington state and private parties have all turned to aquaculture to augment populations and harvest.

In some cases, this includes the use of net pens to grow fin fish until they are strong enough to survive in the wild.

We are not alone in our love of fish, nor are we alone in our belief in aquaculture.

Peoples all over the world love seafood, and seafood has been shown to be an important component of a healthy human diet.

Much of the fish eaten worldwide is farmed.

The question is whether we want to import fish from countries where farmed seafood is unregulated, or whether we want to do our due diligence and use the best that science and technology have to offer in order to grow fish safely and sustainably in our own country.

All food production impacts the environment.

The key is understanding and mitigating those impacts in order keep the environment clean and productive.

We believe that growing fin and shellfish safely and sustainably is possible, and as good stewards of our lands and waters, that is what we are doing and intend to continue doing.

In fact, we are on the cutting edge of the aquaculture industry.

Jamestown Seafood’s Point Whitney Ventures LLC is spawning and growing oyster and geoduck seed and seeding the Sequim Bay tidelands for harvest.

This work is possible because of the restoration work that we did more than 10 years ago in the Jimmycomelately Creek and Estuary.

In lower Dungeness and Dungeness Bay, we have been working for decades with Clallam County and Clallam Conservation District to improve water quality.

We have achieved significant improvements, with hundreds of acres having a shellfish harvest classification upgrade.

We understand that all life is connected.

That is why our Natural Resources staff take a holistic approach to all of their work.

We research and monitor the impacts of all that we do to assure that we do no harm to the environment as we pursue methods of producing the fin and shellfish that are a part of our Salish culture.

For example, we monitor water quality and quantity in terms of such issues as storm water, algae blooms, ocean acidification, impacts of septic systems, irrigation and wells. And then we act on what we find, to clean up and sustain healthy ecosystems.

Most recently, we have begun a pilot project on farmed black cod (also known as sablefish or butterfish).

Working with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), and the University of Washington at a lab near Manchester, we have spent the past year gaining a better understanding of how to spawn and grow this native species for market.

The once-abundant and highly sought-after species has dwindled in numbers in Puget Sound, and we believe that farming it may provide us with an economically-viable business model in the future.

In order to determine whether this is true, we recently applied for and were awarded a three-year Washington SeaGrant to fund further study.

We intend to explore the pros and cons of many issues related to growing black cod — land-based vs. open-water farming sites; how best to formulate food for this species (as opposed to salmonids); and whether there is a species (like sea cucumber) that we might co-locate beneath the black cod pens that might feed on their detritus and provide us with a second marketable product.

We have already developed a relationship with commercial fishermen in Gig Harbor who helped us bring our first harvest to market, and they were thrilled to have work during their slow season (one of the many benefits of farming fish as opposed to catching them).

We are a 21st century tribe. We believe in economic development and we intend to protect our culture and our treaty rights. We do our due diligence before we commit to any project, always looking to protect the environment while working to become more self-sufficient as a tribal nation.

We urge the public to learn along with us, and to keep an open mind about aquaculture.

Like any technology, it can be done well or poorly.

Like everything else we do, we intend to do aquaculture well, or not to do it at all.

________

Kurt Grinnell is a member of the Jamestown S’Klallam Tribal Council and the chairman of the Jamestown S’Klallam Natural Resources Committee.

More in Opinion

PAT NEAL: Salmon’s gift to the future

MAYBE YOU’VE HAD one of those days. You wake up on an… Continue reading

WEST END NEIGHBOR: Mushroom season is fading out

IN THE FALL, there is gold out in the forests of the… Continue reading

Richard B. Anderson
A tribute to four Peninsula residents who have received Medal of Honor

EDITOR’S NOTE: This column by PDN Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb first… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: My crazy uncle

I’VE GOT THIS crazy uncle. He’s got some bad problems. Maybe you… Continue reading

DIANE URBANI DE LA PAZ: Visit to Puerto Rico: All the grace we can muster

PUERTO RICO WASN’T what I expected. Invited on a yoga retreat there… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: All new fishing excuses

IT HAPPENS EVERY year about this time. People start whining about the… Continue reading

Frances Charles
GUEST COMMENTARY: I-1631 is rural Washington’s great green hope

By Frances Charles and W. Ron Allen The fight to safeguard Washington… Continue reading

WEST END NEIGHBOR: Perfect end for an old hemlock

WHEN THE 124-FOOT hemlock fell with its top right in the fire,… Continue reading

GUEST COMMENTARY: Vote Yes on I-1639: Safer communities

By Paula Barnes In Washington, it’s easier to buy a semi-automatic assault… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: Autumn harvest frustrations

AUTUMN IS A time of gathering the wild abundance that grows all… Continue reading

GUEST COMMENTARY: Vote No on I-1639: Don’t tread on me

By Seth and Rebecca Larson Here at FREDS Guns our focus is… Continue reading

DIANE URBANI DE LA PAZ: Special effects of the imagination

FALL MEANS HIGH time for change. Me, I could use a change… Continue reading