Following a court ruling last week, hatchery salmon can be used to replenish the decimated Elwha River, which is still being coaxed back to life following the removal of dams in 2014. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)

Following a court ruling last week, hatchery salmon can be used to replenish the decimated Elwha River, which is still being coaxed back to life following the removal of dams in 2014. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)

Court of Appeals supports hatchery fish in Elwha River in decision

PORT ANGELES — Hatchery fish can continue playing their disputed role in the largest dam removal and salmonid recovery project in U.S. history, a federal court has decided.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals last week confirmed the continued use of hatchery-bred salmon to replenish a decimated Elwha River run being coaxed back to life following the historic removal of the Glines Canyon and Elwha dams, completed in 2014.

In doing so the court rejected a 2015 appeal by the Wild Fish Conservancy, Wild Steelhead Coalition, Federation of Fly Fishers Steelhead Committee and Wild Salmon Rivers, doing business as Conservation Angler, upholding Judge Benjamin Settle’s U.S. District Court ruling.

The three-person appeals panel sided April 18 with the National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. Department of Commerce, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Fisheries Service and four members of the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe’s senior fisheries and hatchery staff who are overseeing the hatchery-fish effort.

“We’re happy,” Lower Elwha attorney Stephen Suagee of Port Angeles said Monday.

“It basically affirms the district court on all counts.”

Beginning this spring, the tribe will release smolts up to 18 months old that are expected to return to the Elwha River in three or four years to spawn, Suagee said.

Suagee said 25,772 coho smolts were released March 29.

The release of 175,000 steelhead smolts began April 12 and is ongoing, while a release of 71,248 chum salmon is planned for this week, Suagee said.

“Some will go past the hatchery and up toward the dam sites, which is the whole idea here.”

Olympic National Park acting spokeswoman Penny Wagner referred queries about the decision to NOAA Fisheries.

NOAA spokesman Jim Milbury put the ruling in a broad context Monday in an email.

“We’re very pleased the Ninth Circuit found our analysis was complete and that both NOAA and the Park Service have thoroughly [and] adequately assessed the impacts involved, from the dam removal process to the efforts to recover salmon and steelhead populations,” wrote Milbury.

Anti-hatchery-fish groups originally filed their challenge in 2012, well before the completion of the $325 million dam removal and fish restoration project.

They sought limits of no more than 50,000 hatchery steelhead smolts and 50,000 hatchery coho salmon smolts into the Elwha and its tributaries, and wanted no more than 60 adult steelhead, no more than 30 of which are female, to be removed annually from the river to provide broodstock.

“These hatchery fish will overwhelm the small, fragile wild fish populations that remain in the river, severely impeding or even preventing the full recovery of native anadromous fish,” the Conservancy and its partners in the suit said in a Dec. 1, 2014, court filing, claiming hatchery programs were implemented unlawfully without Endangered Species Act authorization.

After the lawsuit was initiated, “[National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Fisheries Service] hastily approved the hatchery programs under the ESA,” according to the appeal.

Wild Fish Conservancy co-founder and Executive Director Kurt Beardslee did not return a call for comment Monday afternoon.

The appeals court found key points in the challenge, led by the Conservancy, moot, asserting that Fisheries had addressed concerns expressed by Settle by issuing a revised environmental assessment — an assessment that had gone unchallenged by the hatchery-fish opponents, according to the court’s opinion.

“The subsequent [environmental assessment] reasonably concluded, after thorough analysis, that the risks posed by the hatchery programs were minimal and that approving the programs would have no significant impact on the environment,” the court said.

“The EA also reasonably concluded that the programs were not highly controversial, and the existence of ‘some’ uncertainty did not require an EIS.”

In its court filing, the federal government also strongly endorsed the hatcheries’ usage.

“[Wild Fish Conservancy] misses an important element of the context: hatcheries for most stocks are not new and were critical to conserving the remaining native Elwha fish while the dams were in place and natural survival in the lower river was gravely threatened,” according to the filing.

“Approximately 95 percent of recent threatened chinook salmon returns are hatchery origin and the program has operated since 1976.”

The Fisheries Service also had endorsed hatchery usage for the project in a 1996 environmental impact statement, the court said.

Suagee said the hatchery program ensures that native Elwha fish stocks, including pink and chum salmon, retain the genetic characteristics of fish originating in Elwha in the face of “lethal” sediment released by the dams’ removal, estimated at 34 million cubic yards.

“We needed the hatchery to rear native fish to make sure the native species would survive the several years onslaught of all that sediment, and so far, so good.”

________

Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 55650, or at pgottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Children pick up candy along the parade route in Forks on Friday during the Forks Old Fashioned 4th of July Parade. (Lonnie Archibald/for Peninsula Daily News)
Festivities on the Fourth

Children pick up candy along the parade route in Forks on Friday… Continue reading

A new parking lot next to the Sequim Civic Center will be completed by the end of the summer, according to Sequim city staff. The city purchased three lots adjacent to the center in June 2022 to convert the properties into a parking lot. The lots also were known for common calls to 911. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim sets its list of projects

Summer work includes paving streets

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading

Security exercise set for Wednesday at Indian Island

Naval Magazine Indian Island will conduct a security training… Continue reading

Project SAFER aims to help those with disabilities

Form identifies sensitivities for law enforcement officers

Summer meal programs help out families in Jefferson County

Jefferson Healthcare and Jefferson County Food Bank Association offer assistance

Violinist Kristian Bugge plays traditional Danish folk songs with Fiddle Tunes found Bertram Levy, July 2. (ELIJAH SUSSMAN/PENINSULA DAILY NEWS)
Fiddle Tunes fill the air at Fort Worden

Traditions flourish, musical and otherwise

Beaver Valley fire sees road closure

One acre vegetation fire controlled quickly

Public meeting on Rayonier Mill Cleanup on Tuesday

The Washington State Department of Ecology on Tuesday will… Continue reading

Port Angeles City Council taking applications for seat

A vacancy on the City Council must be filled… Continue reading

KEITH THORPE/PENINSULA DAILY NEWS
Construction workers stand on what remains of the old U.S. 101 bridge over the Elwha River on Wednesday as the aging structure is dismantled. The old bridge, built in 1926, was in danger of washout when the river beneath changed course and engineers discovered the bridge piers were built on gravel instead of bedrock, leading to constructon of a new bridge, at right, which was opened to traffic in 2024. The old bridge was to remain in place until a fish-spawning window, which runs from mid-July until the end of August.
Bridge removal

Construction workers stand on what remains of the old U.S. Highway 101… Continue reading