Lawmakers seek revisions to wrongful death and injury statutes

  • By Sean Harding WNPA Olympia News Bureau
  • Monday, January 28, 2019 2:46pm
  • Politics

By Sean Harding

WNPA Olympia News Bureau

OLYMPIA — A proposal prompted by the 2015 “Ride the Ducks” wreck on the Aurora Bridge in Seattle came one step closer to becoming law last week as people voiced their views on changes to the state’s wrongful death and injury statutes that would expand the beneficiaries entitled to claim damages.

“The law currently does not allow a nonresident parent to seek justice,” said the bill’s sponsor, Rep. Sharon Santos, D-Seattle, on Wednesday. “It was a law that was established more than 100 years ago.”

Santos said the changes were prompted by the collision between a Ride the Ducks tourist vehicle and a chartered school bus carrying students from North Seattle College in 2015, which killed five international students and injured more than 60 other people.

Santos’ bill would allow parents to claim a wrongful death regardless of their residency.

OMC’s worries

“Our concern regarding HB 1135 is not with the residency requirement. We absolutely support that change in the law,” said Jennifer Burkhardt, chief human resources officer and general counsel at Olympic Medical Center in Port Angeles.

“Our concern is with the other changes that increase legal exposure and will lead to increases in insurance premiums.”

Several organizations expressed concern with Washington’s “joint and several liability” rule, which says if one party is found 1 percent liable for a cause of action, they would still be 100 percent liable for damages if other liable parties were unable to pay.

Expanding the number of beneficiaries would increase liability insurance premiums, Burkhardt said.

“There is the possibility that we are held to a much greater amount of damages than we should be under this particular law,” she said. “And further expanding it to include non-economic damages and some of the other expansions would make this even more unfair to an organization that is already struggling to maintain stability for the community.”

Other provisions allow parents of adult children to seek recoveries if they had “significant involvement” in the child’s life. Under current law, parent may not seek wrongful death claims if they are not financially dependent on the adult child.

“This is my son Bradley,” Lake Stevens resident Deanna Hogue told the committee, fighting back tears as she held up a picture of her son taken three days before he was killed while working at Pacific Topsoils. She said Bradley died after his supervisor ordered him to step in the back of a bark-blowing truck with a defective auger.

In 2016, The Seattle Times reported that the King County prosecuting attorney took the “rare” step of filing criminal charges against Pacific Topsoils for “willfully and knowingly” violating safety laws.

Because Bradley was 19 at the time of the accident and his parents did not depend on him financially, they were not able to sue for wrongful death.

“Imagine, for those of you who are parents, receiving this soul-crushing news,” Hogue said. “Then imagine learning you had no legal rights to hold these people accountable for the preventable death of your child.”

In both the current and proposed version of the law, a parent is not eligible for damages if the adult child has a domestic partner, spouse or children.

The proposal would allow each parent to file separate claims regardless of marital status, and expands the damages that may be claimed, including anxiety, loss of emotional support and humiliation.

HB 1135 is retroactive and if passed, would apply to all claims that are not time barred and all claims pending in court on the date the legislation becomes effective.

The bill is scheduled to enter an executive session Friday.


This story is part of a series of news reports from the Washington State Legislature provided through a reporting internship sponsored by the Washington Newspaper Publishers Association Foundation.

More in Politics

Peninsula hospitals oppose staffing legislation

Proposal would require set ratios for nurses to patients

Derek Kilmer.
Fix Congress panel expires, but chair hopes work will continue

Kilmer led effort to improve lawmaking body

Utah reports law improved safety

By Paul Gottlieb Special to Peninsula Daily News Washington’s new DUI law… Continue reading

Bill would tighten DUI limit

Peninsula law enforcement reacts to proposed legislation

Abortion measures among early bill filings

State Legislature opens its biennial budget season

Paul Gottlieb.
Special legislative coverage

Former Senior Reporter Paul Gottlieb has been coaxed out… Continue reading

Bill Peach, left, and Mike French.
County hopefuls await ballot counts

French leads Peach in race for Clallam commissioner position

Greg Brotherton, left, and Marcia Kelbon.
Brotherton leads Kelbon for county seat

Incumbent has 68 percent of vote; challenger awaiting more counts