John Wayne Marina in Sequim is shown in this March 2018 photo. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)

John Wayne Marina in Sequim is shown in this March 2018 photo. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)

Port of Port Angeles to appeal Sequim determination on John Wayne Marina

SEQUIM — A disagreement has escalated between Port of Port Angeles and Sequim city officials over the future of John Wayne Marina.

The port is appealing the city’s May 25 administrative determination that the shoreline master program unquestionably prohibits the 300-slip public marina, owned by the port and located within the city limits, from being operated by a private entity.

“We have a fundamental disagreement,” port Executive Director Karen Goschen said Thursday.

“When you talk about property rights and the authority of one government agency versus another government agency to manage their property based on their mission, we should have those rights protected.

“It’s a matter of principle.

“We asked that the city and port and Ecology work together on this, and the city chose to be adversarial,” she said.

The nine-page determination was a response to the port’s request for clarity on what the port can and can’t do with the marina, said Sequim City Manager Charlie Bush.

Bush said the city will have to contract with a hearing examiner to hear the appeal.

The city code says appeals must be heard by a board of adjustment, and the city does not have one.

The City Council, which voted April 23 that it “values John Wayne Marina as a public asset,” noted widespread opposition to selling the marina to a private party as part of its resolution.

Port officials are considering the option in light of interest from two private developers and the need for $22 million by 2035 for float, piling and breakwater improvements.

Port commissioners also are considering a Nov. 6 general election ballot measure that would ask voters countywide to approve a 6.4-cents-per-$1,000 levy increase to fund the upgrades.

The administrative determination was authored by Barry Berezowsky, the city Department of Community Development manager-shoreline administrator, and Kristina Nelson-Gross, the city attorney.

They said the city shoreline master program “unambiguously” prohibits private boating facilities and marinas on city shorelines.

“To interpret the city’s Shoreline Master Program as the port suggests is a strained reading and would lead to absurd results,” they said.

Simon Barnhart, port counsel-deputy executive director, said the appeal was filed Wednesday.

“Under a plain reading of the city’s shoreline master program, operation of the John Wayne Marina, as a marina, under private ownership is not prohibited,” it says.

It says the administrative determination “is more restrictive than is necessary given the regulatory controls that are available to the city through both the shoreline master program and the Shoreline Management Act.”

Port board of commissioners President Connie Beauvais also has said the prohibition is not as clear as the city says it is.

Port officials point to a provision that says “new marina development or expansion of existing private marina facilities shall be allowed only in the urban and associated aquatic shoreline environments through a shoreline conditional use permit.”

”The mere reference to ‘expansion of existing private marinas’ does not mean that private marinas are allowed in the City’s current shoreline environments,” Berezowsky and Nelson-Gross responded in the determination.

The state Department of Ecology also agrees with the city’s administrative determination, Rick Mraz, the shorelands technical and regulatory lead for Ecology’s Shorelands and Environmental Assistance Program, said in a May 30 email to Berezowsky.

“That person at Ecology does not make the determination on interpretation of law,” Goschen responded.

Beauvais said she was surprised the determination was issued.

“We had just asked them a question, a point of clarification, and they sent a very formal letter back that we had not asked for,” she said Wednesday.

Bush said Goschen, Beauvais and Barnhart had all raised questions in recent weeks that needed to be answered.

“Clearly they were confused, and we wanted to make sure that nobody’s confused,” Bush said.

“For them to say they never requested [the determination] is kind of amazing.”

Goschen said she notified commissioners that she would file an appeal.

Beauvais said the decision to file the appeal was appropriately made at the staff level.

Commissioner Steven Burke said Thursday the appeal had been discussed in executive session.

“All of us want to maintain John Wayne Marina as a public marina,” he said.

Berezowsky said Thursday that privately-owned public marinas also are prohibited.

According to the determination, port officials were concerned about the prohibition on allowing private marinas in the city limits in 2013 when the shoreline master program was adopted “but failed to convince the city to eliminate the prohibition, and the City Council’s decision was not appealed.”

The port’s website at www.portofpa.com says the late actor John Wayne donated 23 acres of land at Pitship Point in 1975 on condition that it be developed as a public marina.

________

Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 55650, or at pgottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading

Navy training exercise to be conducted Thursday

Naval Magazine Indian Island will conduct a security training… Continue reading

North Olympic Library System public service specialist Jessica Raivo transfers books from the stacks to a cart on Saturday at the Sequim Public Library for eventual transport to a temporary library building. The current library on North Sequim Avenue is slated for renovation and expansion with library services slated to resume on April 1 at 609 W. Washington St., next to Fifth Avenue Furniture, in the storefront that was previously Brian’s Sporting Goods. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Book transfer

North Olympic Library System public service specialist Jessica Raivo transfers books from… Continue reading

Jefferson County is eying short-term rental regulations

Feedback to be presented to Planning Commission

Clallam PUD seeking faster solution for West End outages

County commissioners, coalition support idea of expanded right of way

From left to right, Sean Coleman, Colleen Robinson, Brown Maloney and Todd Ortloff display the awards they earned Friday during the annual gala of the Clallam County Economic Development Council at Field Arts & Events Hall in Port Angeles (Lorie Fazio/Clallam County EDC)
Coleman named Olympic Leader of the Year at EDC gala

Habitat for Humanity, Radio Pacific also win awards during event

Historic bell missing from Camp Parsons

Property crime up in Brinnon area, director says

Casey and Karen Proud, both of Sequim, look at a selection of St. Patrick’s Day hats and other souvenirs for participating in Saturday’s Shamrock Shuffle & Pub Crawl in downtown Port Angeles. The event, a benefit for the Hurricane Ridge Winter Sports Education Foundation, allowed crawlers to receive six tasting tokens for libations at participating bars and restaurants in the downtown area with a drawing for additional prizes. Numerous downtown businesses also offered sale discounts for purchases during the crawl. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Winter sports benefit in Port Angeles

Casey and Karen Proud, both of Sequim, look at a selection of… Continue reading

U.S. Rep. Derek Kilmer, right, discusses emergency services on Thursday during a roundtable session with emergency managers from across the region, including Clallam County Sheriff Brian King, left, and Clallam County Administrator Todd Mielke in Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Clallam seeks additional funds for emergency operations center

Administrator says $10 million still needed for proposed project

More than 100 educators appeared at Thursday’s Port Angeles School District board meeting to show their support for paraeducators, who are seeking a 3.7 percent pay raise and have been working without a contract since Aug. 31. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
Paraeducators fill school board meeting

Labor group asking for same raise teachers received

Committee forms to support Quilcene school levy

Lack of communication cited for failed vote

Herb Beck Marina improvements in the works

New concrete boat launch among the plans