Clallam officials consider contract extension amid litigation

Deal is with company reviewing Judy Lee building plans

PORT ANGELES — Clallam County commissioners have agreed that they should extend by six months a contract with a company in Oregon that is reviewing plans for a 27-bathroom, 32,000-square-foot bed and breakfast planned for Sequim Bay.

Commissioners will take formal action today to extend the county’s contract with Clair Co. through June 11 to give Judy Lee — a California woman suing the county in federal court — an additional opportunity to submit adequate plans.

“The idea would be hopefully that Judy Lee will either submit revised plans or she will continue to be inactive, which would be to our benefit,” said Chief Civil Prosecuting Attorney David Alvarez.

This extension does not increase how much the county is willing to pay the company. The company extended the contract in June, increasing it to a maximum compensation of $30,000.

Lee filed a lawsuit in December 2017 that alleges that the Clallam County Department of Community Development director, Mary Ellen Winborn, has worked to thwart her plans to build her dream home — a 32,000-square-foot, four-story structure she calls a bed and breakfast that features five bedrooms and 27 bathrooms — along the banks of Sequim Bay.

She purchased five acres at 695 E. Sequim Bay Road in 2016 to “make her home into an attractive bed and breakfast to allow others to enjoy the area,” according to the lawsuit.

Winborn determined that the building, which would be larger than the Quality Inn & Suites in Sequim and the Clallam County Public Utility District headquarters in Carlsborg, was actually a hotel and could not be built in that area.

Clallam County selected Clair Co. to review the application in October 2018 after the county and Lee agreed to have a third party review the application.

Winborn has protested this move and said she will not participate in that process.

When Lee filed her third revised application with Clair Co., the company rejected the proposal because the application was not complete. Lee was asked to respond to 49 comments before the application could be considered.

The county has extended the Oregon company’s contract to Dec. 11, 2019, but Lee said in a deposition that she has not taken steps to make the corrections required, including a number of corrections required for Building/Fire/Life Safety Review.

Motion to dismiss

The county asked in October that the lawsuit be dismissed and a motion hearing is now set for Dec. 11 at U.S. District Court in Tacoma.

In a response to the motion, Lee’s attorney said that Winborn “instructed her staff to engage in a helter-skelter pattern of bureaucratic tricks, concealment, and maneuvering — including needless appeals and court actions designed to only frustrate Lee’s project.

“After nearly two years of run-around, caused by Winborn’s officious tactics, Lee filed this lawsuit.”

In her response, Lee wrote that she is hopeful that Clair Co. will issue a permit in the coming months.

The county responded on Nov. 19, arguing that Lee doesn’t dispute the county’s key reasons for requesting the lawsuit be dismissed.

The county emphasizes that Lee never received a permit for the project and has never satisfied any conditions to receive one.

“Indeed, even in late 2018, when the Clair Company received the third amended application from Ms. Lee, it stressed that the plans and specifications were so deficient that they were not suitable for review,” the county’s motion says.

________

Reporter Jesse Major can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 56250, or at jmajor@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

The ferry MV Coho backs into its landing after returning to Port Angeles on Tuesday following annual dry dock and maintenance in Anacortes. During the maintenance period, extensive work was performed on the dock, including replacement of a wing wall used to steer and secure the vessel during loading and unloading of cars and passengers. The ferry is scheduled to resume daily service between Port Angeles and Victoria on Thursday. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Coho returns

The ferry MV Coho backs into its landing after returning to Port… Continue reading

Building association calls for city to cease utility charges

Association says charges unconstitutional

Jefferson Land Trust considering conservation burial ground

Funds from plot sales could fund habitat improvements

Port Angeles artist Bob Stokes sits in his studio and music venue on Wednesday. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Art community mourns Bob Stokes’ passing

Legacy includes statues, concerts, gatherings

Clallam PUD
Cindy Kimble, Clallam PUD’s customer and community outreach programs coordinator, can help residents navigate the utility district’s revamped low-income energy assistance program.
Clallam PUD hires staff to help low-income customers

Clallam County Public Utility District has overhauled its low-income energy… Continue reading

Jen Colmore, left, and June Nichols of the Sequim Food Bank serve a sample of chili to Monica Dixon of Sequim during Saturday’s Community Chili Cookoff at the Sequim Boys & Girls Club. The event, organized by the club and Boy Scout Troop 90, showcased the culinary skills of six community organizations with each group receiving a share of the proceeds and the winner taking a $500 prize. The food bank’s chili recipe took top honors in the competition. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Chili cookoff

Jen Colmore, left, and June Nichols of the Sequim Food Bank serve… Continue reading

Port Townsend to test sewer system with smoke, dye

The city of Port Townsend will test its sewer… Continue reading

JUMP! Playground to close for renovations

Jefferson County Parks and Recreation will close the JUMP! Playground… Continue reading

Barcy Fisher, left, and Patti Buckland have been selected as the 2024 Marrowstone Island Citizens of the Year.
Fisher, Buckland honored as Marrowstone Island citizens of year

Barcy Fisher and Patty Buckland were named Marrowstone Island’s 2024… Continue reading

About 800 people from Jefferson and Clallam counties spill out from the steps of the Jefferson County Courthouse onto Jefferson Street in Port Townsend on Monday to take part in a National Day of Protest organized by the 50501 Movement, which stands for “50 protests, 50 states, 1 movement.” (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Hundreds protest actions of Trump administration

Activists cite USAID, worry about Treasury, impacts of immigration

Peninsula to welcome Canadian visitors

Celebration of Coho passengers planned

Fish barrier removal to impact highway traffic

Portions of roadway to have long-term closures