First Federal stock offer now open; depositors to vote on conversion, community foundation

First Federal President and CEO Larry Hueth

First Federal President and CEO Larry Hueth

PORT ANGELES — A first-time offering of more than 10 million shares of First Federal stock is now open, while depositors have been asked to vote to approve the institution’s conversion from a mutual form of organization, or depositor-owned, savings and loan to a bank owned by stockholders.

Depositors also have the first rights to purchase stock and are being asked to vote to approve the funding of the First Federal Community Foundation.

Slightly fewer than 25,000 voting member proxy cards — which represent about 42,000 First Federal accounts — have been mailed to depositors to determine if the institution will change its structure.

If the move is approved by a majority vote of the bank’s depositors, the only locally owned community bank on the North Olympic Peninsula, 91-year-old First Federal will go public, with common stock publicly traded on the NASDAQ Capital Market under the symbol “FNBC.”

The vote results will be announced Jan. 6 at a meeting at the Red Lion Hotel in Port Angeles.

If the conversion is approved, stock on sale now would go to purchasers shortly after that date.

First Northwest Bancorp, the holding company for First Federal, is offering a prospectus and stock order form for the sale of up to 10,580,000 shares of stock through 5 p.m. Dec. 16 to residents of Clallam, Jefferson and Kitsap counties, where Port Angeles-based First Federal operates banking offices, as well as nationwide.

Depositors have been mailed the prospectus and order form. Others can request mailings through calling the bank’s stock information center.

Each share will be sold for $10. The bank requires a minimum stock purchase of 25 shares, a cost of $250, with purchases limited to 20,000 shares per person ($200,000), or 40,000 shares ($400,000) for those acting together, such as a married couple or domestic partners.

If the stock is popular, the number of shares could increase to 12,167,00, the maximum the bank could offer, according to state and federal regulations.

“It’s really about demand,” said Larry Hueth, president and CEO of First Federal.

“It’s really about how much interest there is in the community.”

The prospectus issued by First Northwest Bancorp is based on an independent appraiser’s determination of the present value of the institution.

The final pricing will be determined by several factors, including the number of orders received and stock market conditions in January, explained Louis Paar, partner in Sandler O’Neill & Partners LP, a national investment banking firm and broker-dealer headquartered in New York City that is assisting First Federal in selling the stock.

The minimum amount of stock that must be sold is 7,820,000 shares.

All can put in an order, but orders will be filled first for depositors of First Federal who have had qualifying accounts since March 31, 2011.

Second in line would be the employee ESOP.

Third in priority would be First Fed depositors with accounts opened between April 1, 2011, and Sept. 30, 2014.

Fourth in line would be other depositors and borrowers of First Fed as of Nov. 10, 2014.

Any stock left would be for sale in a community offering.

Depositors who had active accounts with First Federal as of Nov. 10 both are offered stock and get ballots to vote on two issues: to approve the conversion and to fund a new charitable foundation.

“Only those that maintained an account on Nov. 10, 2014, have the right to vote,” Paar said.

Large account holders have more votes than those with small accounts.

Community meetings about the proposed conversion and the new foundation are scheduled Monday in Port Townsend, Tuesday in Port Angeles, Dec. 10 in Forks and next Thursday, Dec. 11, in Sequim. All meetings are at 5:15 p.m.

For meeting locations and to make a reservation — or to receive a prospectus and stock order form — call the bank’s stock information center at 844-731-2610 between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. Mondays through Fridays.

The call center, which opened Monday, “had a lot of activity,” Hueth said.

He said bank officials do not anticipate “getting any mail back until the end of this week” and so does not know at this point how sales are progressing.

If it is approved, some of the capital raised will go to the First Federal Community Foundation, which has been formed but not funded.

The 501(c)(3), which would give money to various entities within the communities the bank serves, “continues our long tradition of participating in community events,” Hueth said.

The three-member board of the foundation is made up of Stephen E. Oliver and David T. Flodstrom, both directors of First Federal, as well as Karen McCormick, former president and CEO of First Federal.

The new charitable foundation would be funded with $400,000 in cash and the remainder in shares of common stock to total 8 percent of the offering.

The estimated contribution to the foundation would total between $6.3 million and $9.7 million.

“There are two separate votes, one for conversion and one for the formation of a charitable foundation,” Hueth said.

It is possible to vote and not buy stock, he added.

“There is no obligation to buy stock, and there is no obligation to vote,” Paar said.

Proxy cards number fewer than accounts because some accounts belonging to the same person have been consolidated in a manner in line with federal insurance regulations, Paar said.

First Federal, which had assets of more than $795 million as of June 30, stands to gain $78 million to more than $100 million from its stock offering.

“We are not investment advisers, but we are encouraging people to vote for the conversion,” Hueth said.

“The capital that will be raised will benefit the local economy, the bank and the community in total,” he added.

Under the conversion, First Northwest Bancorp would own 100 percent of First Federal, which is known officially as First Federal Savings and Loan Association of Port Angeles.

First Federal’s current board of trustees would serve as trustees of First Northwest, with Hueth also serving as president and CEO of First Northwest.

Eight percent of the stock would be sold to a First Federal ESOP, or employee stock ownership plan, in which First Fed employees would receive stock as part of their annual compensation.

The influx of capital also will allow the bank to grow, Hueth said.

“The capital will allow us to expand deposit and lending efforts, allow us to grow into neighboring communities and continue to add to employment in our communities,” he added.

Growth will not change First Federal, Hueth said.

“The board’s commitment is to remain a Peninsula-based organization” and remain based in Port Angeles, he said.

“Who First Federal is will not change in the process” of conversion, he said.

First Federal, which began in 1923, is based in Port Angeles and has branches there as well as in Sequim, Port Townsend, Forks and Kitsap County’s Silverdale, plus a lending center in the Whatcom County city of Bellingham. It has almost 180 employees.

________

Managing Editor/News Leah Leach can be reached at 360-417-3531 or at leah.leach@peninsuladailynews.com.

Editor and Publisher John Brewer contributed to this report.

More in News

Ben Hecht, a geologist with environmental consulting firm Landau Associates, takes a sample of raw drinking water taken at the city of Port Angeles’ ranney collector on Saturday at the Elwha River, downstream from Friday’s tanker crash that dumped petroleum products into Indian Creek west of Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
‘Do not drink’ order given for Port Angeles water customers

Bottled water available Sunday at two locations

Foundation donates $1 million to hospital

Recipients include residency program, scholarships and cancer care center

A former teacher, Larry Jeffryes moved to Sequim with his wife in 2013. He was appointed to the Sequim School Board in September 2019, elected by voters in November of that year and was elected again in 2023. Before his resignation, Jeffryes’ term was set to go through November 2027. (Larry Jeffryes)
Sequim school board director resigns after six years in seat

District opens process to apply for position

Members of the musical group Soupbones, from left, Ed Schmid of Port Angeles, Ron Munro of Sequim, Carly List of Port Angeles and Hugh Starks of Sequim, perform at a Good Trouble community gathering and picnic on Thursday at Erickson Playfield in Port Angeles. Organizers of the event, one of numerous gatherings across the United States, decided to forego conventional politics while commemorating the life of civil rights activist John Lewis. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Good trouble rally

Members of the musical group Soupbones, from left, Ed Schmid of Port… Continue reading

State funds to benefit coastal habitat

Clallam, Jefferson awarded $1.6M

Artists Heather Sparks, left, and Zeo Boekbinder set up a stencil of a fern leaf in an effort to decorate an otherwise-drab concrete roadside divider along Race Street south of Lauridsen Boulevard on Wednesday in Port Angeles. The divider work was part of a larger project to beautify the Race Street corridor from Eighth Street to Hurricane Ridge Road, which included improved traffic lanes, pedestrian and bicycle lanes and decorative lighting. Long-term plans call for similar improvements to Race Street, extending to First and Front streets. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
A touch of color

Artists Heather Sparks, left, and Zeo Boekbinder set up a stencil of… Continue reading

A tanker truck overturned into Indian Creek west of Port Angeles, according to the State Patrol and the state Department of Transportation. U.S. Highway 101 was closed Friday afternoon at milepost 238 near Herrick Road, and traffic was being diverted to state Highway 112. (Katherine Weatherwax via X)
Highway 101 reopens after tanker truck overturns into creek

Port Angeles asks utility customers to conserve water

Lisa Hansen of Port Angeles, center, takes a cellphone photo of her son, Cooper Hansen, 3, as Hansen’s mother, Tracy Hansen, right, looks on during a warm day at Hollywood Beach on the Port Angeles waterfront on Wednesday. The trio were enjoying a sunny summer afternoon next to the water. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Picture perfect

Lisa Hansen of Port Angeles, center, takes a cellphone photo of her… Continue reading

Claim against First Fed alleges $100M fraud

First Fed plans to ‘vigorously defend’ loans

Olympic Medical Center CEO says Medicaid cuts will hit hard

Darryl Wolfe tells board entire state will feel impact

Joseph Wilson, left, and Kevin Streett.
Jefferson PUD names new general manager

Wilson comes with 30 years of experience