Benjamin Bonner approaches defense attorney Harry Gasnick during Bonner’s first appearance in Clallam County Superior Court last month. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)

Benjamin Bonner approaches defense attorney Harry Gasnick during Bonner’s first appearance in Clallam County Superior Court last month. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)

Mental health evaluation ordered for man accused in Sequim woman’s beating death

PORT ANGELES — A Bainbridge Island High School junior accused of murdering a Sequim-area woman and killing her dog must undergo a mental health evaluation to determine whether he is capable of entering pleas on charges of second-degree murder, first-degree robbery and first-degree animal cruelty.

Benjamin Bonner, 18, who has a delusion disorder, according to a Peninsula Behavioral Health mental health assessment, must undergo a forensic mental health evaluation, Clallam County Superior Court Judge Erik Rohrer ruled Friday, the same day Bonner was expected to enter pleas on the charges.

Rohrer set a status hearing on the case for 9 a.m. June 16.

“The court finds that there is reason to doubt the defendant’s competency,” according to the court order mandating the evaluation.

Bonner, who remained in the Clallam County jail Tuesday on $1.5 million bail, is accused of murdering family friend and children’s advocate Cynthia Little, 71, on May 4 in her Sequim-area Sunland Golf &Country Club home.

He allegedly killed her the day after being released from a mental facility for threatening his adoptive mother, according to the arrest report.

Bonner allegedly took his parents’ SUV without their permission to Little’s home, where he beat Little to death with a fireplace poker, according to the arrest report.

He told authorities he was defending himself against Little, his mother’s longtime friend, who had been described as “like a grandmother figure” to Bonner.

Bonner said Little “tried to attack him by grabbing at him; which he demonstrated as a hugging motion,” according to a probable-cause statement by Sheriff’s Detective Brian Knutson.

The statement said that Little, a volunteer with Court Appointed Special Advocates, repeated “I love you” as Bonner beat her.

Bonner was given a mental health assessment by Port Angeles-based Peninsula Behavioral Health, according to a May 10 report signed by clinician Mac McIntyre.

“It seems obvious that [Bonner] is suffering from some form of a Delusional Disorder (he denied hearing voices or seeing hallucinations) or possibly the beginning of unspecified schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorder,” according to the assessment.

“Client was for the most part consistent with his story that he is the victim of this awful event and he does not know what happened to change what he thought was a safe environment to a dangerous one that he had to defend for all his might.”

Bonner said in the PBH assessment interview that he was diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder at age 8 and treated with medication until age 14.

“Client does not take responsibility for the event that led to the death of his friend, Cynthia Little, and her dog,” according to the assessment.

During the assessment, Bonner spoke of “things starting to ‘go weird’ ” a few days before Little’s death when he was kept out of school.

His anti-psychotic medication was adjusted during the previous week when he received pain medication for dental care he received, according to the arrest report.

He told the PBH evaluator that Little lied to him the night of her death.

“This all leading to how Cynthia changed and that the person who he scuffled with and then hit repeatedly was not Cynthia,” according to the assessment.

“ ‘And when she did grab me I thought, “This is not Cynthia” and I hit her and hit her,’ ” the assessment quotes Bonner as saying.

“Then he explained why he hit the dog too, as he judged that it was aggressive to him.”

During the interview, Bonner said he was innocent.

“ ‘I didn’t know anything was going to happen. I was at the home for safety. Something happened with Cynthia,’ ” Bonner said during the assessment.


Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 55650, or at

More in Crime

Former Olympic Medical Center emergency department physician Josiah Hill, left, was sentenced on Monday to 179 days in jail during a hearing in Clallam County Superior Court. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
Former ER doctor gets 179 days in jail

Hill pleads guilty to gross misdemeanors

Forks man arrested on investigation of drug possession

A Forks man was arrested on investigation of drug possession… Continue reading

Attempted murder trial pushed to November

Sequim man allegedly shot at neighbor in 2022

Drive-by shooter sentenced to 5½ years in prison

Port Angeles man convicted after two-day jury trial

Arrest warrant issued for Sequim contractor

Complainants allege Gamboa failed to complete jobs after being paid

Sequim man charged with six counts of child rape

A Sequim man is facing six counts of third-degree… Continue reading

Alleged bank robber shot by police is identified

A man who allegedly attempted to rob a bank… Continue reading

Woman gets 20 years for murder

Court adds four months for max penalty

Former ER physician still faces civil trial

Hill pleaded guilty to lesser charges Friday