Clallam County expected to appeal Ecology

PORT ANGELES — Clallam County is preparing to appeal the state Department of Ecology’s decision that the Port Angeles Urban Growth Area qualifies for the “onerous” Phase II Municipal Stormwater Permit.

The permit would increase development costs and require the county to add staff to address new administrative tasks required by the state, local officials said.

On July 2, Ecology told the county that the Western Washington Phase II Municipal Stormwater Permit, which requires municipalities to develop a stormwater management program to prevent stormwater runoff from polluting downstream waters, would go into effect Aug. 1.

Several officials described the Phase II Permit costs and requirements as “onerous” and agreed the county should seek mediation.

Commissioner Mark Ozias said Monday the county would draft its notice of appeal to the Pollution Control Hearings Board to be discussed during Monday’s 9 a.m. work session and that commissioners would consider approving the appeal Tuesday.

By appealing the decision, officials said they hope to reach a compromise with Ecology during mitigation and avoid having a hearing before the Pollution Control Hearings Board.

Mary Ellen Winborn, the director of the Department of Community Development, said that Ecology officials were not sympathetic when the county stated its case for not being subject to a Phase II permit.

Winborn said Ecology officials praised the county for its stormwater management efforts, but now it is “penalizing” the county by requiring the permit.

“This is an area that is not developing,” Winborn said. “The rest of our county is developing. This area has not had anything substantial.”

Commissioner Randy Johnson described the Phase II Permit as a “one size fits all” approach that doesn’t make sense in the Port Angeles UGA.

“I just look at the onerous costs that have come to the city of Port Angeles,” Johnson said. “That’s why I think we as a county have to look at this.”

County hydrogeologist Carol Creasey told commissioners that Ecology determined in 2012 that the Unincorporated Port Angeles Urban Growth Area did not qualify for the Phase II permit and that since there have been few changes in the area.

She said there are no new ditches, no new curbs or gutters. She said that Streamkeepers of Clallam County have collected data that shows water quality is improving in most areas.

“Things haven’t really changed in the Unincorporated Port Angeles Urban Growth Area,” she said.

She said in 2012 Ecology recommended the county adopt its draft stormwater management plan. Some of the recommendations were followed, she said, but the county didn’t follow through with others.

Ecology would provide the county with a $95,000 grant over two years to help fund the transition.

“All the stuff we had to do for responses to them and going to the meetings put us behind on our schedule for updated stormwater management with the entire county,” she said. “They seem to think it is more important to concentrate on a small area in our county than to get updated stormwater management for the entire county.”

Winborn said the county could consider developing a contract with the city of Port Angeles to process development permits in the UGA and that the department could team up with the city on code enforcement.

Ozias said he felt filing litigation in hopes of mediating with the state was the best approach, but he questioned whether the effort would be worth it.

He said in many cases when local jurisdictions find ways to be successful the state implements plans that undo that work and there is little that can be done.

He said the county should be cautious in how long and how hard it fights back.

“When do you cross the point of rather than standing up for what we believe is right, when we recognize as right as we might be and as much data as we have to support our position, ultimately it doesn’t matter,” Ozias said. “I don’t really know in this arena when that is.”

________

Reporter Jesse Major can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 56250, or at jmajor@peninsula dailynews.com.

More in News

Sunlight reflects off the skull of Gunther, the California gray whale carcass on display on the pier in Port Townsend. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
The golden hour

Sunlight reflects off the skull of Gunther, the California gray whale carcass… Continue reading

The state is looking to turn Miller Peninsula, a 2,800-acre undeveloped park east of Sequim, into a destination state park with a visitors center, cabins, picnic areas and more. Some locals oppose the move. (Warren Wilson)
Opponents want park to stay day use

State updates plan for Miller Peninsula

Sequim staff plan to send a proposal to the state this month to potentially fund sewer and water lift stations on West Sequim Bay Road using new developments’ property taxes through a Tax Increment Area by Sequim Bay in a 363-acre area. It would require the city to prove that developments in the area wouldn’t happen without the stations. The city council also would have to approve it. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim exploring funding mechanism to incentivize development

City would create district, repurpose tax dollars for lift stations

Fred Rix of Port Angeles, right, looks over floral arrangements with Ann O’Neill, an employee of Angel Crest Gardens of Port Angeles at a temporary stand at First and Race streets in Port Angeles on Valentine’s Day. Rix said he wanted roses for his wife, Wendy Rix, for their 55th wedding anniversary. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Valentine’s roses

Fred Rix of Port Angeles, right, looks over floral arrangements with Ann… Continue reading

Port Angeles-owned Lancashire Heeler “Ki” poses with handler and co-owner Chelsy Pendleton of Utah with their ribbon. Ki placed as Best of Opposite Sex at the 149th annual Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show.
PA dog places at famous show

Lancashire Heeler wins ribbon at Westminster

x
Nominations open for Community Service awards

Forms due March 25; event scheduled for May 1

Poplars to be removed in spring

Boat Yard expansion part of larger project

Jeffco Aquatic Coalition launches pool survey

Results intended to inform design process

Voters approving all Peninsula school measures

Sequim bond passing with required supermajority

A snow-covered Mount Angeles is seen from Black Diamond Road a few miles south of Port Angeles. While the Peninsula has seen temperatures below freezing this week, a warming trend is expected by this weekend with highs reaching the upper 40s and overnight lows in the 30s. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Winter snowscape

A snow-covered Mount Angeles is seen from Black Diamond Road a few… Continue reading