PORT ANGELES — It’s unusual in any murder case for the victim to have a say in the killer’s case.

But before Jimmie Homer Shreve pulled the trigger last year to end her life, Elizabeth “Beth” MacNeille, 54, wrote numerous letters to friends and family members indicating she wanted to die.

“In this case, I had the victim telling me very clearly what her wishes were,” Clallam County Superior Court Judge Ken Williams said Wednesday. “And of course, you don’t get that in murders.”

Shreve, 52, pleaded guilty Monday to second-degree murder and was sentenced to time he’s already served in jail for killing MacNeille Aug. 14, 2001, in a failed suicide pact.

He was originally charged with first-degree murder, but accepted a plea bargain for the lesser charge Monday.

Shreve’s attorney, John Hayden with Clallam County public defenders, said Wednesday the case would meet the elements of a homicide if brought before a jury.


The rest of the story appears in the Thursday Peninsula Daily News. Click on SUBSCRIBE, above, to get the PDN delivered to your home or office.

More in News

Jefferson County Library gets large bequest

Board welcomes ‘amazing, unexpected’ gift

Port Angeles ceremony to honor man killed in Korea

Remains of local Korean War soldier come home

US Highway 112 slide repair expected to begin Monday

State Department of Transportation officials expect to begin repairs of… Continue reading

COVID-19 cases keep rising on Peninsula

Olympic Medical Center transfers cases to Jefferson Healthcare

Jaymon Skinner of Bernt Ericsen Excavating is part of the crew moving earth for the foundation of 7th Haven, the Olympic Community Action Programs’ housing project at Seventh and Hendricks streets in Port Townsend. (Diane Urbani de la Paz/Peninsula Daily News)
7th Haven on schedule and on budget

First residents of housing project expected in spring ‘23

Scott Gardinier/Peninsula Daily News 
Port Angeles Food Bank workers hand out bags of food supplies and sanitization products to a long line of cars Wednesday afternoon. More than 90 people came to the drive-thru by 2 p.m. The food bank is currently preparing an indoor shopping area that is expected to be open early this year.
Port Angeles Food Bank provides for the community

Scott Gardinier/Peninsula Daily News Port Angeles Food Bank workers hand out bags… Continue reading

Peninsula awaits news on how to order federal masks

Health officer: N95, KN95 masks recommended

Police rescue 2 after Bellevue home slides off foundation

Police in Bellevue rescued two people from a home that… Continue reading

Most Read