Demolition plans affecting two 19th century Port Townsend houses prompt fears of losing historic character

PORT TOWNSEND — Demolition permits filed for two older homes on Fillmore Street have stirred concerns about the city losing its historic flavor.

The Jefferson County Historical Society and several residents have written letters to the city’s Development Services Department protesting a partial demolition permit filed for 535 Fillmore, which was built about 1860, and for a full demolition permit filed for 308 Fillmore St., which was built around 1888.

“I saw those two notices being posted, and I realized I was seeing the footprint of our community changing,” said Linda Maguire, one resident who wrote a letter.

“It’s another change creeping in through the door.”

It isn’t that the permits wouldn’t be legal, said Bill Tennent, director of the Jefferson County Historical Society.

“In this community, the only buildings that are protected are the commercial buildings, and not residential buildings,” Tennent said.

But if too many homes in the district are altered or destroyed, there is a chance that Port Townsend’s national historic district classification will be lost, he said.

Tennent said that while two homes would not change the historical classification, the razing of old buildings takes its toll on the town.

“Once that is gone, it’s gone. We don’t get it back,” he said.

The society drafted two letters to John McDonagh, city development services department planner, registering its concerns.

Letters giving public comment, which were due by Tuesday, and plans for demolition will be weighed against the city’s moratorium on razing historic buildings.

More in News

Police and rescue workers surround the scene of a disturbance on Friday morning at Chase Bank at Front and Laurel streets in downtown Port Angeles that resulted in a fatal shooting and the closure of much of the downtown area. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
One person dead in officer-involved shooting

Police activity blocks intersection in downtown Port Angeles

May Day celebration in Sequim

The Puget Sound WA Branch of the Party for Socialism… Continue reading

A mountain goat dangles from a helicopter in Olympic National Park south of Port Angeles on Sept. 13, 2018. Helicopters and trucks relocated hundreds of mountain goats from Olympic National Park in an effort officials said will protect natural resources, reduce visitor safety issues and boost native goat populations elsewhere in Washington state. (Jesse Major /Peninsula Daily News)
Few survivors remain after relocation to North Cascades

Tracking data show most died within five years

Clallam to pause on trust land request

Lack of sales could impact taxing districts

Hospital to ask for levy lid lift

OMC seeking first hike since 2008

Paving to begin on North Sequim Avenue

Work crews from Interwest Construction and Agate Asphalt will begin… Continue reading

Kyle Zimmerman, co-owner of The Hub at Front and Lincoln streets in downtown Port Angeles, adds a new coat of paint on Wednesday to an advertising sign on the back of his building that was uncovered during the demolition of a derelict building that once hid the sign from view. Zimmerman said The Hub, formerly Mathews Glass and Howe's Garage before that, is being converted to an artist's workspace and entertainment venue with an opening set for late May or early June. Although The Hub will have no control over any new construction that might later hide the automotive signs, Zimmerman said restoring the paint is an interesting addition to the downtown area for as long as it lasts. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Paint restoration in Port Angeles

Kyle Zimmerman, co-owner of The Hub at Front and Lincoln streets in… Continue reading

Open house set for estuary project

Representatives will be at Brinnon Community Center

Port of Port Townsend considers moorage exemptions

Effort to preserve maritime heritage

Anderson Lake closed due to Anatoxin-A

The state Parks and Recreation Commission has closed Anderson… Continue reading

John Brewer.
Remembrance event set next month for John Brewer

Former publisher, editor was in charge of Peninsula Daily News for 17 years

Smoke rises on Tuesday morning from the site of a baled cardboard fire that broke out late Monday night at the McKinley Paper Company on Marine Drive in Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
No injuries following fire at McKinley paper mill

The Port Angeles Fire Department responded to a fire… Continue reading