Arraignment delayed for Port Townsend farmer/boat-builder accused of bank robbery

Michael J. Fenter, a Port Townsend boat builder alleged to be living a double life as a bank robber, is expected to enter a plea in federal court next Friday, after an arraignment scheduled this week was postponed.

Fenter, 40, is accused of robbing $73,000 from a Bank of America branch in Tacoma armed with a .40-caliber Glock handgun and claiming he had a bomb that his partner could detonate from outside the building, and is suspected in three other bank robberies, the FBI said.

He is charged with bank robbery and being armed in the commission of a violent felony.

Before he was taken into custody on Oct. 8, Fenter lived on the 40-acre Compass Rose Farms with his wife, Kateen Fenter — his high school sweetheart — their three children, and his in-laws.

The three generations of the family raised wool, honey and produce sold at local farmers markets on the farm owned by Kateen Fenter and her mother.

Michael Fenter, a graduate of the Northwest School of Wooden Boatbuilding in Port Townsend, paid the bill and the mortgage on the land the Fenters bought in 2007 with work in his field of marine carpentry, said his wife.

The arraignment, originally was scheduled Friday, was delayed because of a change of attorneys.

His first court-appointed attorney, Linda Sullivan, withdrew from the case Monday.

A new attorney, Timothy R. Lohraff, has been assigned to the case and will represent Fenter at this Friday’s hearing.

Remains in custody

Fenter remains in custody at the federal detention center in SeaTac without a posted bail.

During the robbery, Fenter allegedly told the assistant manager at the bank that he represented a group of people who were angry at the government, the FBI said.

After his arrest in Tacoma, Fenter refused to identify himself. He put a glue-like substance over his fingerprints and said his name was Patrick Henry.

He was referred to as the “John Doe bandit” until the FBI revealed his identity on Oct. 16.

The FBI also is investigating Fenter for one bank robbery in Seattle in February, one in San Francisco in April and one in Sacramento in August.

He has not been charged with those robberies.

Phone messages left for FBI spokeswoman Roberta Burroughs went unreturned Friday.

The Feb. 4 robbery of a Washington Mutual in Seattle resulted in building evacuations and street closures when a suspicious bag was left behind in the bank.

Fenter is not suspected of robbing any banks on the North Olympic Peninsula, Burroughs has said.

Fenter, who had no criminal record until his arrest last month, worked at the Sea Marine boat repair yard in Port Townsend until he quit in January.

The Fenters gave a conservation easement to Jefferson Land Trust on their land to protect salmon habitat on Snow Creek.

They worked together on the farm, aiming someday to be certified organic.

Fengter’s wife of 20 years said she learned of her husband’s arrest when an FBI agent called her on Oct. 9, and couldn’t believe what she was hearing.

“I just kept telling them, ‘No, it’s not true, it’s not Michael, it’s not even a possibility,'” she said Oct. 18.

________

Reporter Erik Hidle can be reached at 360-385-2335 or at erik.hidle@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

April Messenger, left, and Olympic National Park Ranger Chris Erickson share ideas on Wednesday during a listening session at Field Arts & Events Hall in Port Angeles. Nearly 150 people provided feedback about a new Hurricane Ridge Lodge project following the 2023 fire that destroyed the original structure. Nine easels were set up with questions and notes were provided for people to express their goals for a new lodge. The earliest construction can begin is in 2028, and it would take two to three years to complete, weather permitting. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Listening post

April Messenger, left, and Olympic National Park Ranger Chris Erickson share ideas… Continue reading

Port of Port Townsend to pursue grant for airport

Funds aimed to spur small industrial work

Future of Oceans program to focus on puffins

Expert spent 37 years studying seabirds in Alaska

The city of Port Angeles has put out a request for proposals for the sale of the historic fire hall at 215 S. Lincoln St. (City of Port Angeles)
Port Angeles is seeking a buyer for fire hall, prioritizes affordable housing

Historic preservation also noted for city’s landmark property

A standup paddle boarder and his dog take advantage of mild temperatures and calm waters on Tuesday to go for a ride on Port Townsend Bay. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Going for a ride

A standup paddle boarder and his dog take advantage of mild temperatures… Continue reading

Port of Port Angeles seeking design team

Building intended for aerospace production

Olympic National Park Superintendent Sula Jacobs answers questions Wednesday during the Port Angeles Chamber of Commerce luncheon at the Red Lion Inn. (Emily Hanson/Peninsula Daily News)
Superintendent says national park had more than 3.6M visitors in ’25

Construction projects to affect amenities in ONP this summer

Northwest Maritime CEO to take six-month sabbatical

Northwest Maritime CEO Jake Beattie will take a planned… Continue reading

Rachel Anderson.
Sequim City Council elects Anderson as mayor

The Sequim City Council elected Rachel Anderson as mayor and… Continue reading

Wedner Klebanow uses both arms to control a kite at Fort Worden State Park on Sunday. She was with her father, Rick Klebanow, in 16 mph winds, strong enough for the kite to perform certain stunts. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Let’s go fly a kite

Wender Klebanow uses both arms to control a kite at Fort Worden… Continue reading

Port Townsend plans for street projects in 2026

Sales tax, grants to fund expanded effort

Dr. Evan Small.
Emergency department director says many factors drive wait times

Small: Repeated OMC violations didn’t involve issues with patient care