Covarrubias lawyer seeks to move site of second murder trial

PORT ANGELES — Too many people have made up their minds about Robert Gene Covarrubias, Port Angeles lawyer Ralph Anderson said Thursday.

So Anderson, Covarrubias court-appointed attorney, will seek a change of venue for his client’s second first-degree murder trial, he said.

Anderson — who also represented Covarrubias, 28, at his first trial — made the pledge in Covarrubias’ weekly status hearing in Clallam County Superior Court, where Judge George L. Wood also is involved in the case a second time.

Wood presided in April 2006 when Covarrubias was convicted of first-degree murder in the death of 15-year-old Melissa Leigh Carter, whose nude body was found along Olympic Discovery Trail in Port Angeles the day after Christmas 2004.

Covarrubias was sentenced to 34 ½ years.

He has pleaded not guilty.

The state Court of Appeals on Jan. 6 ordered a new trial on the basis of errors committed by Wood and county Prosecuting Attorney Deb Kelly during the first trial but said there was enough evidence to convict Covarrubias, 28.

Authorities said Carter was sexually assaulted; Covarrubias said the sex was consensual.

‘Everyone has opinion’

“Pretty much everyone has an opinion on this case,” Anderson said during the hearing.

He also told Wood he expects to interview the jurors who convicted Covarrubias in 2006.

If a change of venue is granted, a jury should be chosen in another county other than Clallam, Jefferson or Kitsap, Anderson said in an interview.

If a change of venue is not granted, “I think we would have a very hard time getting a jury that does not have pre-conceived notions about the guilt or innocence of the defendant,” he said.

“I want a jury panel from somewhere else, and somewhere where the case was not a big deal and wasn’t covered.”

Busing jurors

An alternative also may be picking a jury elsewhere and bussing jurors to Clallam County for the trial, Anderson added.

County Prosecuting Attorney Deb Kelly said Thursday she was reluctant to comment on the case for fear of adding to the chances that Wood would grant the change of venue.

At the hearing, Anderson and Kelly decided to delay discussing the extent of DNA testing that will be required for Covarrubias’ new trial.

“There’s an awful lot of material to go through,” Anderson said.

He and Kelly may have an order for Wood’s signature by Monday, Anderson said.

Anderson said additional DNA tests may be conducted on items including a pair of underwear found at the murder scene and hair found in the underwear.

The hair could be an important part of the case only if a hair follicle is present. The follicle is more viable for DNA testing than the rest of the hair, Anderson said.

Anderson said he also wants DNA tests conducted on blood that was present in the “flophouse” that Covarrubias lived in about a block north of the courthouse.

“Several items were not tested” in the first trial, he said.

A weekly status hearing on the case is 9 a.m. every Thursday.

The trial is scheduled to start by July 7.

________

Staff writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-417-3536 or at paul.gottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Sunlight reflects off the skull of Gunther, the California gray whale carcass on display on the pier in Port Townsend. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
The golden hour

Sunlight reflects off the skull of Gunther, the California gray whale carcass… Continue reading

The state is looking to turn Miller Peninsula, a 2,800-acre undeveloped park east of Sequim, into a destination state park with a visitors center, cabins, picnic areas and more. Some locals oppose the move. (Warren Wilson)
Opponents want park to stay day use

State updates plan for Miller Peninsula

Sequim staff plan to send a proposal to the state this month to potentially fund sewer and water lift stations on West Sequim Bay Road using new developments’ property taxes through a Tax Increment Area by Sequim Bay in a 363-acre area. It would require the city to prove that developments in the area wouldn’t happen without the stations. The city council also would have to approve it. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim exploring funding mechanism to incentivize development

City would create district, repurpose tax dollars for lift stations

Fred Rix of Port Angeles, right, looks over floral arrangements with Ann O’Neill, an employee of Angel Crest Gardens of Port Angeles at a temporary stand at First and Race streets in Port Angeles on Valentine’s Day. Rix said he wanted roses for his wife, Wendy Rix, for their 55th wedding anniversary. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Valentine’s roses

Fred Rix of Port Angeles, right, looks over floral arrangements with Ann… Continue reading

Port Angeles-owned Lancashire Heeler “Ki” poses with handler and co-owner Chelsy Pendleton of Utah with their ribbon. Ki placed as Best of Opposite Sex at the 149th annual Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show.
PA dog places at famous show

Lancashire Heeler wins ribbon at Westminster

x
Nominations open for Community Service awards

Forms due March 25; event scheduled for May 1

Poplars to be removed in spring

Boat Yard expansion part of larger project

Jeffco Aquatic Coalition launches pool survey

Results intended to inform design process

Voters approving all Peninsula school measures

Sequim bond passing with required supermajority

A snow-covered Mount Angeles is seen from Black Diamond Road a few miles south of Port Angeles. While the Peninsula has seen temperatures below freezing this week, a warming trend is expected by this weekend with highs reaching the upper 40s and overnight lows in the 30s. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Winter snowscape

A snow-covered Mount Angeles is seen from Black Diamond Road a few… Continue reading