Options presented for Lincoln Park, but hearing focuses on proposed tree removal

PORT ANGELES — A botanical garden, larger wetlands and new play equipment were among the options presented during a public hearing on the future of Lincoln Park.

But the majority of comments from the public at the overflow meeting of the Port Angeles Parks, Recreation and Beautification Commission on Wednesday night did not stray away from the subject that remains the focal point of the proposed park master plan: the removal of many of the park’s numerous tall evergreen trees.

Twenty-three of the approximately 90 people attending the meeting in council chambers at City Hall spoke during the public comment period, with seven of them speaking for protecting the trees, which are in a city park, and eight urging their replacement to protect the landing path to a runway at the adjacent William R. Fairchild International Airport.

A few others were less certain and requested that at least some trees remain.

Those in favor of protecting the trees included neighbors concerned that their absence would lead to more noise from the airport and less wind protection, as well as environmentalists who consider their fate part of a larger effort to save the planet.

“If we were talking about placing an airport, where would we put it today?” said Kim Weiner, questioning its location outside a residential neighborhood.

The Port of Port Angeles, which owns the airport, has proposed removing most of the trees, identified by the Federal Aviation Administration as obstructions, to protect landing aircraft and avoid losing more of the safe approach to a runway.

Because of the height of many of the nearby trees, the port has prohibited airplanes from landing on 1,354 feet of its eastern runway.

The city and the port have agreed to create the master plan, the subject of Wednesday’s meeting, to determine the future use of the park, particularly what should replace any trees that are felled.

Mel Rudin, who spoke for tree removal, said the city does not have to choose between the park and the airport.

“It’s not one or the other,” he said. “It is both.”

“Both are essential to the community, and having a low-canopy open park that is something that can be used by multiple groups of people is much more advantageous than the existing park as I see it now.”

The consultant for the master plan, Juliet Vong of HBB Landscape Architecture, said felled evergreens could be replaced by low-canopy trees to maintain a forest and buffer between homes and the airport.

Devon Graywolf and William Hunt, activists who have led the effort to save the trees, sang a song about protecting the trees during the public comment period.

Both have spoken against a new, low-canopy forest.

“Saving our planet starts at home in our communities,” Graywolf told the parks commission.

“We pray the City Council will say no to the Federal Aviation Administration and the Port of Port Angeles and say yes to protecting our historical and heritage trees of Lincoln Park.”

Vong presented four options for the park at the meeting.

All four options protect existing uses, though one includes relocating the BMX track to the northeast end of the park.

The options differ in the size of wetland areas and new additions, such as climbing and playground equipment, an amphitheater, botanical gardens and educational facilities.

But how such changes would be paid for remains to be determined.

Richard Bonine, city recreation services manager, acknowledged that the city has limited funds for additional park enhancements and maintenance.

Because of budget cuts over the past several years, the city has relied on donation drives and volunteers to maintain existing parks or add new equipment.

Bonine said city staff will give preference to low-maintenance options for park improvements.

“We just got to be realistic,” he said.

Vong said refined versions of the plan will be presented at a public meeting in April.

A proposed final draft will be presented at another meeting in May.

The City Council has final say over the plan.

________

Reporter Tom Callis can be reached at 360-417-3532 or at tom.callis@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Lower Elwha Klallm Tribal Chairwoman Frances Charles, left, speaks about the Paddle to Elwha 2025 canoe journey as Carmen Watson-Charles, the tribe’s cultural manager, holds an informational pamphlet during a presentation to the Port Angeles Chamber of Commerce on Wednesday. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Thousands expected for canoe journey this month

Tribe anticipates speeches, songs and traditional dance

Glass recycling returns to Jeffco

Port Townsend, Quilcene locations available

Port of Port Townsend OKs update to its strategic plan

Commissioners discuss economic development

Reservoir project to start this weekend

Lower water pressure expected through Aug. 1

Forks institutes voluntary water conservation measures

The city of Forks is requesting residents to follow voluntary… Continue reading

Resurfacing project begins on Priest Road

Work crews contracted by the city of Sequim have begun… Continue reading

Mandy Miller of Port Angeles and other members of her family spent some time over the Fourth of July weekend picking eight pounds of strawberries at the Graysmarsh Farms north of Sequim. Raspberries will soon though reach their peak picking season, and both are available at Graysmarsh. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Berry picking

Mandy Miller of Port Angeles and other members of her family spent… Continue reading

Peninsula counties awarded $5M in grants

Funding to cover easements, equipment

Port of Port Angeles to forge ahead with terminal upgrade plans

Design phase would help envision future opportunities

The Northwest Watershed Institute purchased 81 acres for conservation and stewardship in the Tarboo Valley for inclusion in its 500-acre Tarboo Wildlife Preserve. (John Gussman)
Tarboo valley land set aside for preservation

Nearly 500 acres now part of wildlife preserve

Emily Simmons of Port Angeles, a member of the Surfriders Foundation, collects fireworks debris from along Ediz Hook Road in Port Angeles on Saturday. Although fireworks have been banned in the city of Port Angeles, many people used them illegally, leaving behind trash and spent casings and tasking volunteers to pick up the remains. A group from 4PA performed similar cleanup duty on another portion of the hook. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Cleanup efforts

Emily Simmons of Port Angeles, a member of the Surfriders Foundation, collects… Continue reading

Stage 3 water alert issued for Clallam Bay system

Clallam County Public Utility District No. 1 has declared a… Continue reading