Port Angeles approves more money for water facilities legal dispute

PORT ANGELES — A Seattle law firm’s contract has been boosted to $407,500 to represent the city of Port Angeles in an industrial water facilities dispute with the National Park Service.

City council members Tuesday unanimously approved increasing the budget for the legal services agreement with Lane Powell LLC by $185,000, nearly doubling a contract council members approved June 7, 2016.

They approved the increase even as city officials continue negotiations with the National Park Service on reaching a settlement over water facilities the federal government built to mitigate the sediment impact on city water of removing the Elwha River dams.

The project to remove the Glines Canyon and Elwha dams — the largest such effort in U.S. history — was completed in 2014.

Public Works Director Craig Fulton said Wednesday that he and City Engineer Jeff Bender will travel June 21 to the Park Service’s Denver Service Center headquarters.

There, he said, Fulton will huddle with federal officials to discuss ways to lower the repair estimates and operating costs of the water facilities, which the Park Service wants to turn over to the city.

The water is utilized by the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe for its hatchery and the state Department of Fish and Wildlife for its fish-rearing channel.

It also will be used by the now-shuttered Ediz Hook mill purchased March 31 by Mexican-owned McKinley Paper Co. .

“Everyone wants to reach a settlement on this,” Fulton said Wednesday in an interview.

“We are looking for a new contract with a new scope of work.”

City council members were of one mind on increasing the contract with Lane Powell.

“For me, this is all about the original agreement,” Mayor Patrick Downie said.

Deputy Mayor Cherie Kidd recalled then-Mayor Jim Hallett testifying before Congress in 1992 and the city agreeing to dam removal as long as the water supply was protected, paving the way for passage of the 1992 Elwha River Ecosystem and Fisheries Restoration Act.

“We will fight for the water rights we have been guaranteed,” Kidd said.

The new budget for Lane Powell “is a big number,” Councilwoman Sissi Bruch said.

“Compared to what we have and what we could lose, [what we could lose] is way higher,” she said.

“We are talking about millions and millions and millions of dollars.”

City Attorney Bill Bloor said in a memo to the council that the funds for Lane Powell will be drawn from a city water treatment plant account.

“As one part of the resolution of the city’s claims against NPS, one goal is to reimburse the treatment plant account for all funds used to resolve the Elwha dam removal issues,” Bloor said in the memo.

“Unfortunately, the facilities that were built by the park service on the river to protect the city’s water failed, and they weren’t adequate, and as a result of that the city has been in negotiations with the Park Service to remediate that situation,” Bloor told council members Tuesday.

Fulton said he is optimistic about the upcoming meeting in Denver.

“One of the things we will be looking at is, are there ways that the existing facilities can be improved and made more efficient and less expensive to operate.

“We are very heartened that the National Park Service and the Bureau of Reclamation have agreed to host these facility discussion meetings.

“No idea is off the table.”

But Fulton said one route is a no-go: having the city pay for water facility improvements that city officials say are needed for the facilities’ long-term operation.

City officials have estimated it would cost $20 million over 20 years to maintain them.

“The city has no money to pay for any facilities, any improvements,” Fulton said.

There’s also another certainty, he said: “The city owns the property and will eventually own the facilities.”

The three industrial water users pay for the cost of the industrial water service as part of their utility rates, Fulton said Wednesday in an email.

“Hence why we are moving forward with a cost of service study for industrial water,” he wrote.

“It is the city’s intent to ensure the industrial water customers receive the quality and quantity of water they received prior to dam removal, at a reasonable cost.

“Because so much is at stake, the city has undertaken an extensive due diligence effort to fully investigate the condition of the facilities and to insist that [the National Park Service] make any repairs that are necessary to provide for reliable, cost-effective operations in the future.”

________

Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 55650, or at pgottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Port Angeles teachers’ union votes to honor paraeducators’ picket line on April 8

Members of the Port Angeles Education Association voted overwhelmingly… Continue reading

Funding needed for Port Townsend homeless shelter

Operation at Legion Hall to close April 30

Port of Port Angeles renews lease for Composite Recycling Technology Center

Agreement covers 26,000 square feet at airport business park

Fire district volunteers lauded

Clallam County Fire District No. 3 recently recognized seven members… Continue reading

Clallam to continue providing deputy to Forks

Contract includes wages, mileage and maintenance reimbursement

Maintenance closes section of Olympic Discovery Trail

A portion of the Olympic Discovery Trail is closed… Continue reading

Hanna Paoluccu of Alexander, N.Y., and Rosie Berg of Nevada City, Calif., members of the Hood Canal Salmon Enhancement Group and working with the Jefferson County Noxious Weed Board, remove poisonous hemlock weed from along the Larry Scott Trail in Port Townsend on Monday. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Poison hemlock removal in Port Townsend

Hanna Paoluccu of Alexander, N.Y., and Rosie Berg of Nevada City, Calif.,… Continue reading

YMCA to build childcare facility

$1-2M still needed for $6.7M project

Port Townsend Police Department recognizes award recipients

The Port Townsend Police Department recognized officers, employees, volunteers… Continue reading

Port Angeles High School evacuated due to bomb threat

Nothing suspicious found, principal says

A tree that has grown out of its tree box and shattered a nearby curb and sidewalk in the 100 block of North Oak Street is among those targeted for removal and replacement in downtown Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Port Angeles tree and sidewalk replacement to begin Monday

The Port Angeles downtown tree and sidewalk replacement project… Continue reading

Grant for Forks treatment plant to be discussed

The Clallam County Opportunity Fund Advisory Board will discuss… Continue reading