Other officers killed on the North Olympic Peninsula over the years

There is probably no greater outpouring of community grief than when a law enforcement officer dies in the line of duty.

When one who swears to protect the community dies from deadly force, the loss is everyone’s loss.

The kind of collective suffering that last happened in 2000 with the shooting death of Clallam County Sheriff’s Deputy Wally Davis has visited the North Olympic Peninsula three times earlier over the previous 89 years.

Davis was the first law officer in Clallam and Jefferson counties to be shot and killed while on duty.

But the two sheriffs and a town marshal died earlier because of events related to their official duties.

  • Jefferson County Sheriff John McInnis presumably drowned Nov. 5, 1911. His body was never recovered.

  • Clallam County Sheriff William Nelson was the youngest sheriff in Washington when he died March 30, 1924, at age 29.

  • Forks Town Marshal John Weldon Rice died of a heart attack March 18, 1960, after struggling with a man he was putting in jail.

    Rice left a wife, two daughters, 11 and 6 and a son, 9. He was 48 when he died, the same age as Davis.

    Rice had been a logger and worked for the U.S. Forest Service before becoming town marshal.

    During World War II he was an Army demolitions man during savage fighting on Okinawa and Ie Shima.

    His obituary said he loved flowers, animals and the outdoors. He was buried near his mother’s home in Welser, Idaho.

    Nelson was a Beaver native. He died after “a long illness.”

    It was speculated at the time that his health had been damaged by being gassed while serving in World War I and exposure to the elements while watching for bandits and whiskey runners in damp woods.

    That was his modus operandi, to go to great lengths to get the bad guys regardless of the conditions. The man was known as fearless lawman.

    At a young age he learned the use of firearms from his sister, herself a crack shot.

    Nelson joined the Army Corps of Engineers in 1917, survived the trenches, then returned to Beaver, where he became a timber cruiser.

    He was 26 in 1920 when he began serving as sheriff. In 1922 he was elected to a four-year term. He and his wife had a son.

    During his tenure, Nelson captured Discovery Bay murderers Charles Butt and T.H. Riley.

    He forced them to surrender single-handedly in their cabin on the Hoh Trail.

    Nelson once arrested a whiskey runner who threatened to shoot anyone who tried to take him to jail.

    “You have two minutes to decide,” Nelson told him, according to one account. “After that, you are coming along with me one way or the other.”

    The man gave up.

    The American Legion post of Port Angeles conducted Nelson’s funeral.

    McInnes was known as an expert boatsman when he set out from Port Townsend in his tiny boat on the morning of Nov. 5, 1911, a Sunday. He was headed for Point Wilson.

    His cockleshell was found bottom up two miles inside Marrowstone Point, in mid-channel.

    One oar was stuck beneath the rower’s seat and a trolling line dragged the stern.

    A Jefferson County deputy sheriff said McInnes took his revolver and handcuffs. McInnes never carried them unless he was on official business.

    McInnes and the deputy would often search for men running deer with hounds.

    It was believed that McInnes took his trolling line along as a cover tactic, or to fish for salmon while patrolling.

  • More in News

    The aurora borealis, also known as the Northern Lights, illuminate the sky on Friday night into Saturday morning at Hurricane Ridge in Olympic National Park south of Port Angeles. A G5 magnetic storm created conditions for the aurora to be visible to large portions of North America, including hundreds of people who ventured to the ridge to watch the geomagnetic spectacle. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
    Lighting up the sky

    The aurora borealis, also known as the Northern Lights, illuminate the sky… Continue reading

    Revisions to Clallam County's code propose provisions for farms countywide, such as requiring guides for farm tours or clearly marked areas visitors can go. Retail stores are also proposed to be 1,000 square feet or less. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
    Hearing set for farm standards

    Proposal before Clallam County Planning Commission

    194-lot subdivision proposed for Carlsborg property

    Planner: Single largest development in past 20 years

    Port Angeles school board to set up public forum

    Directors to meet with community on budget concerns

    Chimacum man arrested for firing gun during dispute

    66-year-old charged with assault, reckless endangerment

    Firefighters from Clallam County Fire District 3 fought a fire on Friday that damaged a manufactured home in Sequim. (Elliott Jones/Clallam County Fire District 3)
    Sequim manufactured home, garage apartment damaged by fires

    Firefighters stop spread of shop fire on Shore Road

    Sequim Irrigation Festival Royalty, from left, princesses Ashlynn Northaven and Kailah Blake, queen Ariya Goettling and princess Sophia Treece, wave to the Grand Parade crowd on Saturday. (Michael Dashiell/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
    A royal wave

    Sequim Irrigation Festival Royalty, from left, princesses Ashlynn Northaven and Kailah Blake,… Continue reading

    Terrie Comstock of Port Townsend asks questions about a display at the city’s kickoff meeting for its 2025 Comprehensive Plan update at the Marvin G. Shields Memorial Post 26 American Legion Hall on Thursday. The meeting was the first in a series for the update, due at the end of 2025 and required by state law. (Peter Segall/Peninsula Daily News)
    Port Townsend kicks off plan for next 20 years

    City seeking input on comprehensive outlook

    Sequim schools agree to $40K settlement over public records dispute

    District updates policy to ‘beef up’ consultation with third parties

    Chimacum Creek enrolling Transition to Kindergarten program

    Chimacum Creek Primary School is currently enrolling children ages 4½… Continue reading

    Security training exercise set next week

    Naval Magazine Indian Island will conduct a security training… Continue reading

    Alex Toombs of Port Townsend was among the first visitors to the Welcome Center at the Northwest Maritime Center on Thursday.  Diane Urbani de la Paz/For Peninsula Daily News
    Maritime themes highlight new space at campus

    Former PT retail space now welcoming center for visitors