A sequoia tree at the edge of Lions Park in Port Angeles is slated for removal by the city because of safety concerns and property damage caused by its roots. (Jesse Major/Peninsula Daily News)

A sequoia tree at the edge of Lions Park in Port Angeles is slated for removal by the city because of safety concerns and property damage caused by its roots. (Jesse Major/Peninsula Daily News)

Attempt to delay removal of Port Angeles sequoia falls short with City Council

Plans to cut down tree for remain

PORT ANGELES — A last-ditch effort to delay the removal of the Lions Park sequoia failed to gain traction with the Port Angeles City Council this week.

Council member Lindsey Schromen-Wawrin’s motion to request a moratorium on tree removal died Tuesday for a lack of a second.

“This has been a really difficult decision,” Mayor Sissi Bruch said after an hour-long discussion.

Plans to fell the tree for safety reasons and concerns about property damage remain in place.

City officials have not announced the date on which a contractor will remove the 100-foot redwood from the neighborhood park at 601 E. Whidby Ave.

“Because of recent storm events, the city does not have a time frame to remove the tree at Lions Park,” Parks and Recreation Director Corey Delikat said Wednesday.

“Our hope is to have it down by the end of the year.”

Schromen-Wawrin’s motion to request that staff “develop an ordinance to adopt a moratorium on removal of the sequoia tree in Lions Park until the council has had an opportunity to review the tree removal policy” was based on a new arborist’s report.

Katy Bigelow, a master arborist who climbed the tree for a detailed inspection Dec. 11, determined in a Dec. 13 assessment that tree is in good health.

“The hazard posed by the potential for codominate trunks breaking out can be reduced to a low possibility by installing dynamic cabling and periodic monitoring by the risk managers,” Bigelow said in the 16-page report.

Bigelow’s Level 3 risk assessment was sought and provided to the city by environmental attorney Elizabeth Dunne, part of an ardent group of citizens who oppose the sequoia’s removal.

Supporters of the tree have named it “Hope.”

City officials decided to remove the tree after a multi-year public process that involved a citizen’s subcommittee, 10 public meetings, an in-house arborist’s assessment, a risk assessment from a third-party arborist and a new tree removal policy, City Manager Nathan West has said.

Kevin McFarland of Sound Urban Forestry, the city’s third-party arborist, concluded in a Level 2 risk assessment that dynamic cabling of the two main stems would reduce the risk from high to moderate-high but would “not eliminate the possibility of a failure.”

The two main stems of the sequoia form a weak union that could snap in high winds or by gravity, McFarland said in his January report.

Given the risk of stem failure and root damage to an adjacent driveway, McFarland recommended that the tree be removed.

“I think one of the reasons why the city’s been determined to move forward with this is because of an arborist’s report saying that there’s a high risk,” Schromen-Wawrin said.

“We now have a more qualified arborist’s report that is more thorough saying that there’s a low risk and it can be mitigated, it sounds like, by a $500 equipment expense.

“Given that, I don’t see a need to remove the tree from a risk management perspective,” Schromen-Wawrin added.

Twelve speakers testified in support of a moratorium in the first public comment period in a 3 1/2 hour meeting Tuesday. Many lamented the council’s inaction in a second comment period.

Several speakers noted that Hope the sequoia stood tall and protected a bird in the Friday windstorm that knocked down other trees and cut power to all of Clallam County.

“Please don’t be the Grinch who stole Christmas,” tree advocate Jasmine Hunt said.

“Hope is the name given to our sequoia. Now is the time for hope, for joy and for possibility.”

After the first round of public testimony, the council voted 4-3 to add the moratorium to the agenda.

Council members Schromen-Wawrin, Bruch, Mike French and Deputy Mayor Kate Dexter voted to discuss the item while Cherie Kidd, Michael Merideth and Jim Moran voted no.

“This is not an appropriate discussion for us,” Kidd said. “This is a staff decision at this point.”

Later in the meeting, Moran said the city could spend an “inordinate amount of staff time” and obtain 15 more arborist reports.

“I am vehemently opposed to infringing upon the decision-making process of the city manger and the city staff,” Moran said.

French defended the council’s role in the decision.

“There’s been lot of concern about us micromanaging our employee and his staff, but we have a boss, too, and our boss is our constituents,” French said.

“When they come to us to redress their grievances, as is protected in our United States Constitution, we have a duty to listen.”

French suggested that the city Parks, Recreation and Beautification Commission evaluate the competing arborist reports and make a recommendation.

“This isn’t a decision that we would bring for a group of volunteers at our parks commission when it’s about safety of a tree,” Delikat said.

“But who’s the arbiter of fact?” French replied. “We have two different assessments that disagree.”

Bruch said she struggled with her decision about the sequoia, citing Bigelow’s finding that likelihood of codominate trunk failure was possible.

“I would love to think that our sequoia could grow up to be 1,000 years old, but I think that that double leader has doomed it,” Bruch said of the two main trucks.

Bruch added that 1,000-year-old sequoias like those in California’s Sequioa National Park have one main stem.

“I’ve gone around and around on this one because, like I said, I really, truly believe in trees, love trees, I want to plant them everywhere,” Bruch said. “But this one really worries me.”

Dexter said she appreciated Bigelow’s report but had concerns about the long-term maintenance and monitoring of a dynamic cabling system.

West told the council that he had reviewed Bigelow’s report and he, too, had concerns with some of its recommendations.

West questioned whether a dynamic cabling system could withstand the weight of one of the main stems in a trunk failure.

“To me, it isn’t acceptable to have any risk relative to that residential dwelling unit and the residents that live within it,” West said of the neighboring house.

West said the city paid to have an in-house arborist conduct an initial assessment and a third-party arborist to provide a risk assessment.

“I have to concur with council member Moran,” West said. “How many different opinions are we going to get before we bring this to a final conclusion?”


Reporter Rob Ollikainen can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 56450, or at rollikainen@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Jon Picker, airport and marina manager for the Port of Port Angeles, describes runway sections for William R. Fairchild International Airport on a diagram of the terminal area. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Fairchild upgrades completed

Ribbon cutting is planned for Dec. 12

Clallam County eyes changes to park fees

Public hearing on adjustments set Dec. 12

Rich Foutch of Active Construction, Inc., in Tacoma paints a line on the roadway at the new roundabout at Kearney Street and state Highway 20 for the placement of temporary stripes in a pedestrian crosswalk on Monday in Port Townsend. The temperatures have to be in the mid-50s to install permanent striping, he said. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Roundabout striping

Rich Foutch of Active Construction, Inc., in Tacoma paints a line on… Continue reading

Proposal to rename Sequim road put on hold

Rotary, city to consider other options to honor local Olympian

Researcher: Managed forests needed to fight climate change

Wood products can replace existing fossil fuel-based materials

Jefferson County updates fee schedules

Environmental Public Health up 6 percent

The downtown Port Angeles Christmas tree is surrounded by people during a lighting ceremony on Saturday at First and Lincoln streets. The 30-foot tree will stand at the Conrad Dyar Memorial Fountain plaza through the holidays. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Lit up for the holidays

The downtown Port Angeles Christmas tree is surrounded by people during a… Continue reading

Community Aid seeks support for Toys for Sequim Kids

Nonprofit helps hundreds of children with Christmas presents

Planned electrical outage in Forks on Thursday

A planned power outage in Forks will affect electric service… Continue reading

Nordland man dies of injuries from Nov. 14 wreck

A second person involved in a two-car collision on Nov.… Continue reading

Santa Claus, portrayed by Stephen Rosales of Sequim, waves to the crowd after his arrival by vintage fire truck at Centennial Place in downtown Sequim on Saturday, part of the city’s Hometown Holidays celebration. Santa, accompanied by Irrigation Festival royalty, greeted children next to the city’s Christmas tree in an event that also featured music by the Sequim City Band and a lighted tractor parade. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Holiday tradition

Santa Claus, portrayed by Stephen Rosales of Sequim, waves to the crowd… Continue reading

District 3 chief pick bows out

Fire officials could resume search in ’24