Clallam County files charges against Midway Metals

Scrapyard owners cited for dumping, nuisance issues

PORT ANGELES — Clallam County prosecutors have filed charges against the owners of Midway Metals, a waste facility on U.S. Highway 101 east of Port Angeles, for failure to comply with environmental remediation orders.

The county has been in negotiations with owners Katrina Haymaker and Jason Hesseltine for several years, but until recently had not sought criminal charges. Sheriff Bill Benedict said in an interview Tuesday that he has personally tried to work with Haymaker to resolve issues at the site.

“I have attempted to work with them and even assist them in getting the right permits,” Benedict said. “She has $30,000 to $40,000 in fines that she’s made no effort to pay.”

Haymaker did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

A court appearance is scheduled for 9 a.m. Oct. 7, in Clallam County District Court I.

Midway Metals sits on more than 2 acres at 258010 Highway 101 near Barr Road east of Port Angeles.

According to an email last week from Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Patrick Murphy, Haymaker and Hesseltine were charged with unlawful dumping or depositing of solid waste under state law and one count of public nuisance under the county code.

Both Haymaker, who lives in Port Orchard, and Hesseltine were charged with the same two-count criminal complaint, Murphy said.

The unlawful dumping charge is what’s known as a “gross misdemeanor,” punishable by up to 364 days in jail and a maximum fine of $5,000.

Under state law, the owners also can be held accountable for a cleanup restitution payment that must be greater than twice the actual cost of removing and properly disposing of the litter, or $100 per cubic foot of litter.

The law states half the restitution payment goes to the landowner where the littering occurred and the other half to the jurisdictional health department investigating the incident.

However, because in this case the landowners contributed to the littering, they will not be eligible for any restitution payments, Murphy said, and the full amount will go to cleaning up the site.

The state Department of Ecology has documentation showing contamination at the site dating back to 2008, and county officials have in the past tried to work with the owners to remediate the site.

Hearing Examiner Andrew Reeves ruled in 2019 that Katrina Haymaker, owner of Midway Metals at 258010 U.S. Highway 101, was in violation of Title 7 of the county code and fined her $750.

A cleanup effort started in 2021, but in July, Benedict forwarded a criminal referral to the prosecutor’s office, citing continued violations.

Benedict previously told Peninsula Daily News the referral came after years of trying to work with the owners, the county and the state on issues like illegal dumping, soil contamination and consistent violations of county and state solid waste ordinances.

“The (Midway Metals) Site contains tons of solid waste that has been unlawfully dumped onto the property and solid waste continues to be unlawfully dumped onto the site,” the Clallam County Board of Commissioners wrote in a Cease and Desist order in January 2021.

“Despite all of the County’s efforts to convince you to abate the violations, you have not done so,” Commissioners wrote.

The letter claims that in addition to the dumping violations, the site is not permitted — nor eligible to be permitted — for a waste disposal facility.


Reporter Peter Segall can be reached at

More in News

Erin Kluck of Port Townsend watches as her son Kaspar, 4, gives Santa Claus a high five during Saturday’s Uptown Port Townsend Farmers Market. Santa, aka Bryan Hood, said he’ll be manning the Crusty Crumb bakery table again, as the last two farmers markets of the year happen this Saturday and on Dec. 17. (Diane Urbani de la Paz/For Peninsula Daily News)
Give me five

Erin Kluck of Port Townsend watches as her son Kaspar, 4, gives… Continue reading

Santa, Christopher Thomsen, holds Lizzie on Sunday at Airport Garden and Nursery in Port Angeles as part of a fundraiser for the Peninsula Friends of Animals. More than a dozen dogs, some more wiggly than others, sat in Santa’s lap for a photo. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Furry fundraiser

Santa, Christopher Thomsen, holds Lizzie on Sunday at Airport Garden and Nursery… Continue reading

Woman files suit against Olympic Medical Center

She cites behavior of former physician

Utility upgrades to close campground at Heart O’ the Hills next year

Project to replace water pipes could be finished in June

Repair shop to close Dec. 23

The Recyclery to focus on cycling programs

Chamber of Jefferson County aims to bring back its Young Professionals group

Members sought for task force that will help relaunch vision

First Fed Foundation awards $400,000 in fall grants

First Fed Foundation has awarded 22 organizations a total… Continue reading

2022 Woman of Excellence to be announced

The Port Townsend branch of the American Association of… Continue reading

Jefferson Transit to discuss board composition

The Jefferson Transit Authority Board will discuss the composition… Continue reading

Most Read