Guilty pleas entered for raping three girls

One an Alford plea; man could face four years in prison

PORT ANGELES — A former Port Angeles man who pleaded guilty this week to raping two 14-year-old girls and a 15-year-old girl in 2019 and 2020 will be sentenced Nov. 16.

Justin Michael Thayer, 21, of Edmonds could serve four years in prison. He entered the pleas Tuesday to two counts of third-degree child rape and one charge of third-degree rape for assaulting the third victim who was 15 at the time. Her age was within four years of Thayer’s.

Thayer pleaded guilty under an Alford plea to the third-degree rape charge in order to take advantage of a plea offer, stating his innocence but asserting he could be convicted if tried.

The victim and Thayer had been friends for about a year, she told Deputy Marc Titterness of the Clallam County Sheriff’s office.

Thayer’s trial on four charges of third-degree child rape and one charge of second-degree rape-forcible compulsion had been scheduled for Oct. 11.

Under the plea agreement, in which two rape cases against Thayer were combined into one, four Clallam County Sheriff’s Office cases and one Port Angeles Police Department case will not be pursued.

Information on those allegations was not available from the two agencies late Wednesday afternoon.

Thayer could be sentenced to four years in prison on each count and 36 months of community custody under a recommendation from the Clallam County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office. The sentences would run concurrently.

Thayer’s standard sentence range is 46-60 months on each child rape charge and 41-54 months on the third-degree rape charge.

Third-degree rape, a Class C felony, occurs when there is not consent to sexual intercourse or if there is a threat of substantial harm to the victim’s property rights.

Third-degree child rape, a Class C felony, occurs when a person has sexual intercourse with someone who is between 14-16 years old and the perpetrator is at least four years older than the victim.

Two of the girls, who were friends, said they were passed out or near passing out when Thayer assaulted them, according to a probable cause statement in one case.

A third said Thayer raped her after she told him to stop. Thayer admitted he had a sexual relationship with her, according to the probable cause statement in the other case.

Thayer assaulted them between April 25, 2019-May 15, 2020.

Superior Court Judge Lauren Erickson ordered a pre-sentence investigation.

Thayer, who was on electronic home monitoring, was handcuffed and incarcerated in the Clallam County jail without bail pending his sentencing.


Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 55650, or at pgottlieb@

More in News

Dave Swinford of Sequim, left, and Marlana Ashlie of Victoria take part in a workshop on Saturday about cropping bird photos for best presentation during Saturday’s Olympic Birdfest. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Bird spotting

Dave Swinford of Sequim, left, and Marlana Ashlie of Victoria take part… Continue reading

Annette Nesse, at the Jamestown S’Klallam Tribe’s main campus in Blyn in December 2021, is serving as interim director at the Dungeness River Nature Center, the organization announced. (Emily Matthiessen/for Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Nesse to serve as interim director at River Center

New position to begin May 1; organization will continue its full-time search

Sequim Wheelers, seen on the historic Railroad Bridge near the Dungeness River Nature Center, prep for a ride on the Olympic Discovery Trail. The nonprofit's season begins in May, and it has an open house for potential new volunteers on April 20 at the River Center. It also has an orientation for new volunteers on April 25 at the River Center. (Sequim Wheelers)
Sequim Wheelers gearing up for 2024 rides, seek recruits

Nonprofit looking for help during for 20-week season

Ashlynn Emiliani of Port Angeles, center, tosses woody debris into a pile for collection as volunteers work to clean up a section of hillside above the parking lot of the Red Lion Hotel in Port Angeles on Saturday. More than a dozen members of Elevate PA spent the morning clearing up overgrown areas on the hillside from Haynes Viewpoint to the hotel’s Front Street driveway as part of a city beautification effort. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Hillside cleanup in Port Angeles

Ashlynn Emiliani of Port Angeles, center, tosses woody debris into a pile… Continue reading

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading

Operations set at Bentinck range

The Royal Canadian Navy has announced that the land-based… Continue reading

Pictured, from left, are Wolfe, May, Reader and Emily Fry.
May recognized with BEE award from medical center

Reuben May has received a BEE award from Olympic Medical Center. The… Continue reading

Schools open following contract

PAPEA, district reach tentative agreement

Port Angeles School Superintendent Marty Brewer, second from right, speaks with members of the Port Angeles Parents for Education, on Friday about the Port Angeles Paraeducation Association strike. Assistant Superintendent Michele Olsen stands at right. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
District, PAPEA to pick up bargaining Sunday

Parent group presses officials for answers on strike

Instructor Josh Taylor, left, points out the workings of an electric vehicle on Wednesday at the Auto Technology Certification Program at Peninsula College. Nick Schommer, center, and Brian Selk get ready to do some testing on the electric auto’s parts from underneath the vehicle. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
College’s automotive technology program gets a reboot

Students can earn a certificate separate from two-year degree

Port Townsend transportation tax dollars to be put to work

Benefits district to raise $400,000 to $600,000 in first year