Port Townsend: Teenager’s request for conditional plea in Aldrich’s fire rejected; case headed for trial

PORT TOWNSEND — A teenage girl facing felony charges for the fire that destroyed Aldrich’s grocery store is headed for trial after a conditional offer to plead guilty has been rejected.

“Negotiations have broken down,” said Stacey Bennetts. “At this point it has to go to trial.”

Bennetts is a Seattle attorney who has been representing the girl, one of three teenagers accused of causing the Aug. 4 fire that destroyed the 114-year-old grocery building in the historic uptown district.

Her client is the only one who has not made a statement about the night of the fire, and Bennetts’ request to reduce the charge to a gross misdemeanor was rejected earlier.

Last week, the attorney notified prosecutors that her client — who like the other teens is not named in the PDN because of her age — was willing to plead guilty to the original charge of reckless burning if the victims would agree to a stipulation that she and the other teenager facing prosecution would pay off what they could in two years in lieu of a set amount in restitution.

‘Nothing specific’

Jonathon Ryweck, who with his partner David Hamilton owned Aldrich’s grocery, said that they dismissed the offer as vague.

“It sounded like nothing to us because we heard nothing specific,” Ryweck said.

“There was no number given, nothing in writing. These two juveniles made a terrible mistake, but we don’t think they should get off scot-free, which is what their attorney is asking for.”

Police say the fire started in the early hours of Aug. 4 from embers of a fire that started in a paper recycling bin.

One teenager gave evidence in exchange for immunity from prosecution.

The second, a boy, reportedly admitted taking part in the circumstances which led to the blaze.

All were 14 years old at the time.

Under juvenile law, the felony charge can be removed from the two teenagers’ records after two years if restitution awarded by the court has been paid.

Otherwise, the charge sticks for life.

Last chance to plead

“It was our last-ditch effort to plead to a felony,” Bennetts said.

“These kids are not going to be able to pay, and their parents aren’t either.”

The girl, now 15, lives with her grandparents, who are retired, and was on the honor roll at school.

But she felt so much persecution after her name was published in a weekly newspaper that they rented an apartment in a different county so that she could go to school there, Bennetts said.

She now wants to return to Port Townsend to work, but cannot find a job with the felony charge hanging over her, Bennetts said.

More in News

KEITH THORPE/PENINSULA DAILY NEWS
June Ward, 10, examines a wooden paddle she is decorating as her father, Jack Ward of Port Angeles, works on his own paddle during a craft-making session on Friday at the Elwha Klallam Heritage Center in Port Angeles. The paddles are among the thousands of gifts being created for participants in the 2025 Tribal Canoe Journey, hosted this year by the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe. The event begins with the landing of dozens of native canoes at the mouth of the Elwha River on July 31 and continues with five days of celebration on the Lower Elwha reservation west of Port Angeles. As many as 10,000 indigenous peoples are expected to take part. The public is invited to help with giftmaking sessions, scheduled daily from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. at the Heritage Center.
Canoe paddle crafts

June Ward, 10, examines a wooden paddle she is decorating as her… Continue reading

Ralph Henry Keil and Ginny Grimm.
Long lost sailor to be honored at graduation

An honorary diploma will be presented to the family of… Continue reading

Singers to workshop vocal instruments at Fort Worden

One hundred and fifty singers to join together in song

Jefferson County fire danger risk level to move to high

Designation will prohibit fireworks over Fourth of July weekend

Candidate forums to be presented next week

The League of Women Voters of Clallam County and… Continue reading

Port Townsend City Council candidate forum set for next month

The League of Women Voters of Jefferson County will… Continue reading

Jefferson County to host series of community conversations

Jefferson County will conduct a series of Community Conversations… Continue reading

Denise Thornton of Sequim deadheads roses on a flower display at the Sequim Botanical Garden at the Water Reuse Demonstration Park at Carrie Blake Park on Wednesday in Sequim. Thornton, a volunteer gardener, was taking part in a work party to maintain the beauty of the garden. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Rose display

Denise Thornton of Sequim deadheads roses on a flower display at the… Continue reading

Electric rates see big increase

Jefferson proposal approved for 4-year hike

Clallam Transit to receive $4M in grants

Agency to use funds on Strait Shot and other routes

Port Angeles council OKs sidewalk near park

Applicants to receive grant funding for one-third of total cost