A grilled cheese sandwich sits waiting for a bowl of tomato soup. (Carrie Sanford/for Peninsula Daily News)

A grilled cheese sandwich sits waiting for a bowl of tomato soup. (Carrie Sanford/for Peninsula Daily News)

PENINSULA KITCHEN: Grilled cheese sandwich and tomato soup provide fall comfort food

THE ULTIMATE KIDDO compliment: “Mama, your homemade tomato soup tastes just like the stuff from a can.”

That was uttered more than six years ago by my darling daughter.

We had this soup just the other night, and I think she’d revise her compliment now to say, “This is even better than canned tomato soup.”

Her 12½-year-old palate is becoming much more discerning with age.

She appreciates food tasting more like the ingredients and less like the canned version these days.

Because we’ve finally seen some fall-like weather in these parts and we’re collecting quite a counter-load of tomatoes from our CSA farm share, tomato soup is a welcome addition to our family meal rotation.

You can get away with adding extra vegetables to this mix, too: bell pepper, extra carrots and basil.

The tomatoes are the star of this soup, of course.

I find I have either a plethora or a dearth of fresh tomatoes.

In the case of the former, I remove all stems and greens and freeze tomatoes whole, doling them out judiciously for soups such as this or chili throughout the winter.

I add them frozen and whole to the hot stock.

In the case of no fresh or frozen tomatoes in the house, please do not be tempted by the mealy, pale tomatoes in the grocery store in wintertime.

Instead, use canned tomatoes.

They are preserved at the peak of ripeness.

You’ll be much happier with the results.

Finally, there’s nothing that goes with tomato soup quite as well as a grilled cheese sandwich.

My husband’s trick is to grill both sides of the sandwich in a butter-slathered skillet until it is perfectly golden brown.

He then slides them into a warm oven to finish melting the cheese and keep them hot while I’m pureeing the soup.

We like our grilled cheese cut into triangles for easier dipping into a cup or bowl of soup.

Slicing sandwiches into bite-size croutons to float on the soup is also a delicious and beautiful choice.

Cream of Tomato Soup Adapted from Mark Bittman’s “How to Cook Everything”

1 tablespoon butter

1 medium onion, sliced

2 cloves garlic, diced

1 carrot, diced

Salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste

4 cups chopped tomato (canned is fine; include the juices, or do a combination of both)

1 tablespoon homemade pesto (or more to taste)

1-2 cups chicken stock

1 cup cream or half-and-half or milk

Melt butter in a large, deep pot.

When hot, add the onion, garlic and carrot.

Sprinkle with salt and pepper and cook, stirring, until the onions begin to soften, about five minutes.

Add the tomato and pesto and cook, stirring occasionally, until the tomato breaks up, 10 to 15 minutes.

Add the stock, sti, and cook until hot, then lower the heat and simmer about five minutes.

Taste and adjust the seasonings.

Add the cream to the soup, and puree it carefully with an immersion blender.

Heat just until warm throughout.

Serve with grilled cheese to dip or with croutons floating on top.

___________

Carrie Sanford, who shares the Peninsula Kitchen column with Betsy Wharton, is a mother, wife, educator, artist, activist and cook.

She writes the newsletter for Salt Creek Farm in Joyce during the growing season and volunteers with nonprofits and schools in Port Angeles, where she lives with her husband, Tom Sanford, and their daughter, Abby.

More in Life

The 2024 Community Service Awards winners gather before Thursday's awards ceremony at Holy Trinity Lutheran Church in Port Angeles. This year's recipients were, seated from left, Steph Ellyas and Lyn Fiveash, and standing from left, Gordon Taylor, Don Zanon, Carol Labbe and Betsy Reed Schultz. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Six honored for community service efforts

Volunteers provide energy for trails, respite care

Photo by Karen Griffiths

Cutline: A fundraiser for WAG and Open starts Today at 11 a.m. with an English and jumping fun show, followed tomorrow with a Western Games show at Kari Payne’s 4-L arena off Blue Mountain Road, 95 S. McCrorie Rd. Port Angeles.  Fox-Bell Farm owner Shelby Vaughan, and her assistants Sophie Feik and Kaia Lestage (holding Marley) will be there to host. Shown is Tatar Trots, 10. a horse Shelby got from OPEN five years ago when he was a feral, unhandled stallion and, now, after castrating and training,  he’s a docile horse who enjoys teaching kids how to ride.

 

(Rescue dog Rocky laying down if he’s shown in photo)
HORSEPLAY: Rescue program gives horses new life

SHELBY VAUGHAN WAS born into the rescue mindset. She grew up on… Continue reading

A GROWING CONCERN: For garden chores, keep the spring in your step

SO THE DREAM Playground build is going wonderfully. Thank you for those… Continue reading

ISSUES OF FAITH: Be a gracious and hospitable host

NOTICE OUR ROAD traffic is getting busier? Yep. We are beginning our… Continue reading

The Rev. Larry Schellink will present “Love God and Tie up your Camel” at 10:30 a.m. Sunday. Schellink is the guest speaker at Unity in the Olympics, 2917 E. Myrtle Ave.
Weekend program scheduled for Unity in the Olympics

The Rev. Larry Schellink will present “Love God and… Continue reading

Unity speaker slated in Port Angeles

Phoenix Biggs will present “Singing of Honor… Continue reading

Jaiden Dokken, at Jeanette Best Gallery in Port Townsend, is Northwind Art’s new exhibits coordinator. (Northwind Art)
Poet laureate takes on new role with Northwind Art

Artist, poet and educator Jaiden Dokken is Northwind Art’s… Continue reading

Author John Vaillant stands in front of the iconic tower at Port Angeles City Pier. (Elijah Sussman/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Author visits Peninsula for Writer in Residence program

Vaillant awarded Shaughnessy Cohen Prize

A GROWING CONCERN: Volunteers a dream for playground

YOU, MY LOYAL readers, have been excellent the couple of times I… Continue reading

Unity in Port Townsend planning for Sunday services

Joanna Gabriel will present the lesson at 11 a.m.… Continue reading

The Rev. Cindy Akana
Program scheduled for OUUF on Sunday

The Rev. Cindy Akana will present “Mother Wolf, Mother… Continue reading