PORT ANGELES — It’s unusual in any murder case for the victim to have a say in the killer’s case.

But before Jimmie Homer Shreve pulled the trigger last year to end her life, Elizabeth “Beth” MacNeille, 54, wrote numerous letters to friends and family members indicating she wanted to die.

“In this case, I had the victim telling me very clearly what her wishes were,” Clallam County Superior Court Judge Ken Williams said Wednesday. “And of course, you don’t get that in murders.”

Shreve, 52, pleaded guilty Monday to second-degree murder and was sentenced to time he’s already served in jail for killing MacNeille Aug. 14, 2001, in a failed suicide pact.

He was originally charged with first-degree murder, but accepted a plea bargain for the lesser charge Monday.

Shreve’s attorney, John Hayden with Clallam County public defenders, said Wednesday the case would meet the elements of a homicide if brought before a jury.


The rest of the story appears in the Thursday Peninsula Daily News. Click on SUBSCRIBE, above, to get the PDN delivered to your home or office.

More in News

Clint Ostler, president of Dash Air Shuttle, announces details of the startup airline’s plans to begin service between Port Angeles and SeaTac Airport in Seattle during a gathering of Port of Port Angeles commissioners and others on Tuesday at William R. Fairchild International Airport. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Dash Air taking reservations for first flights in August

Several aspects unfinished as of Tuesday

Housing topic of Thursday tent gathering

Officials from city, county, nonprofits to speak

Venita “Nita” Lynn, executive director of First Step Family Support Center in Port Angeles, is retiring after nearly 40 years of service in Clallam County. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Builder of First Step to step down

Retirement party set for Thursday

Clallam County seeking board volunteers

Applications are due Friday, July 15, for 73 volunteer… Continue reading

Candidate forum set for 6th Congressional District

A candidate forum featuring primary election candidates for the 6th Congressional District… Continue reading

Clallam PUD reschedules

Clallam County Public Utility District commissioners will consider a resolution… Continue reading

Sailboats engage in racing during the weekly Friday evening event on Port Townsend Bay. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Sailboat racing

Sailboats engage in racing during the weekly Friday evening event on Port… Continue reading

Vaccine appointments available for youngest age group

Rise in cases attributed to graduation parties

Clallam County to review noise ordinance

Current law reflects one of four parameters

Most Read