Cartography by Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News ()

Cartography by Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News ()

Clallam County commissioner pulling out ‘cattle prod’ over state’s Dungeness water rule

PORT ANGELES — It’s high time for the state Department of Ecology to fix a broken water management rule for the Dungeness River basin, Clallam County Commissioner Jim McEntire said.

“It’s getting close to cattle-prod time,” he said.

“The rule’s been in effect now since January 2013. There’s no plan that I can see yet that makes the rule work the way that the rule says it’s supposed to work, so Ecology needs to fix that.”

Property owners in a large swath of land south of U.S. Highway 101 in the east county — known as the “yellow area” from Ecology maps — have no access to the “mitigation” they need to use water from new wells outdoors.

That’s a problem, McEntire said, because the county’s rural zoning allows for agriculture, horse stables and other outdoor pursuits.

Real estate transactions in the area, which extends south to the border of Olympic National Park, have fallen through because of the yellow area, McEntire added, and property values in the zone have diminished.

The controversial rule was supposed to provide mitigation for the entire rule area between Bagley Creek and Sequim Bay, McEntire said.

“I’d like to see the yellow area go away entirely because that is not found any place in the rule,” he said in a board work session Monday.

“It is just simply an artifact of [Ecology’s] water exchange not having come up with a source of mitigation water for those areas, at least to date.”

Ecology implemented the rule to ensure that the Dungeness River and neighboring streams have enough water to protect fish and human populations, particularly in the low flow period in the late summer and early fall.

Agency officials have said more water rights have been issued than there is water in the salmon-supporting Dungeness River.

The rule requires that the amount of water drawn from new wells be replaced with mitigation water to maintain instream flows.

Examples of mitigation include buying existing, unused water rights and aquifer recharge and flow restoration projects like the reopening of abandoned irrigation ditches and the construction of reservoirs.

But Ecology says that allowing outdoor use of water in the yellow area would adversely affect stream flows in the river and other waterways.

The yellow area is south of the southernmost irrigation ditches in the Sequim-Dungeness Valley.

Outside of the yellow area, mitigation for new wells can be purchased from a reserve that Ecology set up administratively. The rule does not affect wells that existed prior to its implementation.

Sen. Jim Hargrove, D-Hoquiam, helped secure $2.05 million in 2013 to pay for mitigation fees and water storage and conservation projects in the Dungeness Valley.

That appropriation will expire at the end of the current biennium, June 30.

McEntire, who represents the eastern third of the county and serves as board liaison for the water rule, drafted a Jan. 27 letter to Ecology Director Maia Bellon suggesting three ways to eliminate the yellow area.

His suggestions for mitigation were:

■   Obtain a legal determination that few new permit-exempt wells in the yellow area would draw from a 90-cubic-feet-per-second groundwater flow that pours into the Strait of Juan de Fuca. He based that suggestion on a report from a hydrogeologist.

■   Apply “out-of-kind”mitigation from downstream territory to the yellow area.

■   Drill a series of deep wells as far south as possible and allow a trickle of water to augment streams that would not otherwise benefit from deep aquifers.

In a March 3 reply letter, Bellon said Ecology has contracted with the state Department of Fish and Wildlife to “take a closer look at mitigation and opportunities.”

“The study is projected to be completed by next winter,” Bellon wrote.

“With the study results, we should be able to determine if ‘out-of-kind’ mitigation or other more flexible approaches to mitigation will provide the protections needed in the ‘yellow area.’”

Ecology will convene a “broad audience” of state and local experts to explore the merit and viability of McEntire’s suggestions, Bellon said.

“We expect preliminary recommendations from this work group this summer,” she said.

Kaj Ahlburg of the Olympic Resource Protection Council of Sequim asked county commissioners Tuesday to join a lawsuit the group filed Dec. 31 that challenges the water rule, or at least file an amicus brief in support of it.

Doing do would allow the county to negotiate with Ecology from a position of strength and provide leverage to “ensure that Ecology actually acts rather than just offers up unenforceable promises or more studies,” Ahlburg said.

Commissioners have not scheduled a discussion on joining the lawsuit.

Bellon in her letter said she understands the “public frustration with the difficulty of selling property in the affected areas and the reluctance of potential buyers to make offers on property that is for sale in this area.”

She also defended the need for a water rule in the Dungeness basin.

“This regulation protects existing water rights, established instream flows to protect the Dungeness River, and helps guide decisions on new water uses in the watershed,” Bellon said.

Although he was “underwhelmed” by the response letter, McEntire said he was encouraged after a recent meeting with Ecology officials.

He said the agency is showing alacrity in “coming up with ways to make the yellow area go away.”

On Monday, McEntire will present a response to Ecology’s response for his fellow commissioners to discuss.

In the new letter, he says the yellow area intrudes on the county’s land-use and zoning configuration.

Mary Ellen Winborn, first-year Department of Community Development director, told McEntire last week that the county should assemble a group of stakeholders and present a “complete package” to Ecology that “works for our community.”

“It’s Ecology’s issue,” McEntire said. “They manage water. They’ve got to solve the problem.”

Said Winborn: “Well, we might not be very happy with what they come up with.”

“I’m not happy right now with the fact that there’s no mitigation water available,” McEntire replied.

“That needs to be fixed. . . . We’ve suffered through the yellow area’s existence since the rule went into effect, and it’s time for that to go away.”

________

Reporter Rob Ollikainen can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 5072, or at rollikainen@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Election security measures in place

Fire suppressant just one example

Ruby Speer, 3, of Port Angeles receives a treat from KaraLee Monroe of Kindred Collective as part of Thursday’s Halloween festivities in downtown Port Angeles. Hundreds of youngsters and adults made their way door-to-door in search of candy and other treasures. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Trick or treat in Port Angeles

Ruby Speer, 3, of Port Angeles receives a treat from KaraLee Monroe… Continue reading

Karen Huber, sister of Nash Huber, the owner of Nash’s Organic Produce, stands by large crates that hold various seeds that Nash sells to farmers. She said she’s mitigated alleged violations and concerns from property owner, Washington Land Trust, but the longtime farmer faces eviction from the property if he doesn’t comply with ending his lease agreement that goes through 2032. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Washington Farmland Trust could evict Dungeness farmer

Nash Huber helped preserve Delta Farm in 1999

Amy Seidewand chair making. (Lacey Carnahan)
Port Townsend Woodworkers Show ready for the weekend

Event dedicated to memory of woodworking pillar

Two ghosts dangle from a tree in the breeze in the 200 block of West 10th street in Port Angeles. Halloween events are scheduled today throughout the North Olympic Peninsula. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Ghostly visions

Two ghosts dangle from a tree in the breeze in the 200… Continue reading

Port of Port Angeles awarded $9.4M in funds

Will help move toward zero-emission goals

Potential defense workload changes could have ripple effects

Clallam, Jefferson counties brace for decision, expected in January

Leaders discuss rural reproductive health

Policy, funding and workforce shortages considered

There were no serious injuries after a two-car collision pushed a Chevrolet pickup truck into the corner of the Emporium building at the corner of Eighth and Cherry streets in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Two-car collision pushes truck into building

A Chevrolet pickup truck collided with a building following… Continue reading

Two Totem Poles were missing from The Quileute Tribe’s 101 Building in Forks.
Sheriff’s office seeking information about missing totem poles

The Clallam County Sheriff’s Office is looking for information about… Continue reading

A recent snow is visible from Port Angeles on the Klahhane Ridge on Tuesday. The forecast for the rest of the week calls for high temperatures hovering about 50 degrees with a chance of showers and overnight lows in the low 40s. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Snowy peaks over Port Angeles

A recent snow is visible from Port Angeles on the Klahhane Ridge… Continue reading

Clallam County, Flaura’s Acres establish agreement

Utility Local Improvement District may be formed