Proposed tax for Port Townsend pool is questioned

County commissioners push back on funding

PORT TOWNSEND — The Board of Jefferson County Commissioners declined to support the recommendations for a new pool facility in Port Townsend, urging the steering committee to reconsider the proposed funding mechanism.

At their Monday meeting, commissioners asked the project’s steering committee to draft recommendations that would fund the project with a more localized tax, rather than a countywide sales tax.

The steering committee for the new pool project — known as the Healthier Together Initiative — issued recommendations for the construction of a new $37 million aquatics facility located at the Mountain View Commons site in Port Townsend, where the city’s current pool is located.

The recommendations also included a commitment to raise $17 million through state, federal and private grants while continuing the City of Port Townsend’s $400,000 annual subsidy paid to the current pool and raising $20 million in bonds.

The Port Townsend City Council approved the steering committee’s recommendations last week.

But the committee also suggested the creation of a Public Facilities District (PFD) — a countywide taxing district that would then enact a two-tenths of 1 percent sales tax to help pay for the facility.

County commissioners said they supported the creation of a new pool, but Commissioners Greg Brotherton and Heidi Eisenhour expressed concern about the recommendations.

Brotherton — who represents District 3, covering south and west Jefferson County — said he supported a pool but did not support a countywide taxing district to pay for it.

Brotherton said he’d heard from several people in his district supporting the pool, but, “I’ve heard from 10 times that many that it isn’t equitable that everyone gets taxed the same for an amenity in Port Townsend, and I have to say I agree with them.”

Brotherton said he might be able to support the countywide tax if the pool facility were more centrally located, but with the pool being located in Port Townsend, he said the tax doesn’t seem appropriate.

“I want to find a way to get to a pool, but I’m not in favor of a PFD as the funding mechanism,” Brotherton said.

Eisenhour, who represents District 2, said she had concerns about the efforts to raise $17 million in grants and donations and noted that if the tax were to pass, the county would be contributing more to the pool than it did to homelessness and affordable housing or mental health.

“This is moving too fast, in my opinion,” Eisenhour said. “I haven’t had an opportunity to hear from everybody.”

Eisenhour said there may be other locations in the county — Chimacum’s HJ Carroll Park, for example — where the pool could be located.

“I need to dig into the weeds a little bit,” Eisenhour said. “It’s not something I’m ready to vote on today.”

The steering committee had also considered the creation of a municipal parks district (MPD), which would have its borders drawn around a primary service area. Once an MPD is created, a $0.20 per $1,000 property tax levy would be enacted for the next 20 years.

Both kinds of taxes would have to be approved by voters, but an MPD would require two votes to pass; one to create the district and another to enact the tax. With a PFD, county commissioners could vote to create the district and assign its board, and then the district would put the tax on the ballot in a special election.

But once an MPD is created, voters would have to approve the new property tax by a supermajority vote, whereas a sales tax under a PFD would require only a simple majority.

District 1 Commissioner Kate Dean — who sits on the steering committee — said she felt the municipal parks district is a better mechanism for funding the project but that it is less feasible.

“More folks paying in a smaller amount is the reason why this makes sense,” Dean said. “This is a regional facility; many facilities that we all pay into that are not in our hamlet.”

Dean said she is concerned the lack of family amenities in the community is causing families to leave the region and that failing to invest in additional family-friendly infrastructure would continue that trend.

Several people gave public testimony at the meeting, most of them in favor of the project, but several expressed concerns about the cost and how many county residents would actually use the pool.

“I’ll always go to bat for kids, but it should be a regional item, not in Port Townsend,” said Marcia Kelbon, a Quilcene Fire/Rescue District commissioner. “Slow it down.”

The Healthier Together Initiative is a joint effort between Jefferson County, the City of Port Townsend, Jefferson Hospital District, Port Townsend School District, Olympic Peninsula YMCA, Jefferson Aquatic Coalition and the Port of Port Townsend.

The YMCA, which runs the current pool and would administer the new facility, and the Jefferson Aquatic Coalition have agreed to lead the fundraising efforts, and the steering committee hopes to pass a tax before those organizations begin seeking grants.

Those organizations can begin applying for grants in June, said Carrie Hite, Port Townsend’s director of parks and recreation strategy, but they would not be competitive without the public show of support provided by the approval of a tax for the project.


Reporter Peter Segall can be reached at

More in News

Dave Swinford of Sequim, left, and Marlana Ashlie of Victoria take part in a workshop on Saturday about cropping bird photos for best presentation during Saturday’s Olympic Birdfest. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Bird spotting

Dave Swinford of Sequim, left, and Marlana Ashlie of Victoria take part… Continue reading

Annette Nesse, at the Jamestown S’Klallam Tribe’s main campus in Blyn in December 2021, is serving as interim director at the Dungeness River Nature Center, the organization announced. (Emily Matthiessen/for Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Nesse to serve as interim director at River Center

New position to begin May 1; organization will continue its full-time search

Sequim Wheelers, seen on the historic Railroad Bridge near the Dungeness River Nature Center, prep for a ride on the Olympic Discovery Trail. The nonprofit's season begins in May, and it has an open house for potential new volunteers on April 20 at the River Center. It also has an orientation for new volunteers on April 25 at the River Center. (Sequim Wheelers)
Sequim Wheelers gearing up for 2024 rides, seek recruits

Nonprofit looking for help during for 20-week season

Ashlynn Emiliani of Port Angeles, center, tosses woody debris into a pile for collection as volunteers work to clean up a section of hillside above the parking lot of the Red Lion Hotel in Port Angeles on Saturday. More than a dozen members of Elevate PA spent the morning clearing up overgrown areas on the hillside from Haynes Viewpoint to the hotel’s Front Street driveway as part of a city beautification effort. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Hillside cleanup in Port Angeles

Ashlynn Emiliani of Port Angeles, center, tosses woody debris into a pile… Continue reading

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading

Operations set at Bentinck range

The Royal Canadian Navy has announced that the land-based… Continue reading

Pictured, from left, are Wolfe, May, Reader and Emily Fry.
May recognized with BEE award from medical center

Reuben May has received a BEE award from Olympic Medical Center. The… Continue reading

Schools open following contract

PAPEA, district reach tentative agreement

Port Angeles School Superintendent Marty Brewer, second from right, speaks with members of the Port Angeles Parents for Education, on Friday about the Port Angeles Paraeducation Association strike. Assistant Superintendent Michele Olsen stands at right. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
District, PAPEA to pick up bargaining Sunday

Parent group presses officials for answers on strike

Instructor Josh Taylor, left, points out the workings of an electric vehicle on Wednesday at the Auto Technology Certification Program at Peninsula College. Nick Schommer, center, and Brian Selk get ready to do some testing on the electric auto’s parts from underneath the vehicle. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
College’s automotive technology program gets a reboot

Students can earn a certificate separate from two-year degree

Port Townsend transportation tax dollars to be put to work

Benefits district to raise $400,000 to $600,000 in first year