As supporters on both sides of the case vie for position behind, Attorney General Bob Ferguson, right, and ACLU attorney Michael Scott speak with reporters following a hearing Tuesday in Bellevue before Washington’s Supreme Court about a florist who was sued for refusing to provide services for a same sex-wedding. (Elaine Thompson/The Associated Press)

As supporters on both sides of the case vie for position behind, Attorney General Bob Ferguson, right, and ACLU attorney Michael Scott speak with reporters following a hearing Tuesday in Bellevue before Washington’s Supreme Court about a florist who was sued for refusing to provide services for a same sex-wedding. (Elaine Thompson/The Associated Press)

Case of florist who denied service for gay wedding is heard

By Gene Johnson

The Associated Press

BELLEVUE — A florist who was sued for refusing to provide services for a same-sex wedding says she was exercising her First Amendment rights, but state Supreme Court justices repeatedly questioned Tuesday whether ruling in her favor would mean other businesses could turn away customers based on racial or other grounds.

The court heard arguments in the closely watched case against Barronelle Stutzman, a 71-year-old florist in Richland who was fined by a lower court for denying service to a gay couple in 2013.

Stutzman had previously sold the couple flowers and knew they were gay but told them she couldn’t provide flowers for their wedding because same-sex marriage was incompatible with her Christian beliefs.

Washington Attorney General Bob Ferguson and the couple sued her, saying she broke state anti-discrimination and consumer protection laws, and the lower court agreed.

It’s one of several lawsuits around the country — including some involving bakers and wedding photographers — about whether businesses can refuse to provide services involving causes they disagree with or whether they must serve everyone equally.

“A Muslim graphics designer should not be compelled to create designs promoting a Jewish Friends of Israel group, a gay public relations manager shouldn’t be forced to promote the Westboro Baptist Church, and a Christian floral designer shouldn’t be forced to create custom wedding designs for a wedding that is not between one man and one woman,” Stutzman’s attorney, Kristin Waggoner, told the court.

Waggoner immediately ran into questions. Justice Susan Owens brought up the state’s first and only black justice, the recently deceased Charles Z. Smith, who had to stay in separate hotels from other attorneys when he traveled the country while working for the Justice Department in the 1960s.

“How is this different?” Owens asked. “Because I’m sure some of the owners of those hotels would profess they had strongly held religious beliefs that prohibited racial integration.”

For one thing, Waggoner responded, renting out a hotel room isn’t a form of artistic expression or speech deserving of protection. Stutzman’s floral arrangements do constitute expression protected by the Constitution, the lawyer said, and the government can’t compel that expression.

“If we even get to the point where we might acknowledge that making floral arrangements is freedom of expression, what’s the limiting principle?” asked Justice Mary Yu. “Is it the landscape architect next? Is it the bartender?”

Justice Steven Gonzalez wanted to know why a business could refuse a gay couple but not an interracial couple.

Waggoner suggested that her client’s objections were based on a message — her opposition to same-sex marriage — rather than about targeting people for who they are, as the “unique evils of racial segregation” did.

Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud interrupted: “So racial discrimination would be based on a bad religious belief, according to you, but this discrimination would not be based on a bad religious belief. Doesn’t that task the courts with what’s a good religious belief and what’s a bad religious belief?”

Waggoner said it doesn’t.

“The context of marriage is very different,” she said, noting that millions of people believe marriage should be between one man and one woman, and those beliefs aren’t necessarily rooted in religion.

Michael Scott, a Seattle attorney who worked with the American Civil Liberties Union to represent Robert Ingersoll and Curt Freed — the couple denied the flowers — said he didn’t believe Stutzman’s floral creations constituted speech.

By providing flowers for a same-sex marriage, he argued, “she’s not endorsing same-sex marriage. She’s selling what she sells.”

Ferguson said the state’s argument rests on longstanding principle and uprooting it would severely weaken antidiscrimination law.

“ ‘No shoes, no shirt, no service’; ‘We do not use profanity in our messages’ — a business can absolutely have policies in place about the services they provide, as long as they apply that policy equally and not discriminate or refuse service or say, ‘We do not serve your kind,’ ” Ferguson said.

After the arguments, held in a packed theater at Bellevue College, a large crowd of Stutzman’s supporters greeted her outside, chanting her name and waving signs with pictures of roses that said “Justice For Barronelle.”

She told them she still feels fondly for Ingersoll, her old customer.

“To me, marriage is a very sacred event,” she said. “The government is asking me to choose between my affection for Rob and my faith.”

Supporters on both sides of the case vie for position following a hearing before Washington’s Supreme Court on Tuesday in Bellevue about a florist who was sued for refusing to provide services for a same sex-wedding. (Elaine Thompson/The Associated Press)

Supporters on both sides of the case vie for position following a hearing before Washington’s Supreme Court on Tuesday in Bellevue about a florist who was sued for refusing to provide services for a same sex-wedding. (Elaine Thompson/The Associated Press)

Barronelle Stutzman, center, a Richland florist who was fined for denying service to a gay couple in 2013, smiles as she is surrounded by supporters after a hearing before Washington’s Supreme Court on Tuesday in Bellevue. (Elaine Thompson/The Associated Press)

Barronelle Stutzman, center, a Richland florist who was fined for denying service to a gay couple in 2013, smiles as she is surrounded by supporters after a hearing before Washington’s Supreme Court on Tuesday in Bellevue. (Elaine Thompson/The Associated Press)

More in News

The ferry MV Coho backs into its landing after returning to Port Angeles on Tuesday following annual dry dock and maintenance in Anacortes. During the maintenance period, extensive work was performed on the dock, including replacement of a wing wall used to steer and secure the vessel during loading and unloading of cars and passengers. The ferry is scheduled to resume daily service between Port Angeles and Victoria on Thursday. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Coho returns

The ferry MV Coho backs into its landing after returning to Port… Continue reading

Building association calls for city to cease utility charges

Association says charges unconstitutional

Jefferson Land Trust considering conservation burial ground

Funds from plot sales could fund habitat improvements

Port Angeles artist Bob Stokes sits in his studio and music venue on Wednesday. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Art community mourns Bob Stokes’ passing

Legacy includes statues, concerts, gatherings

Clallam PUD
Cindy Kimble, Clallam PUD’s customer and community outreach programs coordinator, can help residents navigate the utility district’s revamped low-income energy assistance program.
Clallam PUD hires staff to help low-income customers

Clallam County Public Utility District has overhauled its low-income energy… Continue reading

Jen Colmore, left, and June Nichols of the Sequim Food Bank serve a sample of chili to Monica Dixon of Sequim during Saturday’s Community Chili Cookoff at the Sequim Boys & Girls Club. The event, organized by the club and Boy Scout Troop 90, showcased the culinary skills of six community organizations with each group receiving a share of the proceeds and the winner taking a $500 prize. The food bank’s chili recipe took top honors in the competition. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Chili cookoff

Jen Colmore, left, and June Nichols of the Sequim Food Bank serve… Continue reading

Port Townsend to test sewer system with smoke, dye

The city of Port Townsend will test its sewer… Continue reading

JUMP! Playground to close for renovations

Jefferson County Parks and Recreation will close the JUMP! Playground… Continue reading

Barcy Fisher, left, and Patti Buckland have been selected as the 2024 Marrowstone Island Citizens of the Year.
Fisher, Buckland honored as Marrowstone Island citizens of year

Barcy Fisher and Patty Buckland were named Marrowstone Island’s 2024… Continue reading

About 800 people from Jefferson and Clallam counties spill out from the steps of the Jefferson County Courthouse onto Jefferson Street in Port Townsend on Monday to take part in a National Day of Protest organized by the 50501 Movement, which stands for “50 protests, 50 states, 1 movement.” (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Hundreds protest actions of Trump administration

Activists cite USAID, worry about Treasury, impacts of immigration

Peninsula to welcome Canadian visitors

Celebration of Coho passengers planned

Fish barrier removal to impact highway traffic

Portions of roadway to have long-term closures