POINT OF VIEW: Stolen valor hurts all veterans

False claims lead to passing of act

  • By Greg Taylor
  • Monday, November 11, 2019 5:43am
  • Opinion
Greg Taylor

Greg Taylor

By Greg Taylor

VETERANS DAY IS a special day set aside to honor those who have made sacrifices, and some who made the ultimate sacrifice, to preserve our fragile freedoms.

This summer, the Peninsula Daily News featured a front-page story about a Vietnam veteran riding his motorcycle to the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington, D.C. to pay homage to his fallen comrades. Because he was dying of cancer — the result of Agent Orange exposure — the trek was dubbed “The Wall Before I Die.”

To those familiar with the history of that war, the veteran’s age and the dates he professed to have served in Vietnam, 1974 and 1975, just did not ring true.

America had ceased large-unit combat operations by 1973.

A FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) request exposed the truth: the veteran had served but had never stepped foot in Vietnam — and certainly could not be dying of Agent Orange exposure.

This development is laid out in great detail in a recent article by PDN reporter Jesse Major.

Sadly, lying about one’s service is not uncommon.

Statistics show that for every authentic Navy Seal, hundreds make false claims.

This phenomenon, quickly becoming an epidemic, resulted in the passing of the Stolen Valor Act.

Hard to believe, but the First Amendment allows one to lie about their service.

But, if you receive any tangible benefit from your lie or display certain valorous medals, that is against the law.

Federal prosecution of violations does happen. There is a campaign to legally raise Stolen Valor to the level of impersonating a police officer. Several states are creating their own Stolen Valor laws.

During the war and for many years after, some harbored negative sentiment against Vietnam veterans. Today, Americans have come to understand these young soldiers were honorably serving their country and veterans are now recognized for their service.

Unfortunately, some actual veterans falsely embellish their records, but it is just as likely that fake valor vets have never served at all.

Apparently these individuals are so desperate for recognition, they are willing to fabricate a lie to claim glory for themselves.

Search YouTube for “Stolen Valor” and you will find many videos of fake-vet encounters.

There are several ways to get at the truth of a claim to valor, but it is always best to start off calmly and conversationally and not jump to conclusions. Keep it civil.

Inquire about their unit and where they served.

All names on The Wall are listed in chronological order. Inquire about the names and dates of their fallen comrades’ deaths.

Ask to see their Military Discharge Form DD214. Dates, duty stations, awards, rank and other details will verify their service. Those who claim to have lost theirs can receive a copy through the Department of Veterans Affairs website. If they are reluctant to provide the form, you can use Standard Form 180 “Request Pertaining to Military Records” though the National Archives — without their permission.

You will receive a document titled “Information Releasable Under the FOIA”. There you will find more than enough information to verify service.

Forging or altering any federal form is a felony.

An (unaltered) driver’s license will verify if the claim of service jives with dates of combat.

Perhaps the biggest red flags are claiming records are classified, restricted or burned.

Only certain missions or events are ever classified — and never for individuals. The National Records Center fire of 1973 destroyed 80 percent of Army and Air Force records prior to 1961.

Lying about service to this country is a serious offense, and I believe it is our duty to report it.

An internet search with the phrase “Stolen Valor” will provide links to several groups devoted to exposing these liars: militaryphony.com and stolenvalor.com are just two.

Every liar steals something precious from those who made grave sacrifices in service to our country — and from their families and loved ones.


Greg Taylor volunteered for service in Vietnam (1968-1969) while serving with the Army as a Specialist E-5 from 1966-1969. He is a retired carpenter living in Port Angeles.

More in Opinion

A barred owl perched on a road sign. (Pat Neal/for Peninsula Daily News)
PAT NEAL: The barred owl menace

And so, another hunting season passes astern. I hope you did better… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: How to have a happy Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving. The word conjures images of black-robed pilgrims in white starched collars… Continue reading

Marilyn Lewis as a young woman.
PAT NEAL: She died with her boots on

In last week’s episode, we were celebrating the life of the Hoh… Continue reading

Daughter of the Olympic Wilderness: The Life and Times of Pansy Martin Snell
PAT NEAL: Daughter of the Olympic Wilderness

Read any good books lately? Daughter of the Olympic Wilderness: The Life… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: Fishing for excuses

Profiling and stereotyping have no place in a Wilderness Gossip Column. In… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: The great deer hunt

I spent all last summer cursing the day deer were invented for… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: The great mushroom hunt

In last week’s episode, we examined the very real possibility of mushroom… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: A reoccurring moisture trend

A REAL WOODSMAN doesn’t need a weatherman to know if it is… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: A winter forecast

THE SIGNS OF the season are certain. There is fresh snow on… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: The fall chore list

THIS MUST BE the most beautiful fall weather we’ve seen in years.… Continue reading

Mara  Zimmerman
POINT OF VIEW: Big bold action needed for salmon restoration

THE DECLINES OF SALMON runs, as highlighted in Peter Segall’s Sept. 2… Continue reading

LETTER: Biden impeachment

Biden impeachment I recently wrote our U.S. Representative, Derek Kilmer, to ask… Continue reading