State court explains ruling in defamation case

Reykdal failed to prove the statement as ‘demonstrably false’

By The Associated Press

SEATTLE — The state Supreme Court has dismissed a defamation case brought by Superintendent of Public Instruction Chris Reykdal against his election opponent who stated Reykdal championed a policy that teaches “sexual position to fourth graders.”

The court ruled 6-3 last week that Reykdal failed to prove the statement as “demonstrably false,” The Seattle Times reported.

His challenger Maia Espinoza made the statement in the state voter guide mailed to all registered voters based on a comprehensive sex education law also on the ballot in November.

The court initially ruled in August that Reykdal did not have the legal grounds to succeed in the defamation case, meaning the statement could stay in the voter guide.

The written order released last week elaborated on the reasoning behind the ruling.

The opinion written by Chief Justice Debra L. Stephens said the statement is inflammatory but not false, and that Reykdal failed to prove defamation, which requires “actual malice” or was made knowing it was false.

Book cited

If approved by voters, the policy would require school districts to adopt a sex education curriculum of their choice that meets state standards listed by the Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction.

Espinoza’s statement refers to a book, “It’s Perfectly Normal: Changing Bodies, Growing Up, Sex, and Sexual Health,” which is listed in a handout for parents from one of nine curricula the state suggests for fourth and fifth graders, and contains cartoon images of a couple having sex, the opinion said.

“It is unlikely but truthful that the policy could result in unintentionally exposing fourth graders to depictions of, and thus ‘teaching’ them, different sexual positions,” it said.

Justices Steven González, Mary Yu and Raquel Montoya-Lewis disagreed with the ruling, arguing that the public school agency does not approve or recommend any particular curriculum for use under the law, it only reviews to see if curricula meet state standards.

“This book is not part of the teaching curriculum, and this record is bereft of any hint OSPI is recommending teachers use it to teach,” González said, adding that Reykdal met the standard for defamation.

“While I disagree with the court’s majority, this case was about only one example of my Republican opponent’s alarming pattern of personal dishonesty,” Reykdal said.

More in News

Clallam County removes ‘relic’ ordinance

Clallam County commissioners removed a 46-year-old ordinance regarding licensing… Continue reading

Clallam COVID cases trending downward as expected

Clallam County’s rate of new COVID-19 cases continues trending… Continue reading

Grant applications accepted for small businesses, nonprofits

Applications for the Working Washington Grants: Round 5 and new… Continue reading

Derek Kilmer helps Port Angeles Food Bank Executive Director Emily Dexter fill up the shelves with some crackers inside “The Market”. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Port Angeles Food Bank services well-used

Expanded facility aims to revert to grocery store model soon

U.S. Rep. Derek Kilmer, second from left, tours Olympic Medical Center on Monday, hearing from hospital leadership CEO Darryl Wolfe, left of Kilmer; and, to the right, Human Resources Manager Jennifer Burkhardt and Communications Manager Bobby Beeman. (Ken Park/Peninsula Daily News)
Site-neutral ruling topic of discussion during tour

Olympic Medical Center reimbursements at issue

Julie Jaman, the 80-year-old woman at the center of a controversy around transgender access to bathrooms, speaks at a protest across from Port Townsend City Hall on Monday. Jaman was banned from the local pool after she confronted a transgender woman in the locker room, and the event has gained national attention. Jaman and her supporters were surrounded by protestors Monday evening who shouted and made noise while they tried to speak, and scuffles broke out between the two groups. (Peter Segall / Peninsula Daily News)
Transgender proclamation draws hundreds to meeting

Protesters clash outside Port Townsend City Hall

Observable sheen from oil spill shrinks

No effect seen on wildlife, Coast Guard says

A giant Pacific octopus swims in its tank at Feiro Marine Science Center at Port Angeles City Pier while fans of the creature cast ballots for a name in an online poll, which ended Thursday afternoon. Octomatic was the people’s choice with 54.1 percent of 1,123 votes cast, winning out over Olive with 39 percent, Cranberry with 3.9 percent, Toby with 2 percent and Bobbie with 0.9 percent. The octopus, which was captured in Agate Bay north of Joyce, will reside at Feiro until it reaches maturity, and then it will be released in the area of where it was found. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Octopus named

A giant Pacific octopus swims in its tank at Feiro Marine Science… Continue reading

Monkeypox vaccine coming to Clallam County

COVID-19 case rates trending downward

Most Read