Longtime river guide skeptical of fish restoration

Pat Neal tells Kiwanis some projects do more harm than good

Pat Neal

Pat Neal

PORT ANGELES — Pat Neal has been a fishing guide on the Hoh River for more than 30 years and in that time he’s seen populations of salmon and trout in decline.

There are several efforts to restore fish populations, but Neal is skeptical those projects are having a positive effect.

In many cases, he says, they’re having the opposite.

“To me, these rivers are being managed for extinction,” Neal — who is an historian and preservationist, the author of four books and a humor columnist for the Peninsula Daily News as well as a fishing guide — told a meeting of the Port Angeles Kiwanis Club on Thursday.

“They’ve been managed to the point of endangered species status,” Neal said, “which is a crime to me. It just means that our rivers look more dead than alive to the people managing our fisheries because they’re relying on the endangered species funding for their questionable activities.”

According to Neal, millions of dollars are spent on various restoration projects but fish populations haven’t necessarily recovered.

“I always ask these people where have you brought back a run of fish, well they can’t tell me,” Neal told Peninsula Daily News after his presentation.

“That’s the thing that gets me — with all these millions of dollars — where have you brought a fish run back, anywhere? They can’t tell me, because they haven’t.”

Neal’s observations are considered controversial by those involved in salmon restoration.

He admits his is a cynical view to have, but after spending decades working in the fishing industry on the Olympic Peninsula he said it’s the conclusion he’s drawn.

Fish populations across the Olympic Peninsula are widely variable, but are generally trending downward according to data from the State of Salmon report published by the Washington Recreation and Conservation Office.

The report tracks salmon and steelhead trout species in various regions across the state and for those around the Olympic Peninsula — Puget Sound, Hood Canal and Washington Coast — populations are showing different signs of improvement.

Fish populations on the Hood Canal are showing some positive signs, according to the most recent report, but populations in Puget Sound have remained stagnant for decades. For the Washington Coast region, which includes the Hoh River where Neal lives and works, the report says the number of fish returning is far below potential.

“Washington’s coastal rivers enjoy some of the strongest salmon, steelhead trout, and bull trout populations in the state,” the report said, but that’s still below historic runs.

“Based on historical records, steelhead runs are just 55 percent of their 1950s levels and chum, once the most abundant salmon in Willapa Bay, return at a fraction of historical levels,” the report says.

According to the report, recent trends of the region’s 117 non-listed populations are mixed. Since the 1980s, spring Chinook salmon and steelhead trout have declined in number; coho salmon fluctuate widely in response to ocean conditions such as the 2014-2016 marine heat wave and Fall Chinook and chum salmon returns show no recent trend.

There are several factors that impact fish populations, including ocean temperatures, industrial fishing and spawning habitats, but Neal said efforts to restore the state’s rivers haven’t shown strong results and in some cases may be causing more harm than good.

During his presentation to the club, Neal showed a photo of a man-made log jam built as part of an effort to restore fish spawning habitats.

“There’s a forest along there, they fall the trees into the river, drag it through the steelhead spawning beds, dump the concrete on top of it, and the fish don’t come back to spawn,” Neal said.

An easy solution, according to Neal, would be to allow private landowners to place biodegradable boxes with fertilized fish eggs in creeks on their property to help restore fish populations. Neal said some people are already doing that but it’s currently illegal.

Neal said that local tribes have had success in reintroducing fish populations by using native broodstock.

“The tribes should be running (fish restoration) because they’re the ones that actually produce the fish,” Neal said.

Neal said he gets emotional discussing the issue because he’s been watching the fish populations slowly decline.

“Just watching the extinction, being a witness to extinction, it’s awful, it’s like watching the buffalo disappear,” Neal said, “and everybody’s saying we’re doing all we can to save them. I’m not seeing that.”


Reporter Peter Segall can be reached at peter.segall@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

A pair of Clallam Transit buses sit at The Gateway Transit Center in Port Angeles in preparation for their fixed-route runs on Thursday. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Clallam Transit sees large rise in ridership

No issues seen with new zero-fare policy

Plans move ahead for Quilcene skate park

Jefferson County, volunteers seek grants

Peninsula College Foundation reports record levels of giving

Programs, students both recipients of funds

County to repave section of Carlsborg Road

Clallam County commissioners will consider awarding a contract for… Continue reading

A paving crew from Lakeside Industries replaces pavement on the Waterfront Trail and the entrance to the Port Angeles City Pier parking lot on Wednesday as part of a project to improve sidewalks and storm water drainage around the site. The project is expected to be substantially completed and the parking lot reopened by mid-March. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Port Angeles City Pier

A paving crew from Lakeside Industries replaces pavement on the Waterfront Trail… Continue reading

Port Townsend approves utility rate changes, renames skate park

Public hearing set for Transportation Benefits District

Slate of initiatives has upended Olympia, lobbyist says

‘Potential showstoppers’ described at Coffee with Colleen

Artist Chris Stevenson, who described herself as an urban sketcher from Port Townsend, uses a pencil for scale as she sketches the work at the new entrance to Point Hudson Marina on Monday morning. A group in town, the Port Townsend Urban Sketchers will meet at 10 a.m. Saturday to sketch at the Port Townsend Aero Museum. Sessions are free and open to sketchers of all skill levels. For more information, see www.urbansketchersporttownsend.wordpress.com. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Marina art

Artist Chris Stevenson, who described herself as an urban sketcher from Port… Continue reading

The site of the former Rayonier mill in Port Angeles, shown on Tuesday, awaits completion of environmental cleanup almost 27 years after the last roll of pulp rolled off the line. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Cleanup at Rayonier site still years away

Action plan to be approved in 2024-25

About 25 people, including Warren Musgrove of Port Angeles, far right, rallied in support of Palestine on Saturday in front of the Clallam County Courthouse. The event, also scheduled to run from noon to 1 p.m. this Saturday and March 2, included an information table that provided information about the history of occupation in the Gaza Strip, organizer Christy Cox said. (Lois Danks)
Rally for Rafah

About 25 people, including Warren Musgrove of Port Angeles, far right, rallied… Continue reading