Elk stand in a field at the Olympic Game Farm. The Game Farm is not accredited to possess Roosevelt Elk. (Jesse MajorPeninsula Daily News)

Elk stand in a field at the Olympic Game Farm. The Game Farm is not accredited to possess Roosevelt Elk. (Jesse MajorPeninsula Daily News)

Federal judge denies Olympic Game Farm’s motion to dismiss portions of lawsuit

Animal Legal Defense Fund gains legal victory as complaint moves forward

TACOMA — The Animal Legal Defense Fund was handed its first legal victory in its federal lawsuit alleging animal mistreatment at the Olympic Game Farm when a federal judge rejected the Game Farm’s motion to dismiss certain elements of the lawsuit.

The Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) sued Olympic Game Farm in December, alleging that the Sequim-area business is in violation of the Endangered Species Act and asking the court to require the Game Farm to give up its endangered or threatened species to a sanctuary.

The Game Farm filed a motion in March to dismiss the state public nuisance and animal cruelty claims, saying state law does not recognize private cause of action to enforce cruelty laws.

U.S. District Judge Ronald Leighton wrote in his order last week that the Game Farm isolating the public nuisance claim from the lawsuit was “an attempt to prune this ‘Bonsai tree’ with tweezers and fingernail clippers.”

Bonsai trees are cared for using many different special tools.

This decision allows the lawsuit to move forward in whole. The parties are required to hold a settlement conference no later than Feb. 26, 2020, enter into mediation by March, 31, 2020, and prepare for trial which is scheduled for May 4, 2020.

Leighton wrote that the Game Farm already has admitted to violating state law by possessing Roosevelt elk. State law makes it illegal for a non-accredited facility to posses that species, he wrote.

“ALDF has alleged that Defendants’ failure to abide by the federal Endangered Species Act, as well as alleged violations of Washington State animal cruelty laws creates a public nuisance,” Leighton wrote in his order.

“Defendants admit one of these allegations, namely that they are not accredited but ‘possess or display Roosevelt Elk.’”

The order says that the state limits who can bring a public nuisance claim, but for a private party to bring a public nuisance claim the party must show special injury that is distinct from what has been suffered by the general public.

The state Supreme Court reviewed the provision last year and explained that the special injury requirement “is not a particularly high bar” and “[i]njury to the aesthetic appeal and environment of an area is sufficient to support standing if the plaintiff establishes that he or she uses that area for recreational purposes,” according to the order.

When ruling on the motion to dismiss, the judge is required to rule as if accepting all facts alleged by the other side are true and provable.

“ALDF is a public interest organization whose members have been ‘specially injured’ by Defendant’s nuisance because, as animal lovers and advocates, they visited the OGF for recreational purposes based on the mistaken belief that OGF was caring for exotic animals, when in fact, OGF is mistreating and abusing those animals, which left ALDF’s members emotionally upset and unable to return to OGF for recreational enjoyment,” Leighton wrote.

“The harms alleged by ALDF’s members are sufficiently distinct from the general public to satisfy the standing requirements of [state law]. ALDF’s members would return to OGF for their recreational enjoyment if the housing conditions improved, or they would visit the animals if they were moved to a law-abiding sanctuary.”

________

Reporter Jesse Major can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 56250, or at jmajor@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Port Angeles teachers’ union votes to honor paraeducators’ picket line on April 8

Members of the Port Angeles Education Association voted overwhelmingly… Continue reading

Funding needed for Port Townsend homeless shelter

Operation at Legion Hall to close April 30

Port of Port Angeles renews lease for Composite Recycling Technology Center

Agreement covers 26,000 square feet at airport business park

Fire district volunteers lauded

Clallam County Fire District No. 3 recently recognized seven members… Continue reading

Clallam to continue providing deputy to Forks

Contract includes wages, mileage and maintenance reimbursement

Maintenance closes section of Olympic Discovery Trail

A portion of the Olympic Discovery Trail is closed… Continue reading

Hanna Paoluccu of Alexander, N.Y., and Rosie Berg of Nevada City, Calif., members of the Hood Canal Salmon Enhancement Group and working with the Jefferson County Noxious Weed Board, remove poisonous hemlock weed from along the Larry Scott Trail in Port Townsend on Monday. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Poison hemlock removal in Port Townsend

Hanna Paoluccu of Alexander, N.Y., and Rosie Berg of Nevada City, Calif.,… Continue reading

YMCA to build childcare facility

$1-2M still needed for $6.7M project

Port Townsend Police Department recognizes award recipients

The Port Townsend Police Department recognized officers, employees, volunteers… Continue reading

Port Angeles High School evacuated due to bomb threat

Nothing suspicious found, principal says

A tree that has grown out of its tree box and shattered a nearby curb and sidewalk in the 100 block of North Oak Street is among those targeted for removal and replacement in downtown Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Port Angeles tree and sidewalk replacement to begin Monday

The Port Angeles downtown tree and sidewalk replacement project… Continue reading

Grant for Forks treatment plant to be discussed

The Clallam County Opportunity Fund Advisory Board will discuss… Continue reading