State Supreme Court upholds conviction, death sentence

  • By Martha Bellisle The Associated Press
  • Friday, April 13, 2018 8:49am
  • News
Conner Schierman

Conner Schierman

By Martha Bellisle

The Associated Press

SEATTLE — The state Supreme Court on Thursday upheld the conviction and death sentence of a Kirkland man who killed two women and two children in 2006 and then tried to cover up the murders by setting the house on fire.

In a divided 254-page opinion, the justices affirmed the conviction of Conner Schierman. The justices upheld his death sentence in a 6-3 vote.

Schierman was sentenced to death in 2010 after being convicted of murdering Olga Milkin, her 5-year-old son Justin, 3-year-old son Andrew and her sister, Lyubov Botvina. Olga Milkin’s husband, Leonid Milkin, was serving with the National Guard in Iraq at the time of the slayings.

Schierman raised multiple challenges to his conviction, claiming his constitutional rights were violated during the jury selection process. He also claimed evidence was withheld during the penalty phase, but the justices ultimately rejected those points.

King County Prosecutor Dan Satterberg said the ruling was the first hurdle in what will likely be years of appeals in both state and federal court.

“It’s important to remember that Leonid Milkin is a man who lost everything while he was serving the country in the military,” Satterberg said. “He is supportive of the death penalty in this matter and we continue to pursue it, as it continues to be the law of the state.”

On July 17, 2006, officials responded to a fire at the Milkin home. Once the fire was out, they discovered the bodies of the women and children, who had been stabbed to death.

An investigation traced an accelerant and other evidence to Schierman, who claimed he was in the home at the time, but had suffered an alcohol blackout. He said he found the bodies when he woke up. He said he showered, changed his clothes and decided to burn down the house.

Schierman claimed his rights were violated while the jury was being selected because he wasn’t present during some discussions about releasing some of the panel.

Justice Sheryl McCloud, who wrote the lead opinion, agreed that violations occurred, but said any error was harmless, so his conviction should stand.

However, McCloud said two rulings during the penalty phase of Schierman’s trial require his death sentence to be reversed. Chief Justice Mary Fairhurst agreed with McCloud.

Justice Barbara Madsen agreed with McCloud’s opinion, and wrote a separate opinion saying the death sentence was “disproportionate” compared to similar cases. She said state law requires the high court to review the sentence.

“Based on the information that is now available and considering the statutory review required by the legislature, I find the sentence of death in this case disproportionate to the penalties imposed in similar cases,” she said. “I would affirm the conviction in this case but reverse the sentence of death.”

Justices Mary Yu, Steven Gonzalez and Charles Wiggins agreed that the conviction and sentence should be affirmed, but disagreed that the sentence was “disproportionate.”

Much of the debate in the lengthy dissents and concurrences centered on whether the high court had been correct in the past to conclude that minor mistakes made during the trial should not automatically result in the reversal of a convection and/or sentence.

“A majority of this court agrees that justice demands we affirm Schierman’s convictions, but a differently comprised majority of this court unanimously agrees that our precedent precludes us from doing so,” Yu wrote. “In this direct conflict between justice and precedent, justice must prevail.”

More in News

Special Olympian Deni Isett, center, holds a ceremonial torch with Clallam County Sheriff Brian King, right, accompanied by Lt. Jim Thompson of the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribal Police on a leg of the Law Enforcement Torch Run on the Olympic Discovery Trail at Port Angeles City Pier. Tuesday’s segment of the run, conducted mostly by area law enforcement agencies, was organized to support Special Olympics Washington and was to culminate with a community celebration at 7 Cedars Casino in Blyn. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Carrying the torch

Special Olympian Deni Isett, center, holds a ceremonial torch with Clallam County… Continue reading

Hopefuls for Olympic Medical Center board debate

Talk focuses on funds, partnership

An encapsulated engineered coupler used to repair a January leak. The leak occurred along a similar welded joint near to the current leak. (City of Port Townsend)
Port Townsend considers emergency repair for pipeline

Temporary fix needs longer-term solution, officials say

Traffic to be stopped for new bridge girders

Work crews for the state Department of Transportation will unload… Continue reading

The Peninsula Crisis Response Team responded with two armored vehicles on Tuesday when a 37-year-old Sequim man barricaded himself in a residence in the 200 block of Village Lane in Sequim. (Clallam County Sheriff’s Office)
Man barricaded with rifle arrested

Suspect had fired shots in direction of deputies, sheriff says

An interior view of the 12-passenger, all-electric hydrofoil ferry before it made a demonstration run on Port Townsend Bay on Saturday. Standing in the aisle is David Tyler, the co-founder and managing director of Artemis Technologies, the designer and builder of the carbon fiber boat. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Demonstration provides glimpse of potential for ferry service

Battery-powered hydrofoil could open water travel

Electronic edition of newspaper set for Thursday holiday

Peninsula Daily News will have an electronic edition only… Continue reading

Juliet Shidler, 6, tries on a flower-adorned headband she made with her mother, Rachel Shidler of Port Angeles, during Saturday’s Summertide celebration in Webster’s Woods sculpture park at the Port Angeles Fine Arts Center. The event, which marks the beginning of the summer season, featured food, music, crafts and other activities for youths and adults. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Summertide festival

Juliet Shidler, 6, tries on a flower-adorned headband she made with her… Continue reading

Law enforcement agencies to participate in Torch Run

Clallam County law enforcement agencies will participate in the… Continue reading

Crews contain wildland fire near Fisher Cove Road

Crews from Clallam County Fire District 2 quickly contained… Continue reading

Crescent School senior Audrey Gales, right, looks at the homemade regalia worn by fellow senior Hayden Horn on Saturday. Gales had a handmade Native American cap ready for her graduation. Seventeen Crescent students graduated during traditional ceremonies in the school gym. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Crescent graduation

Crescent School senior Audrey Gales, right, looks at the homemade regalia worn… Continue reading

Pertussis cases see 25-fold increase statewide in 2024

The state Department of Health reported an increase in pertussis… Continue reading