Judge rules in favor of water pipeline to Marrowstone Island

PORT TOWNSEND — Marrowstone Island is entitled to a public water system.

So ruled visiting Clallam County Superior Court Judge Ken Williams, setting back a citizens group trying to stall a water pipeline to the island.

Williams’ ruling, unless appealed, clears the way for the PUD to pipe fresh water onto Marrowstone Island, cutting reliance on private water wells that are being fouled by sea water.

The matter was taken to court last May when a group of citizens, Conserve Water First, filed suit against the Jefferson County Public Utility District to stop the pipeline project.

Conserve Water First is led by Marrowstone residents Carrie and Rex Rice, and Wayne and Nicole Chimenti.

Intervening on behalf of the PUD was another citizens group, Water for Marrowstone, led by residents Ralph and Anne Rush, and Kelly and Gloria Hays.

“We’re obviously pleased,” PUD attorney Mary Winters said.

“The judge had done an excellent job of understanding the arguments of both parties and came to a fair and right decision.”

The opponents of the project have 30 days to appeal their lawsuit.

The attorney representing the Conserve Water First group did not return phone calls requesting comment.

The citizens group claimed the PUD violated the public process by improperly calculating the percentage of property owners who voted against the project in a poll taken just before commissioners approved the project in early 2004.

“Within a representative form of government, (PUD officials) are allowed to make such choices, so long as they follow the procedures required,” Williams said in his order.

“This they have done.”

More in News

A helicopter joins the firefighting effort Tuesday afternoon at the Belgian Fire near Brinnon. (Brinnon Fire Department)
Belgian fire under control

Firefighters remained on scene Wednesday

Electronics recycling event set for Saturday

The Port Angeles Noon Rotary will host an electronics… Continue reading

Lane closure set Wednesday for art installation

The southbound lane of Race Street in Port Angeles… Continue reading

Beachgoers look for a spot on the sand on Sunday afternoon at Fort Worden State Park in Port Townsend. Mount Rainier looms in the distance. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Summer sand

Beachgoers look for a spot on the sand on Sunday afternoon at… Continue reading

First Fed accused in Ponzi scheme

Resignations came amid $107M lawsuit

Ballots for Aug. 5 primary election to be mailed today

Hospital commission, Port Angeles, Port Townsend city council races to be determined

Port Angeles to host forum on Rayonier cleanup

Special meeting scheduled for Tuesday

Drought conditions may require trucks to bring water to West End

Clallam Bay/Seiku and Island View water systems are under stage… Continue reading

Clallam County Democrats to host candidate forums

The Clallam County Democrats will host a series of… Continue reading

Firefighters work to contain a wildland fire on Tuesday afternoon near Brinnon. “Go now” evacuation orders were given from Jefferson County’s Emergency Operations Center. (Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office)
Evacuation orders given in Brinnon-area fire

Several areas near Brinnon were being asked to evacuate due… Continue reading

Kennedy Reynolds, 2, takes a look at a row of lavender plants with her mother, Chelsea Reynolds of Port Angeles, during a Saturday outing to B & B Family Lavender Farm west of Sequim. The farm will be a participant in this weekend’s Lavender Weekend, a celebration of all things lavender in Sequim and across the Dungeness Valley. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Fields of lavender

Kennedy Reynolds, 2, takes a look at a row of lavender plants… Continue reading