State historian thinks tribal religion weighed heaviest in decision to scrap graving yard project

OLYMPIA — It wasn’t archaeological discoveries that stopped the Hood Canal Bridge graving yard in Port Angeles. It was religion.

That’s according to Allyson Brooks, head of the state Department of Archaeology & Historic Preservation and the state historic preservation officer.

In a letter to auditors who examined the graving yard project cancellation, she said the state Transportation Department’s yielding to the Lower Elwha Klallam tribe’s religious values — not archaeological concerns — ended the project.

Tribal members declined to discuss those beliefs with the PDN because of their lawsuit against the state and the secrecy of negotiations over the future of the graving yard site.

However, they previously have said privately that their ancestors are tangibly — even audibly — present in their lives.

Those ancestors are angry over having their remains excavated from their resting place at Tse-whit-zen, the ancient Klallam village that underlies the graving yard site beneath 6 feet of fill, the Lower Elwha.

Remains removed

The intact remains of 337 people were removed and placed in handmade cedar boxes before archaeological exploration stopped at the site and the graving yard was closed late in 2004.

In its lawsuit, the Lower Elwha demand to return those bones to Tse-whit-zen, to sift skeletal fragments from soil that was dug from the graving yard, and to return those partial remains, too, to the village site.

Tribal members daub red ochre below their eyes when they visit the site to ward off ancestors’ anger, and they ceremonially wash with water containing snowberries when they leave the site to avoid taking the ill will home.

Even so, Lower Elwha say they suffer physical and psychological distress at the site on Port Angeles Harbor near the crook of Ediz Hook.

Honored at canoe journey

Their belief that the ancestors are near was never clearer than at last summer’s Tribal Canoe Journey that the Lower Elwha hosted.

Canoe pullers — or paddlers — repeatedly and candidly spoke of feeling and hearing the ancestors both on the waters of the Strait of Juan de Fuca and at Tse-whit-zen.

One man, standing at the mouth of the Elwha River as Lower Elwha pullers sent their cedar canoe over the bar, said he could hear the ancestors laughing with joy.

According to Brooks’ letter — dated June 30 but not made available to the PDN until last week — “the underlying issue . . . is how we incorporate cultural values and religious beliefs into our decision-making processes in a manner that is fair, sensitive, constitutional and still results in a complete project.”

Sophisticated archaeological and geological exploration can find burial sites, she wrote, “but once we incorporate religious values and beliefs, then there are no longer any guarantees. . . .

“We need to do a better job of determining in advance how far we are willing to go and whether we are willing to go this far again and again and again.”

More in News

Sequim Irrigation Festival royalty candidates for 2026 include, from left, Tilly Woods, Emma Rhodes, Brayden Baritelle and Caroline Caudle. 
Keith Ross/Keith’s Frame of Mind
Four to compete for scholarships as Irrigation Festival royalty

Program set Saturday at Sequim High School

Dr. Bri Butler, Jamestown S’Klallam Tribe Family Dental Clinic dental director, stands in one of the pediatric rooms of the clinic she helped develop. The tribe is planning to move its Blyn clinic into Sequim to expand both pediatric and adult services. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Jamestown Tribe plans to move dental clinic to Sequim

Sequim building would host both children, adults

Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group
David Herbelin, executive director of Olympic Theatre Arts, is stepping down from the role. He was diagnosed with colorectal cancer in spring 2022, and although he has survived various prognosis timelines, the disease has spread. Herbelin will stay on as a part-time consultant for a few months as OTA’s board of trustees seeks his replacement.
Olympic Theatre Arts director resigns position

Herbelin plans to spend time with family after cancer diagnosis

Kathryn Sherrill of Bellevue zeros in on a flock of brants, a goose-like bird that migrates as far south as Baja California, that had just landed in the Salish Sea at Point Hudson in Port Townsend. Sherrill drove to the area this week specifically to photograph birds. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Brants party

Kathryn Sherrill of Bellevue zeros in on a flock of brants, a… Continue reading

The Port Angeles High School jazz band, led by Jarrett Hansen, placed first in its division on Feb. 6 at the Quincy Square Jazz Festival at Olympic College in Bremerton.
Port Angeles High School jazz band places first at competition

Roughriders win division at Quincy Square festival

EYE ON THE PENINSULA: Peninsula boards set to meet next week

Meetings across the North Olympic Peninsula

Port Townsend Art Commission accepting grant applications

The Port Townsend Arts Commission is accepting applications for… Continue reading

Chimacum Creek early education program could see cuts this year

Governor’s budget says reducing slots could save state $19.5 million

Port Angeles turns off its license plate-reading cameras

City waiting for state legislation on issue

4PA volunteers Kathy and Vern Daugaard pick up litter on the edge of the Tumwater Truck Route this week. 4PA is a nonprofit organization dedicated to a clean and safe community. The efforts of staff and volunteers have resulted in the Touchstone Campus Project, which is being constructed in the 200 block of East First Street, with transitional housing for Port Angeles’ most vulnerable residents. Those interested in volunteering or donating can visit 4PA.org. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Volunteer work

4PA volunteers Kathy and Vern Daugaard pick up litter on the edge… Continue reading

x
Home Fund proposals now accepted at Olympic View Community Foundation

Requests due March 13 from Peninsula nonprofits

Robin Presnelli, known to many as Robin Tweter, poses shortly before her heart transplant surgery.
Transplant recipient to speak at luncheon

With a new heart, Presnelli now helps others on same path