Bill to protect First Amendment rights of student newspapers moves through Legislature

By Taylor McAvoy

WNPA Olympia News Bureau

OLYMPIA — Lawmakers are considering adding protections for high school and college newspapers, allowing student journalists to determine their own content.

SB 5064, sponsored by Sen. Joe Fain, R-Auburn, passed the Senate easily with a vote of 45-4 Jan. 19. The bill was passed by the House of Representatives Judiciary Committee on Thursday.

“By passing this bill we would be free from our censorship fears and would be able to spend more time educating ourselves and our student body while reporting honestly and ethically,” Haley Keizur, social media editor of the Viking Vanguard, student newspaper of Puyallup High School.

Fain introduced the bill in 2016 and said he drafted the bill after meeting with journalism teachers and students at Auburn High School.

“There’s almost been an ideological battle that paints journalists as the bad guy,” he said. “I think we need to reflect on the damage that can do.”

The bill’s origins date back to 2005 when former legislator and now King County Councilman Dave Upthegrove introduced the bill in response to a 1988 U.S. Supreme Court decision in a case that originated in St. Louis, Mo., Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier.

In that case, the court ruled that high school educators can have editorial control over a school-sponsored newspaper when they have a legitimate educational concern. Those concerns include control over articles that are poorly written, biased, “unsuitable for immature audiences” or “inconsistent with the values of a civilized social order,” according to the court text.

Mike Hiestand, attorney and legal consultant for the Student Press Law Center, said the bill would turn back the clock on the Hazelwood decision to the less-strict Tinker standard.

That standard arose from a U.S. Supreme Court case in Des Moines, Iowa, in 1969, Tinker v. Des Moines, and says that in order for a school to suppress free speech, the speech must “materially and substantially interfere” with class or the school’s operation. The court ruled 7-2 that students do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.”

SB 5064 requires schools to follow the less strict standard but, Fain said, it ensures that advisers are still able to be involved in helping students avoid writing stories that might be libelous or an invasion of privacy, teaching them responsible pillars of journalism.

“In light of the battles over free speech, and the rights and roles of journalists today, this is a really important piece of legislation,” Fain said.

“The next generation in this important profession can recognize both the right and the responsibility that they have to bear when it comes to their freedoms in this area.”

Jacoy Willis, a sophomore at the University of Washington studying political science and journalism, offered an example.

The student newspaper at her former high school in Kenmore, Nordic News, wanted to run an article in response to a hazing incident at the school by a group called the “Naked Viks” but the administration stopped it.

The incident drew national attention and Willis said the school administration would not allow the students to run a story about it in their paper.

Willis, who was editor-in-chief at the paper, said the story was about the psychology of hazing, its effects on the school, and how to identify and stop the behavior. The publication left the names of victims out and adhered to the Society of Professional Journalists Code of Ethics, she said.

“Only our school can cover the details of our students, what they thought, why it happened to us, why they are scared to go to football games, and what it means for the future of school spirit; things that can’t be covered in national news,” she said.

Roz Thompson, speaking for the Association of Washington School Principals, said the association is concerned about the emotional safety of students. She said the bill should include protections from stories that could be hurtful to other students.

The bill also includes protections for school newspaper advisers. The bill would not allow administration to punish advisers for protecting students’ free speech rights but still allows for school officials to place and hire staff to best fit their needs.

________

This story is part of a series of news reports from the Washington State Legislature provided through a reporting internship sponsored by the Washington Newspaper Publishers Association Foundation.

More in Politics

Clallam commissioner candidates discuss issues at forum

Clallam County commissioner candidates Dale Wilson, Mike Doherty and… Continue reading

Three candidates for District Court I judge tell of qualifications in Port Angeles

Three lawyers vying for Clallam County’s Port Angeles-area District… Continue reading

Conservative revolt over immigration sinks House farm bill

By Andrew Taylor and Lisa Mascaro The Associated Press WASHINGTON, D.C. —… Continue reading

Former Clallam County commissioner aims at old seat; sheriff now faces opposition

Former Clallam County Commissioner and Democrat Mike Doherty is… Continue reading

Three-way contest forms in Jefferson County

A three-way contest has developed for a Jefferson County… Continue reading

All but one incumbent unopposed so far in Clallam candidate filings

Incumbent elected Clallam County officials are sitting pretty for… Continue reading

One Jefferson candidate files for county office on Wednesday

One candidate filed for office Wednesday morning in the… Continue reading

Contests created with new candidate filings

The second day of candidates filing for the Nov.… Continue reading

Candidates get early start on filing week in Jefferson

Several candidates got an early start Monday morning at… Continue reading