Port Angeles: Psychologist testifies that Roberts is chronically mentally ill

PORT ANGELES — A Seattle psychologist took the stand Wednesday in Thomas Martin Roberts’ murder trial, confirming what the defense team hopes to prove — Roberts’ insanity.

“I do think he was (insane),” Kenneth Muscatel said of Roberts’ mental state when he shot deputy Wallace E. “Wally” Davis in the head Aug. 5, 2000.

“I think he has an underlying chronic mental illness,” Muscatel testified. “And I think he’s going to have it the rest of his life.”

Muscatel’s two-hour, 20-minute testimony came in the seventh day of trial for Roberts, charged with aggravated first-degree murder for killing Davis with a shotgun blast on the front porch of Roberts’ Ennis Creek Road home.

Roberts, 56, has pleaded innocent by reason of insanity and has undergone several mental evaluations since he was arrested after a 26-hour standoff with police.

————-

The rest of the story appears in the Thursday Peninsula Daily News. Click on SUBSCRIBE to get the PDN delivered to your home or office.

More in News

Christine Leaver and her two daughters, Sullivan, 5, and Avery, 9, look over many Christmas ideas on Friday during the annual Christmas Cottage at the Vern Burton Community Center in Port Angeles. More than 34 different vendors fill the gym with holiday spirit. The event will continue from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. today and Sunday. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Christmas Cottage

Christine Leaver and her two daughters, Sullivan, 5, and Avery, 9, look… Continue reading

Study: Beavers helping Elwha

Restoration efforts continue on nearshore

PA school district, tribal officials work to address students’ needs

Organizations sign two-year agreement to continue partnership

Garden Row Cafe staff in Jefferson Healthcare’s newly built kitchen, from the left: Aurora Kingslight, Shelly Perry, Aimee Smith, Michelle Poore, Teresa Schmidt, Jimmy Snyder, Arran Stark and Nick Collier. (Elijah Sussman/Peninsula Daily News)
Garden Row Cafe now open to public

Hospital restaurant offers breakfast, lunch and dinner options

EYE ON THE PENINSULA: Agencies to review draft budgets for 2026

Meetings across the North Olympic Peninsula

Three injured in three-car collision south of Quilcene

Three people were transported to hospitals following a three-car collision… Continue reading

Michael Bannister of Bainbridge Island, an employee of Washington Conservation Corp, wheels a load of lupin and scotch broom to a waiting truck for disposal at a compost landfill in Port Townsend. The corps was at Fort Worden State Park, thinning out aggressive growing lupin and invasive scotch broom. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Scotch broom removal

Michael Bannister of Bainbridge Island, an employee of Washington Conservation Corp, wheels… Continue reading

Clallam PUD is planning facility

Utility under contract for land near airport

Port Townsend port commissioners to limit annual cruise ship dockings

Testimony includes surveys from citizens, Main Street program

Kirky Lakenes bought milkshakes for his nieces Ava, left, and Mia Hathaway in Chimacum earlier this year.
Procession set to honor tow truck driver

Lakenes remembered for his helping hand in Jefferson County

The Washington Festival and Events Association’s 2025 Pacific Northwest Summit Award winners were presented Oct. 30 at the WFEA Awards Dinner and Auction in the Regency Ballroom in Bellevue. The event of the year award in the small market category was the Lower Elwha Canoe Paddle, accepted by tribal chair Frances Charles. (Shanna Paxton Photography)
Paddle Journey, Forever Twilight earn top awards at conference

About 40,000 people, more than 100 canoes visit Lower Elwha Tribe

Panel supports timber sale

Committee recommends staying with contract