Double-murder trial jury could be selected Wednesday in Jefferson County

PORT TOWNSEND — Jefferson County Superior Court Judge Craddock Verser called on lawyers Monday to work toward seating a jury in the Michael J. Pierce double-murder case by Wednesday.

In the first round of jury selection, Verser, the prosecuting attorney and Pierce’s public defender trimmed the panel of potential jurors to 28.

Today, 50 potential jurors in a second selection round will be called from the pool to fill out questionnaires and give attorneys their reasons for not being seated as jurors.

“We’re going to pick a jury on Wednesday,” said Pierce’s public defender, Richard Davies, after a number of jurors were questioned and dismissed from jury duty for reasons ranging from fairness to health issues.

Verser agreed saying, “Wednesday morning, we ought to select a jury by noon.”

Courtroom security

Potential jurors and others attending courtroom proceedings were run through metal detectors before entering Verser’s courtroom by two courtroom deputies with the Sheriff’s Office.

Inside, the blinds were drawn in the historic courtroom and the lights were turned on, another security measure.

Two deputies stood guard at the front of the courtroom where Pierce sat in a blue suit and tie with his legal team.

Verser ordered the potential jurors to not read newspapers or watch TV accounts of the case and urged them to even avoid overhearing lawyers in the courthouse possibly discussing the case.

Scott Rosekrans, Jefferson County chief deputy criminal prosecuting attorney, sat before the bench Monday, taking turns with Davies in examining selected potential jurors who raised concerns on questionnaires about whether they read or heard pretrial publicity or discussion and could still remain fair and impartial on a jury panel.

Couple killed in March 2009

Pierce, 35, of Quilcene, who has been held in Jefferson County jail in Port Hadlock without bail for nearly a year, is charged with the March 18, 2009, slayings of Patrick, 60, and Janice Yarr, 57, at their Boulton Farm Road home north of Lake Leland.

The trial could begin early next week after a 12-member jury with two alternates is seated in the case.

Investigators in the case said the farmhouse was set ablaze to cover up the murders. Bullet fragments found at the scene indicated that the victims were shot in the head.

Pierce was being held without bail, which the Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office successfully argued for after the public defender contended that $1 million bond should be reinstated for Pierce under the state Constitution.

In addition to arson and two counts of murder, Pierce has been charged with robbery, burglary, theft of a firearm, unlawful possession of a firearm and theft.

Prosecutors say they have video of Pierce using the Yarrs’ credit card at a bank automatic teller machine.

A stolen ATM card is not proof of burglary of the Yarrs’ home, Davies has contended.

In his prior criminal history, he has outstanding warrants for such crimes as attempting to outrun authorities.

The Yarrs owned Pat Yarr Logging and Yarr Cattle Co.

Pat Yarr had worked as a log trucker across the North Olympic Peninsula since the early 1960s, and the family had lived in Forks and Chimacum before settling in Quilcene.

Janice Yarr also worked as a bookkeeper for Seton Construction of Port Townsend.

Their memorial service drew 700 mourners.

________

Port Townsend-Jefferson County Editor Jeff Chew can be reached at 360-385-2335 or at jeff.chew@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

April Messenger, left, and Olympic National Park Ranger Chris Erickson share ideas on Wednesday during a listening session at Field Arts & Events Hall in Port Angeles. Nearly 150 people provided feedback about a new Hurricane Ridge Lodge project following the 2023 fire that destroyed the original structure. Nine easels were set up with questions and notes were provided for people to express their goals for a new lodge. The earliest construction can begin is in 2028, and it would take two to three years to complete, weather permitting. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Listening post

April Messenger, left, and Olympic National Park Ranger Chris Erickson share ideas… Continue reading

Port of Port Townsend to pursue grant for airport

Funds aimed to spur small industrial work

Future of Oceans program to focus on puffins

Expert spent 37 years studying seabirds in Alaska

The city of Port Angeles has put out a request for proposals for the sale of the historic fire hall at 215 S. Lincoln St. (City of Port Angeles)
Port Angeles is seeking a buyer for fire hall, prioritizes affordable housing

Historic preservation also noted for city’s landmark property

A standup paddle boarder and his dog take advantage of mild temperatures and calm waters on Tuesday to go for a ride on Port Townsend Bay. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Going for a ride

A standup paddle boarder and his dog take advantage of mild temperatures… Continue reading

Port of Port Angeles seeking design team

Building intended for aerospace production

Olympic National Park Superintendent Sula Jacobs answers questions Wednesday during the Port Angeles Chamber of Commerce luncheon at the Red Lion Inn. (Emily Hanson/Peninsula Daily News)
Superintendent says national park had more than 3.6M visitors in ’25

Construction projects to affect amenities in ONP this summer

Northwest Maritime CEO to take six-month sabbatical

Northwest Maritime CEO Jake Beattie will take a planned… Continue reading

Rachel Anderson.
Sequim City Council elects Anderson as mayor

The Sequim City Council elected Rachel Anderson as mayor and… Continue reading

Wedner Klebanow uses both arms to control a kite at Fort Worden State Park on Sunday. She was with her father, Rick Klebanow, in 16 mph winds, strong enough for the kite to perform certain stunts. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Let’s go fly a kite

Wender Klebanow uses both arms to control a kite at Fort Worden… Continue reading

Port Townsend plans for street projects in 2026

Sales tax, grants to fund expanded effort

Dr. Evan Small.
Emergency department director says many factors drive wait times

Small: Repeated OMC violations didn’t involve issues with patient care