Port Angeles man pleads not guilty to rape charges

PORT ANGELES — A Port Angeles man charged with raping two 14-year-old girls has pleaded not guilty.

Justin Michael Thayer, 20, was arraigned Friday on a charge of third-degree child rape of one of the girls. The charge was filed July 29.

He also pleaded not guilty to second-degree rape by forcible compulsion and three charges of third-degree child rape of the other girl. Those charges were filed Tuesday.

Status hearings on both cases were set Friday for 9 a.m. Aug. 28.

Separate four-day trials were set for September and October.

He knew both teenagers, meeting one at a birthday party for a 14-year-old girl, according to court documents.

Both girls said Thayer ignored their pleas to stop while he was assaulting them, according to court documents.

The newest charges grew out of four alleged sexual assaults that allegedly occurred between Jan. 27- May 8, 2019, according to the criminal information. The girl is now 15, according to court documents.

The alleged assaults were reported by Child Protective Services, which reported the girl was having a sexual relationship with an older man later identified as Thayer, according to a probable cause statement written by Port Angeles Police Officer Jeffery Ordona.

The girl was 14 during two sexual encounters, while Thayer was 18 when the relationship began and 19 when it ended, according to the statement.

During the alleged assault, she yelled at him and pushed him off of her, according to the statement.

Thayer admitted to having a sexual relationship with the girl, saying the encounters occurred at the same locations in his vehicle that the girl said they occurred.

“Thayer told me that he and [the girl’s] age difference was his ‘biggest concern’ and that some people thought it was legal, while others disagreed,” Ordona said in the statement.

The age of consent in Washington is 16.

Thayer said he had consensual sex with the other 14-year-old, according to the probable cause statement written by county sheriff’s Deputy Marc Titterness.

The two were at her friend’s house when she and the friend fell asleep, and she woke up to him taking off her clothes, she said.

“[The girl] told Justin to stop several times while Justin was messing with her pants,” according to the statement.

“[The girl] was in and out of consciousness, would wake up and not remember what was happening.”

Thayer remained in the county jail Friday on $100,000 bail.

Third-degree child rape is a Class C felony punishable by up to five years in jail and a maximum $10,000 fine.

Second-degree rape by forcible compulsion is a Class A felony punishable by up to life in prison and a maximum $50,000 fine


Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 55650, or at [email protected] peninsuladailynews.com.

More in Crime

Ryan Warren Ward, left, looks over court papers with attorney Lane Wolfley during Ward's sentencing for three counts of aggravated first-degree murder and multiple counts of theft and firearms violations on Thursday in Clallam County Superior Court in Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Murder sentence: Life without parole

Family members discuss their pain at court hearing

Kallie Ann LeTellier, 36, appears via video in Clallam County Superior Court. She pleaded guilty to her role in a December 2018 murder and has been sentenced to 35 years in prison.
Port Angeles woman sentenced for murder

Kallie Ann LeTellier pleads guilty, will serve 35 years

Driver leaves scene after collision with pole knocks out power

An alleged hit-and-run collision with a utility pole knocked out… Continue reading

Port Angeles man sentenced to seven-plus years for meth sale

A 26-year-old Port Angeles man has been sentenced to… Continue reading

Charge filed in Port Angeles High School roof fire

A Port Angeles man accused of setting fire to… Continue reading

Corrections officer charged with first-degree child rape

A Clallam Bay Corrections Center officer has been charged… Continue reading

Former Port Angeles student accused in roof fire

Four others said to have been with him

Two charged in window-shooting spree in Port Angeles

Two men were charged Wednesday in connection with a… Continue reading

Mike Johnson
Oregon man charged with knife attack at Port Angeles church

A 43-year-old Oregon man has been charged with an… Continue reading

Oregon man in custody after church incident

Casey Strege allegedly assaulted two security guards in Port Angeles

Report: Marysville man attacked another deputy

Additional charges now on former mental patient