Whaling trial judge dismisses hunters’ religion defense

TACOMA — A federal magistrate has denied a defense attorney’s motions to dismiss charges against two Makah whale hunters whose trial is scheduled to begin Tuesday.

The attorney, Jack Fiander of Yakima, represents Andy Noel, who along with Wayne Johnson turned down a plea bargain that their three co-defendants accepted late last month.

Pending a final pretrial hearing scheduled for 3 p.m. Monday, the trial will start at 9 a.m. Tuesday with selection of 12 jurors and two alternates from a pool of 44 to 60 people.

Fiander had moved for dismissal of the misdemeanor charges for lack of federal jurisdiction, and for infringing on the defendants’ freedom of religion and violating the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993.

He argued that the hunt of a gray whale last Sept. 8 — in violation of the federal Marine Mammal Protection Act — had started in Makah tribal waters outside federal jurisdiction.

The whale was harpooned at least four times and shot at least 16 times off Seal Rock in the Strait of Juan de Fuca near Neah Bay.

It died in the Strait more than nine hours after it was wounded.

All five men also face charges in Makah Tribal Court that together could give them one-year jail sentences and $5,000 fines.

More in News

Fred Lundahl, a pilot from Whidbey Island, prepares to fuel up his 1968 Cessna Aerobat, named Scarlett, at the Jefferson County International Airport in Port Townsend. Lundahl was picking up his plane Wednesday from Tailspin Tommy’s Aircraft Repair facility located at the airport. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Fueling up

Fred Lundahl, a pilot from Whidbey Island, prepares to fuel up his… Continue reading

After hours pet clinic set for Peninsula

Opening June 6 at Sequim location

Five to be honored with community service awards

Ceremony set Thursday at Port Angeles Senior Community Center

PASD planning for expanding needs

Special education, homelessness, new facilities under discussion

Clallam County Sheriff’s Office Animal Control Deputy Ed Bauck
Clallam Sheriff appoints animal control deputy

Position was vacant since end of 2024

Highway 104 road work to start week

Maintenance crews will repair road surfaces on state Highway… Continue reading

Supreme Court says no to recall reconsider

Sequim man found liable for legal fees

Chimacum Ridge seeks board members

Members to write policy, balance values, chair says

Fire destroys shop east of Port Angeles

A fire on Hickory Street east of Port Angeles… Continue reading

Jefferson Transit Authority to expand Kingston Express route

Jefferson Transit Authority has announced expanded service on its… Continue reading

From left to right, Northwest School of Wooden Boatbuilding students Krystol Pasecznyk and Scott McNair sand a Prothero Sloop with Sean Koomen, the school’s boat building program director. Koomen said the sanding would take one person a few days. He said the plan is to have 12 people sand it together, which will take a few hours. (Elijah Sussman/Peninsula Daily News)
Wooden boatbuilding school building ‘Twin Boats’

Students using traditional and cold-moulding construction techniques