Sequim sets policy for private street ownership transfer

‘Road islands’ among community concerns

SEQUIM — Homeowners asking the City of Sequim to convert their private street to become publicly owned must follow new policy guidelines approved by the city council before their proposals can be considered.

City staff report that three neighborhoods and/or homeowner associations have inquired about the city assuming road maintenance and repair in recent years, with council members directing them to draft a new chapter of the Sequim Municipal Code (12.11 — Conversion of Private Streets to Public Streets).

The new chapter includes language that requires a written petition from nearby landowners, that the street must add value to the city grid system and meet city street right-of-way standards, and meet certain minimum standards of pavement condition.

Council members approved an ordinance for the new chapter on June 26 in a 6-1 vote with council member Kathy Downer opposed; she said she felt one requirement was too restrictive for homeowners.

The chapter states that landowners can petition the city council to accept rights-of-way and transfer legal and financial duties to the city and convert a street’s status from private to public.

Nicholas Dostie, Sequim’s deputy Public Works director, said June 26 that establishes a process with no guarantee it will be used.

Policy requirements

According to the city’s Municipal Code, requirements for a neighborhood/HOA’s request to be considered, include:

• A written petition signed by 100 percent of the abutting landowners, including all persons with partial ownership interest.

• The private street must add value to the city grid system and help achieve the city’s comprehensive plan policies and goals for transportation.

• The entire proposed street must have a minimum Pavement Condition Index (PCI) of 70 or 100 percent of the average PCI for Sequim streets, whichever is higher.

• The width of the proposed right-of-way must be consistent with city street standards at the time of proposal and be adequate for anticipated buildout purposes.

Council may also impose conditions on a case-by-base basis, such as requiring a utility service study, and the formation of a Local Improvement District (LID) to install city standard street improvements, such as sidewalks, landscaping and street lights.

If conditions are met, council will direct staff to conduct further review and schedule a public hearing.

However, the city council holds the right to not accept the proposal even if it meets the criteria, according to the new code.

There’s also no timeline in which staff or council must act on a proposal.

The city also will require easements if a changeover is to move forward, and stormwater drainage systems must be confirmed as adequate and in compliance with state and federal law.

Costs, concerns

Current city code requires all new streets to be public and staff said they’ll review this requirement as part of the 2025 Comprehensive Plan review.

At the May 8 council meeting, staff said the cost to repair and/or build streets has gone up significantly in recent years, too, with Dostie saying it’s upwards of 10 times, depending on the project compared to projects in 2019-2020.

For roads with a 70 PCI or better with minimal potholes and other issues, he said the PCI can be improved easier versus a lower rating requiring significant costs.

City Attorney Kristina Nelson-Gross said any time a local jurisdiction like the city does a project, it must pay prevailing wages, so if a neighborhood or HOA were to do it, the cost could be about one-third less than what it would cost the city.

A concern for some residents has been what’s been coined “road islands,” a public street disconnected from another public street with access only through a private street.

Public Works Director Sarah VanAusdle said via email that there are between two and seven potential road islands that exist or could exist from possible development.

City resident Steve Graham said June 26 that a second phase in his neighborhood’s development will create a public road island, and he found the new code guidelines “pretty restrictive” for homeowners seeking the city to assume ownership of their private roads to access the public road.

“There are a huge number of hurdles here,” Graham said. “A road island is not something you really want. You want continuous maintenance.”

He encouraged the council to be more flexible to get rid of road islands, and revise the city code to include a negotiation process as it “has a lot of potential to go sideways.”

Dostie said staff have been wrestling with the road island concept and that there’s no easy way to address them.

Deputy City Manager Charisse Deschenes said there are a lot of subdivisions and vacant land throughout the city where it could become more difficult for people to access property, and some development proposals have stopped because of this.

For more about the city’s code, visit


Matthew Nash is a reporter with the Olympic Peninsula News Group, which is composed of Sound Publishing newspapers Peninsula Daily News, Sequim Gazette and Forks Forum. Reach him at

Editor’s Note: Nash lives by a proposed project mentioned in this story.

More in News

Jon Picker, airport and marina manager for the Port of Port Angeles, describes runway sections for William R. Fairchild International Airport on a diagram of the terminal area. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Fairchild upgrades completed

Ribbon cutting is planned for Dec. 12

Clallam County eyes changes to park fees

Public hearing on adjustments set Dec. 12

Rich Foutch of Active Construction, Inc., in Tacoma paints a line on the roadway at the new roundabout at Kearney Street and state Highway 20 for the placement of temporary stripes in a pedestrian crosswalk on Monday in Port Townsend. The temperatures have to be in the mid-50s to install permanent striping, he said. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Roundabout striping

Rich Foutch of Active Construction, Inc., in Tacoma paints a line on… Continue reading

Proposal to rename Sequim road put on hold

Rotary, city to consider other options to honor local Olympian

Researcher: Managed forests needed to fight climate change

Wood products can replace existing fossil fuel-based materials

Jefferson County updates fee schedules

Environmental Public Health up 6 percent

The downtown Port Angeles Christmas tree is surrounded by people during a lighting ceremony on Saturday at First and Lincoln streets. The 30-foot tree will stand at the Conrad Dyar Memorial Fountain plaza through the holidays. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Lit up for the holidays

The downtown Port Angeles Christmas tree is surrounded by people during a… Continue reading

Community Aid seeks support for Toys for Sequim Kids

Nonprofit helps hundreds of children with Christmas presents

Planned electrical outage in Forks on Thursday

A planned power outage in Forks will affect electric service… Continue reading

Nordland man dies of injuries from Nov. 14 wreck

A second person involved in a two-car collision on Nov.… Continue reading

Santa Claus, portrayed by Stephen Rosales of Sequim, waves to the crowd after his arrival by vintage fire truck at Centennial Place in downtown Sequim on Saturday, part of the city’s Hometown Holidays celebration. Santa, accompanied by Irrigation Festival royalty, greeted children next to the city’s Christmas tree in an event that also featured music by the Sequim City Band and a lighted tractor parade. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Holiday tradition

Santa Claus, portrayed by Stephen Rosales of Sequim, waves to the crowd… Continue reading

District 3 chief pick bows out

Fire officials could resume search in ’24