Accused killer Pierce heads for fourth trial after motion to dismiss denied

PORT TOWNSEND –– Michael J. Pierce will face a fourth trial for the March 2009 murders of Quilcene farm couple Pat and Janice Yarr.

Kitsap County Superior Court Judge Sally Olsen rejected Friday a motion from Pierce’s public defender, Richard Davies of Port Townsend, to dismiss charges of two counts of first-degree murder and one count each of first-degree burglary, first-degree robbery, first-degree arson, theft of a firearm, second-degree unlawful possession of a firearm and second-degree theft.

Davies had argued that the charges should be dismissed because of “outrageous conduct” by jailors and that it would put Pierce in double jeopardy.

“No actions undertaken by the government here warrant a finding of ‘outrageous conduct’ sufficient to necessitate dismissal,” Olsen wrote in her decision filed at 1:04 p.m.

Pierce’s trial is slated to begin Oct. 6 in Kitsap County.

A Jefferson County jury convicted Pierce on the charges in 2010.

He was serving a life sentence in prison when the state Court of Appeals overturned the conviction in 2012.

Pierce has been tried two times since, once in Jefferson County and once in Kitsap County, with both ending in mistrials.

Davies’ dismissal request was considered over five partial days of testimony in which psychiatric experts testified to the levels of Pierce’s psychopathy, a disorder that produces voices that sound like a “radio playing in the back of his head.”

Psychotropic meds

Davies argued that those symptoms worsened after Kitsap County jailors stopped administering pyschotropic medications when a 14-day “bridge” prescription expired during the middle of his second retrial.

The Kisap County mistrial was called by Olsen after it was discovered Pierce had been off his medications.

Pierce’s original conviction was overturned by the state Court of Appeals on the grounds that his constitutional rights were denied after his arrest and that Prosecuting Attorney Scott Rosekrans’ closing argument in the original trial represented prosecutorial misconduct.

After an investigation, the Washington State Bar Association later cleared Rosekrans of ethical violations for speculating during closing arguments what the Yarrs and Pierce were thinking during the night of the murders.


Sequim-Dungeness Valley Editor Joe Smillie can be reached at 360-681-2390, ext. 5052, or at

More in News

Chris Johnson of Nordland-based Nordland Construction loads traffic drums onto a trailer as coworker Robert Bufford prepares to secure the load as the pair prepares to open the parking lot at Port Angeles City Pier to automobiles on Friday. The work was part of a project to improve storm drainage, replace damaged sidewalks and ADA ramps and mitigate shoreline erosion around the lot, which had been closed since early January. Tree replacement and other project detail work is expected to follow over the next few weeks.
City Pier parking open

Chris Johnson of Nordland-based Nordland Construction loads traffic drums onto a trailer… Continue reading

Sequim Citizen of the Year luncheon on Tuesday

Emiko Brock, Labbe, Olsen to be honored

EYE ON THE PENINSULA: Broadband, public health before county boards

Government meetings across North Olympic Peninsula

A pair of Clallam Transit buses sit at The Gateway Transit Center in Port Angeles in preparation for their fixed-route runs on Thursday. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Clallam Transit sees large rise in ridership

No issues seen with new zero-fare policy

Plans move ahead for Quilcene skate park

Jefferson County, volunteers seek grants

Peninsula College Foundation reports record levels of giving

Programs, students both recipients of funds

County to repave section of Carlsborg Road

Clallam County commissioners will consider awarding a contract for… Continue reading

A paving crew from Lakeside Industries replaces pavement on the Waterfront Trail and the entrance to the Port Angeles City Pier parking lot on Wednesday as part of a project to improve sidewalks and storm water drainage around the site. The project is expected to be substantially completed and the parking lot reopened by mid-March. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Port Angeles City Pier

A paving crew from Lakeside Industries replaces pavement on the Waterfront Trail… Continue reading

Port Townsend approves utility rate changes, renames skate park

Public hearing set for Transportation Benefits District

Slate of initiatives has upended Olympia, lobbyist says

‘Potential showstoppers’ described at Coffee with Colleen

Artist Chris Stevenson, who described herself as an urban sketcher from Port Townsend, uses a pencil for scale as she sketches the work at the new entrance to Point Hudson Marina on Monday morning. A group in town, the Port Townsend Urban Sketchers will meet at 10 a.m. Saturday to sketch at the Port Townsend Aero Museum. Sessions are free and open to sketchers of all skill levels. For more information, see (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Marina art

Artist Chris Stevenson, who described herself as an urban sketcher from Port… Continue reading